Rare languages a challenge for courts

[Ban Hammer 13,346]

ROCKVILLE, Md. - After three years of searching, officials finally found an interpreter available for the sexual abuse case against a Liberian man who is one of only about 100,000 people worldwide who speak Vai.

But it was too late.

A Montgomery County judge dismissed the charges against Mahamu Kanneh last month, saying problems securing Vai interpreters contributed to repeated delays that violated his right to a speedy trial.

Kanneh learned of the decision through the interpreter.

The ruling, which prompted outrage from the public in the suburban Washington county, illustrates a major challenge professional interpreters say the judicial system faces — finding people qualified to translate unfamiliar languages that are showing up more frequently in courts. It's a problem that can delay cases for long periods and, in some instances, affect the outcome.

In Arizona, a judge threatened to drop human smuggling charges against three men earlier this year because of problems locating Mayan dialect interpreters.

Authorities in Arkansas have struggled with two cases against natives of the Marshall Islands accused of killing children.

And prosecutors in Louisville, Ky., had difficulty earlier this year before finding a Bantu interpreter for a Somali man charged with killing his four children.

Interpreter organizations say it's difficult to estimate the number of cases affected by courts' inability to secure translators of obscure languages. That's because most of the cases are mundane and attract little attention. But as immigrant communities grow, it is not uncommon for cases to be affected by shortages of qualified interpreters, they said.

"The person who ends up getting hurt in this usually is the defendant," said Kevin Hendzel, a spokesman for the Virginia-based American Translators Association.

Federal law requires public agencies receiving federal money to provide equal access to people with "limited English proficiency." Most courts concluded that means interpreters should be available for all court proceedings when needed, most often at the court's expense, Hendzel said.

Interpreters often are at a defendant's side for an entire case, from an arrest through trial. Ideally, they must be able to keep a running translation of what is said, and be familiar enough with legal or other court terms to be able to convert phrases like "blood splatter" into a foreign language.

Courts often turn to agencies, lists by state judiciaries or online services to find interpreters. With hard-to-find languages, they have to cast wider nets, contacting community organizations or embassies to find people. Often interpreters must be flown in for cases.

Moving beyond the usual sources can prove unreliable. Ideally, courts will hire full-time interpreters who are certified by the state or a professional organization. But in cases involving rarer languages, some courts end up hiring people with little or no court background.

"In some cases, you're not going to find anybody who is experienced in court proceedings. They have never set foot in a court," said Isabel Framer, chair of the National Association of Judiciary Interpreters and Translators, a group representing 1,200 interpreters who speak 65 languages.

Many interpreters of rarer languages also have other jobs, meaning courts must work around their schedules.

"It's not just finding; it is seeing if they want to come, when they want to come and bringing them in," said Mara Simmons, who coordinates interpreters for the Arkansas court system.

Mayan dialects and African languages are causing some of the largest problems for courts, Framer said.

Kanneh, of Gaithersburg, was accused in 2004 of assaulting a 7-year-old girl and a 1-year-old girl, both relatives of his. The circuit clerk's office found three interpreters of Vai, spoken in Liberia and Sierra Leone, but all were unqualified or dropped out because of personal issues.

On June 17, Circuit Judge Katherine Savage reluctantly threw out the case. Prosecutors have appealed the decision.

Loretta Knight, the circuit court clerk, noted that other delays, such as a defense review of DNA, also prolonged the case. Her office searched broadly for speakers of Vai, even contacting the Liberian embassy. Knight says her office usually succeeds in finding interpreters for an average of 300 cases per month.

"It is a full-time job and we are struggling with it, but we are doing an excellent job," she said.

Still, Hendzel said the Maryland case also shows that courts often don't use all the resources available, such as databases maintained by groups like the American Translators Association. Shortly after the Kanneh case was dropped, the association found three Vai interpreters for a government client.

Interpreters say the problem will only likely grow as immigrant communities swell.

"We just can't create enough good interpreters," said Hailu Gtsadek, a translator who runs an African language interpreter service in Washington.

link

[JoeMama 0]

Think maybe learning English should be mandatory now?

[Hilarious Clinton 452]

Think maybe learning English should be mandatory now?

I'm convinced.

[Cassandra+Yuibi 0]

Think maybe learning English should be mandatory now?

Agreed.

[Caladan 19]

Unfortunately, chances are that even learning English well enough for every day, the person would still need an intepreter in a court situation (or, say, in a consulate interview situation.) There's no English requirement for permanent residency, and even if there were, it's unlikely that the bar would be high enough to secure a defendant's rights.

[Dan J 277]

Unfortunately, chances are that even learning English well enough for every day, the person would still need an intepreter in a court situation (or, say, in a consulate interview situation.) There's no English requirement for permanent residency, and even if there were, it's unlikely that the bar would be high enough to secure a defendant's rights.

Nor is there any English requirement for most visas to the US. Making everyone learn English does little to solve this problem.

[Jason-Sasha 1]

This rapist spoke English enough to attend school here and then College here. His English is fine. Its just another cop-out excuse to tangle the system. Thanks O.J. for paving the way for criminals to walk free for BS excuses. My Glove doesnt fit, my English is poor. Boo hoo. Go straight to jail, do not pass go! Mandatory? I totally agree. You shouldn't even be cosidered for residency unless you have some grasp of the language. Just my opinion. And bilingual signs? Not in my backyard. I wouldnt even attemp living in a foreign land unless I could speak the language. Maybe its respect or maybe just consideration. Two words....Rosetta Stone.

[Caladan 19]

I missed where it said he attended college here. But speaking as someone in a very international student community the level of English required to do, say, major mathematics at a top university and the English required to understand legal terms is very different.

They offer interviews at the consulates in the fiancees home language, right? Just to make sure everything's understood? Why would a criminal case be less important than whether someone gets to come to the U.S.?

[Ladylethal 12]

You can't make English mandatory to tourists, and tourists also may end up in court.