I would assume the Consulate would have refused the additional docs again when received the same day for not having the PCC?
They did that when I made an attempt to get one from the local police dept from my last address here in 1987.
In my hand written response I clearly stated my continuous presence in the US and cited their own guidelines for who needs a PCC. The Indian PCC requires an Indian address, which I don't have and was refused a PCC when I went to the passport office.
It's just mind boggling that the consulate wasn't able to interpret their own guidelines after reviewing my documents (US driver's license, tax returns, inquiring about my addresses, length of time in the US, 601-A waiver, USCIS work permit, etc.) and conclude that the PCC would be unobtainable and any other doc requiring statement of no criminal record from the US would be unobtainable since I'm now in India and have no way home without a Visa.