The author does a poor job of keeping illegal alien remittance separate from legal alien remittance. Although he seems to be leaning on illegal alien remittance for taxation, he ends up with "tax remittances" which could mean all remittance.
So what about citizen remittance? If you are quoting total remittance figures like India 100 billion, and then breaking them down by U.S. legal status, you might have:
Citizen: 75%
Legal Alien: 15 %
Illegal Alien: 10%
Total 100%
I'm just throwing those % numbers out there. However, I live in the Philippines where remittance is an important part of the economy. Pre-pandemic, remittance was averaging 9% of Philippine GDP. For 2023, the total was 33.5 billion and 13.7 billion came from the U.S.
So how much of that came from Filipino Americans who became U.S. citizens? How much from legal aliens? How much from illegals?
While I agree illegals should not be able to just walk in and then earn money and then send it home, (and certainly not to our enemies) the author does not lay out how taxing ONLY illegal remittances would work. How do you track them? Do they have SSN? How do we even know of their tax status? Need a new branch of the IRS?
Remittance may be a small part of the incentive for illegal entry to the U.S., but taxation and bigger government is not the answer. Just keep them out the old fashioned way: SECURE THE BORDERS AND SEND THEM BACK. For most groups, sending them back will end most of the incentive to come and they will never earn any money in the U.S.
As far as double taxing U.S. citizens and legal aliens on U.S. earned and taxed income used for remittances, hogwash. The government is going to tell us what we can do with our after-tax income? Also, if that ever came about, other countries would retaliate against all the U.S. citizens who work and live overseas.
Remittance to your Filipino family is a time honored tradition for Filipinos and is a primary factor for many to go abroad, legally. Filipino culture respects and takes care of their elders, and much of this is done through remittance.
The argument that the money is not put back in the U.S. economy is not strong. Only a smaller % of income earned would be sent home. For normal people, you have to take care of your expenses first, spending it in the U.S., and send some leftover home. Of course, if you are illegal, and the government is paying for a nice hotel, food, healthcare and other things, maybe you could send almost all of it home, just saving a little bit for cigs and beer.