wrongful deportation my sister by port officer with false info while in visitor visa [merged threads]

[Boiler 46,546]

The obvious solution if you are clueless is to employ the services of an Immigration Lawyer.

 

With you unwilling to answer basic questions I am noit sure how anyone here can help, all we can do is guess.

 

It does sound like your sister is holding information from you for whatever reason.

[TBoneTX 46,647]

Hamid0101, you've been hitting the "Report Post" button instead of "Submit Reply."

You must redo each of your attempted responses.

Do not abuse the "Report" function.

 

VJ Moderation

[hamid0101 0]

my sister never worked in usa while visitor visa while POE forced her again and again to admit she worked in USA but she continuous denied and POE cancelled her visa. i think POE has some evidence ans based on that PEO cancelled her visa we would like to know what kind of evidence whereas she never worked . why we suffer which she never did 

[Boiler 46,546]

Best person to discuss this with is your Lawyer 

[hamid0101 0]

Reply this topic option was not available till yesterday so I thought report option would be good choice reply. I am really sorry for any inconvenient

 

Her visa was cancelled while she was in visitor visa yes POE continuously asked her she worked here or not. Same question again and again and my sister answered same. But question is based on which evidence PEO made decision to cancel her visa whereas she never worked here. Why we would suffer for POE un justification or how we would know based on which evidence POE believed she worked here and if POE can provide that paper we never apply again for her visa.

[hamid0101 0]

Reply this topic option was not available till yesterday so I thought report option would be good choice to  reply. I am really sorry for any inconvenient

 

Her visa was cancelled while she was in visitor visa yes POE continuously asked her she worked here or not. Same question again and again and my sister answered same. But question is based on which evidence PEO made decision to cancel her visa whereas she never worked here. Why we would suffer for POE un justification or how we would know based on which evidence POE believed she worked here and if POE can provide that paper we never apply again for her visa. And while she faced immigrant visa lately Visa office told she worked here based on previous fact also VO mentioned company name was false whereas it was legitimate in USA . we have sufficient evidence

[hamid0101 0]

Reply this topic option was not available till yesterday so I thought report option would be good choice reply. I am really sorry for any inconvenient

 

Her visa was cancelled while she was in visitor visa yes POE continuously asked her she worked here or not. Same question again and again and my sister answered same. But question is based on which evidence PEO made decision to cancel her visa whereas she never worked here. Why we would suffer for POE un justification or how we would know based on which evidence POE believed she worked here and if POE can provide that paper we never apply again for her visa. And while she faced immigrant visa lately Visa office told she worked here based on previous fact also VO mentioned company name was false whereas it was legitimate in USA . we have sufficient evidence

 

My mom applied for her immigrant Visa . and I even don’t know if daughter take care Mom it could be an red flag. We never paid anything to her to doing that.

[appleblossom 3,605]

3 hours ago, hamid0101 said:

my sister never worked in usa while visitor visa while POE forced her again and again to admit she worked in USA but she continuous denied and POE cancelled her visa. i think POE has some evidence ans based on that PEO cancelled her visa we would like to know what kind of evidence whereas she never worked . why we suffer which she never did 

 

If she said she was taking care of her Mom, that would be the evidence. She cannot do that as a visitor. I suspect that’s what happened.  But in any event, she has no right to enter as a visitor and can be refused without evidence. 

 

You still haven’t said if her immigrant visa has actually been denied, or refused (i.e. is in AP)?

[wazzujoel 92]

5 hours ago, appleblossom said:

 

If she said she was taking care of her Mom, that would be the evidence. She cannot do that as a visitor. I suspect that’s what happened.  But in any event, she has no right to enter as a visitor and can be refused without evidence. 

 

You still haven’t said if her immigrant visa has actually been denied, or refused (i.e. is in AP)?

 

For my own education here - Can you expand on "she cannot take care of her mom"? Are you saying that if an immigrant comes to the USA where their parent lives on a tourist visa, and that parent is dealing Covid for example, this person should not make them soup, help them get meds, or whatever else one might do when a loved one is sick? 

[Boiler 46,546]

1 minute ago, wazzujoel said:

 

For my own education here - Can you expand on "she cannot take care of her mom"? Are you saying that if an immigrant comes to the USA where their parent lives on a tourist visa, and that parent is dealing Covid for example, this person should not make them soup, help them get meds, or whatever else one might do when a loved one is sick? 

 

It seems she was working as a Home Carer. Not that I think we will ever get to the bottom of this.

[appleblossom 3,605]

7 minutes ago, wazzujoel said:

 

For my own education here - Can you expand on "she cannot take care of her mom"? Are you saying that if an immigrant comes to the USA where their parent lives on a tourist visa, and that parent is dealing Covid for example, this person should not make them soup, help them get meds, or whatever else one might do when a loved one is sick? 

 

Only if that’s the main reason for the visit and long term, then yes, as that is not consistent with a tourist visa. If it’s a couple of days looking after a parent if they come down with something after one arrives, then that’s different. Essentially, if it is a job that an American could be paid to do i.e. providing full-time care for an aging parent, or full-time child care for a grandchild whilst the parents work, then immigration are likely to take a dim view of that. 

[wazzujoel 92]

17 minutes ago, appleblossom said:

 

Only if that’s the main reason for the visit and long term, then yes, as that is not consistent with a tourist visa. If it’s a couple of days looking after a parent if they come down with something after one arrives, then that’s different. Essentially, if it is a job that an American could be paid to do i.e. providing full-time care for an aging parent, or full-time child care for a grandchild whilst the parents work, then immigration are likely to take a dim view of that. 

 

Oh wow! Thanks for the clarification. I would have thought the line was if they are being paid for services rendered, however interesting to know if it is something that might be someone's job then you can't "help out" simply because it's your parent. You know I feel it's human nature to want to help a family member who is struggling or hurt or sick or whatever. Can't say I'd personally fault them for that, however rules are rules and I guess that's a position USCIS can take.  

[Dashinka 25,180]

37 minutes ago, wazzujoel said:

 

Oh wow! Thanks for the clarification. I would have thought the line was if they are being paid for services rendered, however interesting to know if it is something that might be someone's job then you can't "help out" simply because it's your parent. You know I feel it's human nature to want to help a family member who is struggling or hurt or sick or whatever. Can't say I'd personally fault them for that, however rules are rules and I guess that's a position USCIS can take.  

It is all about context.  As to the OP, no one knows exactly what went on between the sister and the CBP officer, but if a question was asked about what a person's plan was when requesting entry, and the response was visiting family, taking care of my mother, or something like that, a CBP officer can imply illegal work on a visitor visa.  Now I am not suggesting that was what exactly happened, but it could have.  There was a similar story a while back with someone attempting to enter on a K1 being turned around when they were flippant about getting married after entry.  Essentially, their response was maybe I will get married, and maybe I won't.  The CBP officer turned them away.  The upshot is you have to answer the CBP officer's questions truthfully, but there is no need to add information, be flippant, or sarcastic.