i-751 divorce petition - updated to "request for additional evidence"

[God is a good God 238]

5 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

I received the rfe.

They asked me the specific question the following :

my paystub change the status from single to married and then single. Asked me why I keep changing the status.

 

i just changed the status because my company filed me wrong status, so i changed it from single and then married. However, i heard that status is not matter.i heard that both status are married on paycheck, i had to pay alot of tax amount when i submit the tax return.

My roommate made contract for 2 bed and 2 bath condo and I made the contract with roommate. My wife joined after marriage but she back and fourth few month because of hee school. However, i messed up I found out that i wrote the different year on roommate agreement and i-751 form. That was my mistake. How can i explain this matter. They also asked me why my spouse changed the address on credit card statement for only one month. I dont know she did it. In my opinion, she just used alot of credit card payment, so she just changed it in my opinion. I just know it after they send me the rfe. Moreover, I joined her verizon account but i didnt think about changing the name. However, in the later i realized that someone see my wife name and I realized that i need to change it. However, this is also only one month on my name. I dont know why this is changed on verizon bills..

They asked me lots of specific questions on rfe.

Write a detailed personal declaration from how you met, courtship, engament, marriage, abuse, divorce with specific dates (recommended) if you can. In that personal declaration include your explanation of any single thing the mention in your rfe(Point by point and in detail). Support any defense argument with proof.  Each response must have a reference to its proof in annex. You’ll be fine

[POLLI2832 2]

21 hours ago, God is a good God said:

Write a detailed personal declaration from how you met, courtship, engament, marriage, abuse, divorce with specific dates (recommended) if you can. In that personal declaration include your explanation of any single thing the mention in your rfe(Point by point and in detail). Support any defense argument with proof.  Each response must have a reference to its proof in annex. You’ll be fine

Thank you for your answer.

I can explain that they mention in my RFE , but I don’t have proof. What do I do? TT

[Villanelle 4,122]

Evidence or proof comes in many forms. Sometimes they ask for things you have but didn't send, like all pages of bank statements. If that was the case you would simply send them. But what if they don't exist? That you didn't send bank statements because you didn't have a bank account? Are you simply out of luck? No! You send a statement stating you had no account and evidences of how you paid for things without one.

 

Im sure you're familiar with the concept of circumstantial evidence. So try to think of it that way. Your statement is the main evidence and you will back it up with as much circumstantial evidence as you can. 

 

If you want additional advice on your response before you submit it you can post it here. Just edit it to block personal details or you can copy paste just the relevant bits you want input on.  

[God is a good God 238]

13 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

Thank you for your answer.

I can explain that they mention in my RFE , but I don’t have proof. What do I do? TT

Any point they mentioned if you don’t have proof, just explain that point why you don’t have proof and hope it works

[POLLI2832 2]

On 7/16/2022 at 3:44 AM, Dashinka said:

No need to give up your case at this point.  Wait for the RFE and see what USCIS is requesting.  Btw, no difference between request for additional evidence and request for evidence.

 

Good Luck, and let us know what USCIS is looking for.

Hello,

 

I just share what they wanted to explain.

 

1. they asked me that my paystub status was single and goes to married and go back to single. they think it is inconsistent.

 - > my wife filed married 2 on her w-9 and mine was married 3, but my first job manager withhold single and i asked them to change it to married that I gave to them. However, I knew that it is withholding status. If wife withhold married 2 and my paystub withhold married 3, we need to pay lots of pay when we submitted the tax return. I dont know what document do i need to prove.

 

2. they asked me that our phone bill is under her name. However, it goes to change my name on my number and go back to her name again (caller id and bill statement)

-> I dont know what I need to answer. I just transfer my number to her account , but I realized that I called to my friend and I realized that my caller id was my wife name when I call to someone. I chat with verizion that the reason why my phone show my wife name. That was why they chagned my caller ID. Account owner was my wife. However, I bring the non verizon device they didn't recognized my phone. THus, they tried to change the sim card and we had the apple watch 3G and paid the device payment as well as unlimited plan. she didn't use the apple watch, so I used her watch, but I need to connect it to my number. They didn't transfer it to my number because we didn't pay it off in full. They used the unnormal trick to connect it to my number. I think at that time my caller ID became the reset.. I dont know why exact reason why caller ID (bill statement) for my number changed back to her name again. 

