Would my children (under 16yrs) who have US Green Card but live in UK be able to get US passport when I get US passport?

[OmoNaijaUK 3]

On 6/11/2024 at 1:50 AM, Laure&Colin said:

 

Well, a green card as you call it is a Lawful PERMANENT Resident card so obviously not designed for temporary residence. Having your primary residence in the US is required to maintain LPR status, besides the physical presence.

From how you describe your situation it looks like you should be on a work visa (maybe a J Visa related to academic work) rather than a permanent resident. I don't know how you got LPR status for your kids, but you had to have said at some point that they lived with you in the US. I'd be very careful to apply for citizenship because the question "where are your kids" is likely to come up and you might run into problems here if the officer thinks you lied about their residence in order to obtain benefits for them that they didn't qualify for.

Your assumptions do not apply. That was not how they got Greencard. It was thru family filing and legitimate. Many people have US passport but do not live in the US. Being permanent resident doesn't mean you've got to be stuck in the US forever!

 

The question of which visa I should have is not what was asked here. It is always good and reasonable to focus on the question. Many people commenting here mostly rely on their own struggles towards acquiring Greencard and their situations do not apply to everyone. There are different legitimate routes to everything and what was applicable to you might not be applicable to others.

 

 

 

Edited June 13 by OmoNaijaUK

[OmoNaijaUK 3]

6 minutes ago, OmoNaijaUK said:

 q

 

 

Edited June 13 by OmoNaijaUK

[OmoNaijaUK 3]

 

 

It looks like many people commenting here do not know the rules themselves unlike another forum where there real immigration lawyers offering reasonable advice and possible solutions. Being permanent resident doesn't mean you've got to be stuck in the US forever and ever!

 

Many people have US passport but do not live in the US. It is a choice!

 

Many people commenting here mostly rely on their own struggles towards acquiring Greencard and their situations do not apply top everyone. Many are merely emotional about Greencard and mere visa.  There are different legitimate routes to everything and what was applicable to you might not be applicable to others.

 

I DO NOT NEED ANY FURTHER ADVICE HERE BECAUSE I HAVE GOT WHAT I WANT FROM ANOTHER FORUM (which contains knowledgeable immigration professionals).

 

Thanks everyone for your attempted helps and suggestions!

Edited June 13 by OmoNaijaUK

[Boiler 45,467]

I do not see the downside in applying.

 

I am interested in knowing what forum contains immigration professionals.

[milimelo 4,477]

I'd love to know if OP is claiming his kids on the US taxes. 

[OmoNaijaUK 3]

19 minutes ago, milimelo said:

I'd love to know if OP is claiming his kids on the US taxes. 

The tax I pay monthly is more than average American monthly salary and possibly more than your monthly wages.

Edited June 13 by OmoNaijaUK

[OmoNaijaUK 3]

26 minutes ago, milimelo said:

I'd love to know if OP is claiming his kids on the US taxes. 

The tax I pay monthly is more than average American monthly salary and most likely more than your own monthly incomes. 

Edited June 13 by OmoNaijaUK

[milimelo 4,477]

4 minutes ago, OmoNaijaUK said:

The tax I pay monthly is more than average American monthly salary and possibly more than your monthly wages.

Good to know though I doubt it. In any case, you're not really answering questions asked. But do let us know how your naturalization goes... 

[OldUser 6,633]

2 hours ago, OmoNaijaUK said:

Many people have US passport but do not live in the US. It is a choice!

You're correct about choice for US citizens. It's not a choice for LPR, as living outside the US puts this status at risk.

Edited June 13 by OldUser

[OldUser 6,633]

2 hours ago, OmoNaijaUK said:

Being permanent resident doesn't mean you've got to be stuck in the US forever and ever!

You're correct about this one too. Though it doesn't mean somebody can get spend as much time outside of the US as they wish. Few weeks / months a year is OK. However, LPR is expected to live in the US for majority of time (ideally 9+ months and definitely over 6 months). Otherwise they cannot naturalize and may lose GC.

Edited June 13 by OldUser

[Laure&Colin 558]

4 hours ago, OmoNaijaUK said:

Many people have US passport but do not live in the US. Being permanent resident doesn't mean you've got to be stuck in the US forever!

 

Of course US citizens can live wherever they want. That is not the case for permanent residents. It doesn't mean they're stuck in the US forever, but if they decide to live abroad, they de facto abandon their LPR status. It doesn't matter how it was acquired in the first place.

 

https://www.uscis.gov/green-card/after-we-grant-your-green-card/maintaining-permanent-residence

"You may also lose your permanent resident status by intentionally abandoning it, including but not limited to:

 

Moving to another country and intending to live there permanently;

Declaring yourself a “nonimmigrant” on your U.S. tax returns; or

Remaining outside of the United States for an extended period of time, unless it’s a temporary absence"

[Boiler 45,467]

4 hours ago, Conchas Chinas said:

Now we're getting as "silly as the responses" with which you have issues with.

 

Can you share the other forum that you mention. I would like to have a look.

 

Good luck with your family's naturalization. Would be good to keep us informed on how it went - if only to rub our collective noses in it  

Me Too

[R&OC 371]

No need to be rude when faced with uncomfortable feedback. As (allegedly) an academic, you are ignoring facts, data, and the experience of many. 

 

This is neither kind nor professional to throw your income into the mix. Who cares how much you or anyone else earns? Does this make one better or more competent? I didn’t think so.

 

Academia is a small world but you already know that.

 

Back to your question: When you apply for your children‘s certificate of citizenship, you will experience a more detailed investigation. Their residence in the UK will be noticed and, at this point, you may struggle to provide proof of their physical presence in the US (school transcripts etc.) I speak from experience we we just successfully went through the exact same process.

 

I would suggest, you bring your children to the US and enroll them at local schools. Delay your own N-400 until everyone is established and pursue their N-600s a few months later.
 

 

Edited June 14 by R&OC

[nastra30 2,284]

On 6/12/2024 at 8:31 PM, OmoNaijaUK said:

Being permanent resident doesn't mean you've got to be stuck in the US forever and ever!

 

Many people have US passport but do not live in the US. It is a choice!

Professor. Please don't conflate USC with LPR. Two different things.

[harry.st 62]

On 6/13/2024 at 4:19 AM, OmoNaijaUK said:

The tax I pay monthly is more than average American monthly salary and most likely more than your own monthly incomes. 

 

Flexing income here? Really? You are the personification of class, my good sir (I am sure you are trying hard to instill it on your offspring, too).