10years Greencard received even if I entered US before 2years of marriage

[Lil bear 4,256]

12 minutes ago, OldUser said:

This was directed to @Neonred not OP

Sorry. Amended my reply ! 

[Girl-S 30]

2 hours ago, Neonred said:

This is a bit like what we went through.  My wife came on a K-1 and her (first) green card was a 10 year.  We inquired and jumped through hoops only to be told we didn't need to remove conditions.  We decided to just go with it.  There was never an issue at naturalization.

I guess thats the answer i was looking for…also, when i received green card it was almost 2years like 3days less in 2yrs and I read that sometimes they do consider that and issue a 10yr GC if its close to 2yr anniversary. 

 

[OldUser 6,970]

8 minutes ago, Girl-S said:

I guess thats the answer i was looking for…also, when i received green card it was almost 2years like 3days less in 2yrs and I read that sometimes they do consider that and issue a 10yr GC if its close to 2yr anniversary. 

 

They cannot issue 10 year GC by law if you're approved 1 day before 2 year anniversary. Often 10 year GC is issued by mistake, but it's the immigrant who typically is held liable for mistake

[Dashinka 24,634]

15 hours ago, SteveInBostonI130 said:

 

This is confusing.  I will assume that you meant your husband was an LPR and petitioned you as F2A.  If that is correct, your first GC would be for 10 years.  

 

Edit, your first GC should have been 2 years.  This is the first time I saw a situation of someone entering in less than 2yrs of marriage on F2A.

There was a period where the F2A category was current according to the visa bulletin.  So though rare, I suppose there were some folks that this impacted.

[Neonred 3,577]

8 hours ago, OldUser said:

At time of Resident Since date on her GC, were you married for 2 years or less than that?

Yes, married a few weeks when we applied and received card after about 6 or 7 months.

[Crazy Cat 41,982]

9 hours ago, Girl-S said:

I guess thats the answer i was looking for…also, when i received green card it was almost 2years like 3days less in 2yrs and I read that sometimes they do consider that and issue a 10yr GC if its close to 2yr anniversary. 

 

No, they do not.  They have no discretion to do that.

Edited November 26 by Crazy Cat

[appleblossom 2,801]

9 hours ago, Girl-S said:

I guess thats the answer i was looking for…also, when i received green card it was almost 2years like 3days less in 2yrs and I read that sometimes they do consider that and issue a 10yr GC if its close to 2yr anniversary. 

 

 

The date you received your green card isn't relevant. As you were advised back in 2019 it's the marriage length at the date of entry (i.e. the day you become a LPR) that matters. Lots of people delay their entries in to the US for that very reason. You needed to submit a I-90 and then remove conditions.

 

As suggested by others, I'd get it sorted asap before your naturalisation interview. Good luck. 

[Crazy Cat 41,982]

9 hours ago, Girl-S said:

when i received green card it was almost 2years like 3days less in 2yrs

Your timeline states:

 

Marriage: 3/11/2018

US Entry:  12/12/2019

That's about 3 months prior to 2 years of marriage.

[Melancholic Mage 115]

I'm still waiting on my green card and entered around 5 months before my 2 year anniversary. If I get a USCIS slip up 10 year green card, I'll update here. 

 

I personally think this is an error however. Your lawyer shouldn't be so flippant about your worries. It's hard to say what USCIS will do - they may just let the error slide or they may pin it on you if left unreported. I would try and contact them for clarification. 

 

What happened to others users may not fall in the same way for you. 

[Melancholic Mage 115]

Following up my last post, I received my Green Card today and it's the two years conditional as expected. So more evidence pointing to USCIS error if you have an expiry date outside your filing restrictions. 

 

Any update OP? 

[OldUser 6,970]

32 minutes ago, Melancholic Mage said:

Following up my last post, I received my Green Card today and it's the two years conditional as expected. So more evidence pointing to USCIS error if you have an expiry date outside your filing restrictions. 

 

Any update OP? 

Nice, thanks for the update here!