VAWA, Part 26

[Amy wang 4]

Help: My daughter and I submitted 360 at the same time in 2018. My 360 approval date was December 3, 2019, and my daughter’s 360 approval date was December 15, 2019, 12 days later than me. There was a problem when we submitted the 485: my daughter’s 485 approval date was April 20, 2023, and my 485 approval date was May 7, 2023. My daughter was approved before me. A lawyer said that my daughter's green card is invalid because she must wait for my green card to be approved before her green card is legal. The lawyer suggested that I return my daughter's green card to the immigration office, otherwise she will not be able to naturalize in the future. Does anyone know anything about this situation? Please guide me what should I do? Thanks 🙏

 

[OldUser 6,639]

13 minutes ago, Amy wang said:

Help: My daughter and I submitted 360 at the same time in 2018. My 360 approval date was December 3, 2019, and my daughter’s 360 approval date was December 15, 2019, 12 days later than me. There was a problem when we submitted the 485: my daughter’s 485 approval date was April 20, 2023, and my 485 approval date was May 7, 2023. My daughter was approved before me. A lawyer said that my daughter's green card is invalid because she must wait for my green card to be approved before her green card is legal. The lawyer suggested that I return my daughter's green card to the immigration office, otherwise she will not be able to naturalize in the future. Does anyone know anything about this situation? Please guide me what should I do? Thanks 🙏

 

What about resident since dates on your GC vs daughter's?

[Family 3,988]

2 hours ago, Hope21 said:

I will definitely consult some other lawyers. I will post here, what they will tell me . Thank you for your help I will push them to do it . I also have seen here some members got terminated their removal with Vawa approvals notice . I might have done if they asked to terminate my removal with approval notice.  I paid them fully so they are trying to creat another paths to get more money I guess .

There is only one path as outlined. A great deal of what your attorney emailed is pure bs . ..but “sounds “reasonable 

You can resolve things with your attorney ( without conflict) by showing them you now understand the process AND insist filing the motion ( terminate/recalender) w court is the next immediate step you want them to take. If they agree , you are all set
Ask for a copy of the motion .

[Amy wang 4]

Sorry, I didn't understand your question. Can you explain your question in detail? Sorry, I didn't understand

2 hours ago, OldUser said:

What about resident since dates on your GC vs daughter's?

Sorry, I didn't understand your question. Can you explain your question in detail? Sorry, I didn't understand

[OldUser 6,639]

6 minutes ago, Amy wang said:

Sorry, I didn't understand your question. Can you explain your question in detail? Sorry, I didn't understand

Sorry, I didn't understand your question. Can you explain your question in detail? Sorry, I didn't understand

When does your GC start (Resident Since) and when does it start for daughter?

[777_777 15]

3 hours ago, balo101 said:

That is strange. What is status of your i-360 right now?

On April 14, 2022, we received your response to our Request for Evidence for your Form I-360

[Amy wang 4]

24 minutes ago, OldUser said:

When does your GC start (Resident Since) and when does it start for daughter?

The date on my green card is May 7, 2023, and the date on my daughter’s green card is April 20, 2023.

[Family 3,988]

3 hours ago, Amy wang said:

Help: My daughter and I submitted 360 at the same time in 2018. My 360 approval date was December 3, 2019, and my daughter’s 360 approval date was December 15, 2019, 12 days later than me. There was a problem when we submitted the 485: my daughter’s 485 approval date was April 20, 2023, and my 485 approval date was May 7, 2023. My daughter was approved before me. A lawyer said that my daughter's green card is invalid because she must wait for my green card to be approved before her green card is legal. The lawyer suggested that I return my daughter's green card to the immigration office, otherwise she will not be able to naturalize in the future. Does anyone know anything about this situation? Please guide me what should I do? Thanks 🙏

 

Attorney is wrong and making you worry needlessly.

Each of you submitted a stand-alone I-360 …so the sequence of I-485 does not matter.  

[Family 3,988]

3 minutes ago, Amy wang said:

Do you think my daughter’s green card should be returned to USCIS? She followed my marriage and applied for 360 alone. Her 360 approval date was after mine, but her green card approval date was before mine. I heard that this is an invalid green card and she will be found to be an invalid green card when she naturalizes in the future.
 

Your daughter does not need to return her card. Advice you received is very wrong and very skewed…ho

She was a principal in her own I-360 , not a derivative of yours. Does nor matter same abuser .

[Amy wang 4]

7 minutes ago, Family said:

Your daughter does not need to return her card. Advice you received is very wrong and very skewed…ho

She was a principal in her own I-360 , not a derivative of yours. Does nor matter same abuser .

Thank you very much for your answer! I was almost scared to death of the lawyer, thank you!
 

[Family 3,988]

6 minutes ago, Amy wang said:

Are you saying that since my daughter’s green card is dated before mine, it is valid, and when she naturalizes in the future, my daughter’s green card will not be deemed invalid, right?
 

I am saying that because she had her own I-360 the date on her green card IS NOT tied to/ dependent on yours…so no matter if before your date.

She will have no problem naturalizing . 
You did a good job by filing a separate I-360 for her..as it guaranteed her process independent of yours.

[balo101 669]

1 hour ago, 777_777 said:

On April 14, 2022, we received your response to our Request for Evidence for your Form I-360

Then i would say return that to USCIS that has your i-360 receipt number. It must be a mistake from their end. 

[Verrou 1,962]

5 hours ago, Hope21 said:

I will definitely consult some other lawyers. I will post here, what they will tell me . Thank you for your help I will push them to do it . I also have seen here some members got terminated their removal with Vawa approvals notice . I might have done if they asked to terminate my removal with approval notice.  I paid them fully so they are trying to creat another paths to get more money I guess .

I called 70 lawyers in 2 months so I can fire my unmotivated lawyer at that time. Almost pulled the trigger to hire a new lawyer but in the meantime once a week I keep sending email to my current lawyer. He can’t stand it after 8-9 months ghosting me finally he gave up because of my persistent and filed termination to the court.

 

always have ur eggs in many basket. @Family know I even wrote motion to terminate in 4 versions just in case everything didn’t go through 

Edited September 17, 2023 by Verrou

[Amy wang 4]

3 hours ago, Family said:

I am saying that because she had her own I-360 the date on her green card IS NOT tied to/ dependent on yours…so no matter if before your date.

She will have no problem naturalizing . 
You did a good job by filing a separate I-360 for her..as it guaranteed her process independent of yours.

Thank you very much for your answer, I am not afraid anymore. Thank you!!

[Verrou 1,962]

15 hours ago, Hope21 said:

Hi again , it was initially submitted to TX Irwin and we got rejected from there but I found also expired form on my file ,after that th attorney called me and she said we are going to send it to another office. Which was nebraska . They rejected cuz of no active hearing I believe so . I don’t know if I’m going to get approved it will be really luck . 

This is BS. It doesn’t make sense at all