I don't think a judge would rule against my wife either but it's better to be safe and just refile the i751. Whenever someone reviews our case they can clearly see that residing here unlawfully wasn't the intent with filing an n400 and a second i751 including the multiple tier 2 status service requests on the previous i751. Even the tier 2 officer looking at the old i751 said it wasn't denied. We have a new i751 anyway.