Refile i130

[Jrmorad 0]

I'm going to refile I 130 I was revoked in first case

Was the beneficiary EVER in immigration proceedings? Yes or no I didn't go to US before 

 

[Crazy Cat 41,844]

11 minutes ago, Jrmorad said:

I didn't go to US before 

 

Answer is "No"

[nastra30 2,284]

42 minutes ago, Jrmorad said:

I'm going to refile I 130 I was revoked in first case

Was the beneficiary EVER in immigration proceedings? Yes or no I didn't go to US before 

 

Why was it revoked? What did the NOIR say?

Edited March 3 by nastra30

[nastra30 2,284]

I see. Hopefully, you done things to strengthen your case.

 

[JeanneAdil 6,498]

you met in July 2021 /Have u met since then

to refile ,  u do need to meet in last 2 years

Has she spent much time with you in Egypt?

You will need to show  the 2 of you have started to commingle assets to have a strong case

like filing joint tax returns

sending her a POA so she can sign the return in your name

 

[Ryan H 3,812]

***Moved from Progress Reports to Process & Procedures***

 

**Moderator hat off**

 

OP, you said the first case was revoked.  Did you receive a Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR) and if so, did you respond to said notice that would've spelled out the issues that would've needed to be addressed?

 

If you didn't respond to the NOIR and the case was subsequently revoked, then all the issues that would've been spelled out became part of the official record that don't go away by filling a new petition.

[pushbrk 12,877]

On 3/4/2024 at 4:40 AM, JeanneAdil said:

you met in July 2021 /Have u met since then

to refile ,  u do need to meet in last 2 years

Has she spent much time with you in Egypt?

You will need to show  the 2 of you have started to commingle assets to have a strong case

like filing joint tax returns

sending her a POA so she can sign the return in your name

 

There is no requirement to have been together in person in the last two years, for a spouse case.  That's for a fiancée case.  Time together in person is important to show a bona fide relationship, surely, but no two year requirement in this context.

[JeanneAdil 6,498]

18 hours ago, pushbrk said:

There is no requirement to have been together in person in the last two years, for a spouse case.  That's for a fiancée case.  Time together in person is important to show a bona fide relationship, surely, but no two year requirement in this context.

Egypt will  require he has been with her 

after starting to talk online in 2019 the following happened

maybe not required for the type of visa but the OP decided to marry in June 2020 online without meeting her first and then they married on 1st visit in 2021 March

he has to overcome a big hurdle especially whey this embassy likes to see quality time spent together and they did not have it 

so, if they have not been together in 2022 and 2023 ,  he faces another denial 

that decision to marry without meeting first and marrying on 1st visit was part of their NOIR  ( I believe his is actually a NOID when the USC got the notice)

CO wrote "it has not been proven that petitioner and beneficary have a bona fide marriage"

 

The OP and petition also face big age difference not mentioned in the NOIR

 

[pushbrk 12,877]

4 hours ago, JeanneAdil said:

Egypt will  require he has been with her 

after starting to talk online in 2019 the following happened

maybe not required for the type of visa but the OP decided to marry in June 2020 online without meeting her first and then they married on 1st visit in 2021 March

he has to overcome a big hurdle especially whey this embassy likes to see quality time spent together and they did not have it 

so, if they have not been together in 2022 and 2023 ,  he faces another denial 

that decision to marry without meeting first and marrying on 1st visit was part of their NOIR  ( I believe his is actually a NOID when the USC got the notice)

CO wrote "it has not been proven that petitioner and beneficary have a bona fide marriage"

 

The OP and petition also face big age difference not mentioned in the NOIR

 

I agree their time together in person is critical, but your assertion of a "within two years" requirement to file an I-130 still needed to be corrected.