Although I sponsored these people under Biden's Humanitarian Parole program, I do agree with you that the program was very disorganized, had instances of people getting paroled through fraud, and was very short sighted in vetting the people and making sure they had actual support here in the USA. A large fault to the programs failures should be attributed to USCIS inadequacies which is not only seen with this CHNV program but is wide spread across ALL immigration paths. Not processing applications generally in order, and not using standard practices for vetting applications are two huge reasons for the failures of our agency in charge of making sure we have fair, ethical immigration pathways. USCIS needs to instantly stop the practice of processing newer cases while older cases remain untouched only to prop up their average processing times. If you aren't going to fairly process cases that arrive legally then don't be surprised when desperate people find other ways to skirt a system that isn't even following their own laws and rules.
Politics aside - I am not arguing on this forum about what should have been done but talking about real people that are personally apart of my family. I am looking to do what is best for my three people. You stated that they are not immigrants and I am asking you what are they then? These three people are foreigners who were allowed to legally come here temporarily for 2 years. It's perfectly fine if you want to think of this as a two year tourist visa they received, however I will correct you that the people I sponsored did not receive cash benefits from the government, did not receive food benefits from the government, do not receive any sort of housing stipend from the government, nor do they receive health insurance from the government. They paid roughly 500 to USCIS to apply for the authorization to work in this country, which USCIS granted 30 days after their arrival, and then they got overnight jobs at Walmart stocking shelfs because those were jobs Americans didn't want because Walmart couldn't find anyone to do that work. In the last 1.5 years they have worked full time, and have paid taxes on the money, bought cars, pay for insurance, pay for a non-subsidized apartment, and would love to buy a house this summer if they can find one. They have applied for Permanent Residency i-485 under the 1966 law titled Cuban Adjustment Act. They have satisfied all conditions of this US law and as such 2 of the 5 people I sponsored on CHNV have been approved. The other three will be approved if someone at USCIS bothers to look at their application that they submitted 10 months ago.
So if they are not immigrants what are they? Are you saying they are "non-immigrants that have legally applied for permanent residency per US law"?