Johmah P

1. spell out the adoption relationship provide the adoption court records , 2 years of physical and legal custody proof at time of I-130 filing . 2. Document the family blood relationship ( child of your sibling ) birth cert and death cert for your sibling 3. Absolutely address the issue of child habitual residency .. 4. Ask USCIS to review the response to RFE and issue any clarification on further evidence if required, reaffirm the DNA testing will not establish a parental relationship and was issued in Service Error https://www.uscis.gov/adoption/immigration-through-adoption/family-based-petition-process#Children from Hague Adoption Convention Countries Thanks for share! I thought about the RFE may have been issue in error but couldn't considering all the form I-130, birth certificate, adoption and custody were provided, I couldn't imagine it was an error. I have planned to do the DNA and issue additional letter. Thanks for your input!

Yes, the child is actually, my late sibling child, which I think is irrelevant if the basis of I-130 is through legitimate adoption. I could only think about potential reasons but nothing align with immigration law.

The child has one parent and no, the child isn't an orphan.

Hahaha, thanks for sharing!

What do you mean?

The child has been in my legal/physical custody for three years before the adoption, and the child is 13 years old.

I filed an I-130 for my adoptive child, who is undocumented. The adoption was finalized in the USA. I received an RFE from USCIS requesting DNA to establish a biological relationship. I am a little confused because our relationship was established through adoption and not through a biological relationship.I clearly established that on the form 1-130 form. Does anyone know why DNA might be requested, or might it be an oversight?