Now I look at it, there appear to be two options here: I-90 or the USCIS Typographic Error form.
I previously filed the I-90. When I spoke to the USCIS contact centre today, they said I should file the Typo Form. Their response was very generic (it was clear the guy was literally just reading off the screen to me), so I'm not certain their advice was right.
What do you reckon - I-90 or Typo Form? I'm leaning to I-90 even though it didn't work the first time, because really this isn't a typo - they've issued the wrong category of card.