Adam Walsh Act Waiver - CR1 visa

[Happy_go_lucky 0]

Hello there!

I am new to the forum but have been a quiet reader so far. Actually, it is my first time posting in any kind of forum, so I hope things will go okay and please forgive me if I make any "newbie mistakes"!  I know there have been some threads about the Adam Walsh Act Waiver already but most of them are older ones and I am hoping to find some people who are in this situation right now to maybe connect and share some information and experiences with! 

My story: I met my US boyfriend in 2012 while we were both studying for our BA degrees in the US. We started a relationship, he followed me to Germany (on a student visa)... but we broke up eventually because I felt not ready to marry him/do all the paperwork and effort it takes to either live together in the US or in Germany permanently. Fast forward to today, we re-found our love for each other, got back together, and I am finally ready to take that next step with him. He is the love of my life! We plan to marry in Germany and then file for a CR1 visa to start our life together in the US where he has just built a new house and whatnot. So far so good, right?! Well, no! I knew about his juvenile criminal record and we had talked about it during our relationship. He was open about it and told me everything. However, we did not think it would matter regarding me immigrating to the US on a family-based visa since it was a juvenile record. We were so wrong! When we first talked to an immigration lawyer about our plans she said yeah, it is a juvenile record, won't matter... but when she looked at the charges she noticed that one of them may trigger the Adam Walsh Act. It is a sensitive topic but I can say that it involved consensual sex between two teenagers (same age) who were friends at the time. The friend's mom found out about it and my boyfriend got arrested. It was argued that his friend had a mental disability and therefore was not able to give consent. My boyfriend noted that he did not know about the mental disability of his friend since it was not noticeable, he entered a plea deal and got charged. We got referred to another lawyer who knows both criminal and immigration law and just got off the meeting with him via Zoom: He grilled and intimidated us. I liked that he was upfront about the whole process and made clear it takes a lot to build a good case to possibly get a visa approved. But overall, I feel devastated. Yes, there is the possibility to move to Germany together, but due to many personal reasons living in the US together would have been our first choice.

My questions:
- Does anyone know a good lawyer besides Allan Lolly regarding Adam Walsh Act cases?
- The lawyer told us that it is impossible for my boyfriend to i.e. move to Germany and start the whole CR1-visa process from Germany including the possibility of an AWA waiver. Is that true? Do you then basically have to live separately in two countries even if you are married until a decision is being made by USCIS? I can't find it anymore but I think I read about a case on visa journey where the couple filed for the CR1 from abroad...?

Thank you so much to anyone who took the time to read my post!

[Boiler 45,584]

There have been quite a few in the past and one recently. 

 

I do know that success is unusual, obviously case details matter, charges and convictions.

 

Definitely have a plan B, very low approval rate and it is going to cost.

 

Yes he can move to Germany if they have no issue with his past.

[Happy_go_lucky 0]

Thank you so much for your reply, Boiler! Yes, the approval rates are devastatingly low and it makes you wonder whether you should actually spend 20-30k for the whole process that could take 5-10 years. Germany is a possibility.