sorry for the confusion, I meant one attorney said you should be filing after 5 years and 5 months (extra 5 months to cover for half the time I was out i.e 10 months) she said this might show them i have covered the extra time but doesn't know if it will make a difference and I might still be denied. As I don't have a life here, not employment, not paying rent.
others have suggested I am eligible and I shouldn't worry about the trips as they are less than 6 months. Also mentioned the CBP flagging me won't affect citizenship, it is for travel the next time I come back. They also say unemployment and not paying rent doesn't matter.
Can you please tell me what your suggestion is? should i file now in 4 years 9 months?