N600 certificate of citizenship

[Bledi 0]

I am a us citizen and my wife and 3 years old son came with IR2 visa. After receiving green card I applied for his us passport and  received it . Now I applied for certificate of citizenship N600 form and after 3 months received a RFE :

Submit proof of your residence in the U.S. for you and your USC parent from November 30,
2022 to Present.

Evidence may include, but is not limited to, the following:
IRS tax return transcript or federal tax returns,
Rent or mortgage payments,
Utility bills,
School_Records, or
Other relevant documentation.

 

I have federal tax returns which shows my son as dependent and my usa address but I don't have rent or utility bills . I don't have any other documents with the address in his name except state Id. 

Should only tax returns be enough? 

If anyone could help it would be much appreciated 

[Lil bear 4,258]

3 minutes ago, Bledi said:

I am a us citizen and my wife and 3 years old son came with IR2 visa. After receiving green card I applied for his us passport and  received it . Now I applied for certificate of citizenship N600 form and after 3 months received a RFE :

Submit proof of your residence in the U.S. for you and your USC parent from November 30,
2022 to Present.

Evidence may include, but is not limited to, the following:
IRS tax return transcript or federal tax returns,
Rent or mortgage payments,
Utility bills,
School_Records, or
Other relevant documentation.

 

I have federal tax returns which shows my son as dependent and my usa address but I don't have rent or utility bills . I don't have any other documents with the address in his name except state Id. 

Should only tax returns be enough? 

If anyone could help it would be much appreciated 

You can only supply what you have. Any vaccination records.. health records of visits to DR , urgent care etc? Listed on your health insurance ? 

[SalishSea 17,970]

49 minutes ago, Bledi said:

I am a us citizen and my wife and 3 years old son came with IR2 visa. After receiving green card I applied for his us passport and  received it . Now I applied for certificate of citizenship N600 form and after 3 months received a RFE :

Submit proof of your residence in the U.S. for you and your USC parent from November 30,
2022 to Present.

Evidence may include, but is not limited to, the following:
IRS tax return transcript or federal tax returns,
Rent or mortgage payments,
Utility bills,
School_Records, or
Other relevant documentation.

 

I have federal tax returns which shows my son as dependent and my usa address but I don't have rent or utility bills . I don't have any other documents with the address in his name except state Id. 

Should only tax returns be enough? 

If anyone could help it would be much appreciated 

Tax returns are not evidence of being physically present in the US, so, no.

 

Have you been in the US since the date specified?

 

If so, you should have your son’s vaccination and medical records.

 

How is it possible that you have no bills in your name, coming to your address?

 

And since he has his US passport, why the need for the N-600?

Edited October 9, 2023 by SalishSea

[JeanneAdil 6,581]

proof of resdency like parent's state DL,  bank account statement 

copy of his birth certificate with parent's name

his passport page(s) showing date of entry to USA

copy of your natrualization or US birth 

[Bledi 0]

58 minutes ago, Bledi said:

I am a us citizen and my wife and 3 years old son came with IR2 visa. After receiving green card I applied for his us passport and  received it . Now I applied for certificate of citizenship N600 form and after 3 months received a RFE :

Submit proof of your residence in the U.S. for you and your USC parent from November 30,
2022 to Present.

Evidence may include, but is not limited to, the following:
IRS tax return transcript or federal tax returns,
Rent or mortgage payments,
Utility bills,
School_Records, or
Other relevant documentation.

 

I have federal tax returns which shows my son as dependent and my usa address but I don't have rent or utility bills . I don't have any other documents with the address in his name except state Id. 

Should only tax returns be enough? 

If anyone could help it would be much appreciated 

 

1 hour ago, Bledi said:

I am a us citizen and my wife and 3 years old son came with IR2 visa. After receiving green card I applied for his us passport and  received it . Now I applied for certificate of citizenship N600 form and after 3 months received a RFE :

Submit proof of your residence in the U.S. for you and your USC parent from November 30,
2022 to Present.

Evidence may include, but is not limited to, the following:
IRS tax return transcript or federal tax returns,
Rent or mortgage payments,
Utility bills,
School_Records, or
Other relevant documentation.

 

I have federal tax returns which shows my son as dependent and my usa address but I don't have rent or utility bills . I don't have any other documents with the address in his name except state Id. 

Should only tax returns be enough? 

If anyone could help it would be much appreciated 

 

56 minutes ago, Lil bear said:

You can only supply what you have. Any vaccination records.. health records of visits to DR , urgent care etc? Listed on your health insurance ? 

None of them , vaccines already done in country of origin and no need for visits to DR . I have him in my health insurance ,should I ask them to give me any statement ? Thank you for your help!

[Ontarkie 14,304]

~~moved to US Citizenship General Discussion, from Bring Family of PR- the topic of N600 is discussed here.~~

Edited October 9, 2023 by Ontarkie

[SalishSea 17,970]

33 minutes ago, Bledi said:

 

 

None of them , vaccines already done in country of origin and no need for visits to DR . I have him in my health insurance ,should I ask them to give me any statement ? Thank you for your help!

So you’ve been here for nearly a year, and your toddler hasn’t established medical care with a doctor?

[JeanneAdil 6,581]

14 hours ago, SalishSea said:

So you’ve been here for nearly a year, and your toddler hasn’t established medical care with a doctor?

yeah,  u should also have a health care notice where u added him to your plan with the date after child's arrival (which would follow his immigration stamp)

[R&OC 371]

The reason why they are asking this, is because on the day of your naturalisation your child became a US citizen as well if said child was a LPR at the time of your naturalization, in the US, with you having legal and physical custody. It seems USCIS is struggling to determine if your child was with you and in your custody at the time.

[Paul Hanaki 72]

On 10/9/2023 at 5:49 PM, SalishSea said:

 

And since he has his US passport, why the need for the N-600?

Passports are issued by the state department. N600 is issued by immigration. The N600 is better proof of citizenship plus the kid doesn't need to keep renewing the passport. 

[SalishSea 17,970]

9 minutes ago, Paul Hanaki said:

Passports are issued by the state department. N600 is issued by immigration. The N600 is better proof of citizenship plus the kid doesn't need to keep renewing the passport. 

But in what instance would an N-600 trump a U.S. passport when it comes to evidence of citizenship?

[Paul Hanaki 72]

4 minutes ago, SalishSea said:

But in what instance would an N-600 trump a U.S. passport when it comes to evidence of citizenship?

Some government jobs with certain security levels require the N-600. Someone has posted about that before. . Also your passport can't be expired to be used as identification. In certain cases even though the person had a passport they were ruled not to be citizens due to the passport being issued in error. I have not found any case that has happened with a N-600,