 

3. they mentioned that one of the credit card statement address is in SF (all statement is in LA, SF is her grandmother place)

-> Actually my wife was changed mind easily, but I realized that one of credit card statement address is in SF after they mentioned and asked to me. we used the joint account, but I didn't have the social at that time. she made the credit card and I was authorized user. we have differenet financial habit. I Treid to save the moeny for purchasing car, but she kept purchasing food or coffee to coworker. Even though our income is not enough. ( I get 2500 per month, and she was part timer. However she always resigned from her work place) we had alot of argue at that time. That was why she might hide statement from me. that was why she changed the address to her grand mother place. I dont know what proof. I need to give to them.

 

4. discrepancies for date on roommate agreement.

I lived in 2 bed and 2 bath apartment ( my roommate was original contractor with landlord). in the beginning she attended the school in SF and i was student in LA. That is why we back and fourth from la to SF. I visited their grandmother and uncle place. she decided to withdraw her school and came to LA. However, roommate agreement date my roommate put wrong year on the agreement.. 

they asked me the lease agreement.  we just kept staying in that place because we want to save the money for the future. and we have some mind to go SF if I get the better job in SF. Moreover, we didn't pay utility because my roommate was single mom with two kids. They paid all utility. we paid the rent to my roommate.

I dont know how to explain. I have contacted with previous roommate, but she changed the number one month ago. I dont know why.

 

5. they asked me that I singed up the christian mutual med aid for avoiding penalty for not having insurance. However, it is not insurance, but it is certified from goverment to waive the penalty when we submitted the tax return. However, they mentioned it is not the insurance. they asked me health insurance.

-> I treid to get the job who provided the health insurance for me and wife, but it was little harder for me even though I kept applying. My previous company didn't provided the insurance. she kept using medical , but I knew that green card applicant get negative effect if I use the public charge (such as medicals ebt). I didn't sign up the medical because I knew that I can;'t use public charge. Moreover, I just endure when I had the pain. we just singed up the CMM for avoiding penalty, but they also have the level and provided the benefit if we are sick.

 

6. I also provided the gift receipt and receipt for hospital bills for her sickness. She only know me in LA. 

She bring document and went to Canada. ( she is dual citizen and parent live in canada) I dont have that much document I can show under both name. 

 

etc.

 

They asked me alot of question, but I dont know why.. I dont know how to explain and provide the evidence. It was all my fault. if I found the better job and we can get the place under our name and had more evidence for our self like utility. I never think it will be problem and I will go to separated with wife.

 

we purchase the car with loan for 6 year and 0% interest. it still under our name, but she didn't have the drive licecnse..

 

I gave the 3 affidavit when I filed the 751. I will give my mom's letter and my other best firend letter from korea.

 

My lawyer is not helpful for me..

Please help me and advice for me 

Hello,

 

I just share what they wanted to explain.

 

1. they asked me that my paystub status was single and goes to married and go back to single. they think it is inconsistent.

 - > my wife filed married 2 on her w-9 and mine was married 3, but my first job manager withhold single and i asked them to change it to married that I gave to them. However, I knew that it is withholding status. If wife withhold married 2 and my paystub withhold married 3, we need to pay lots of pay when we submitted the tax return. I dont know what document do i need to prove.

 

2. they asked me that our phone bill is under her name. However, it goes to change my name on my number and go back to her name again (caller id and bill statement)

-> I dont know what I need to answer. I just transfer my number to her account , but I realized that I called to my friend and I realized that my caller id was my wife name when I call to someone. I chat with verizion that the reason why my phone show my wife name. That was why they chagned my caller ID. Account owner was my wife. However, I bring the non verizon device they didn't recognized my phone. THus, they tried to change the sim card and we had the apple watch 3G and paid the device payment as well as unlimited plan. she didn't use the apple watch, so I used her watch, but I need to connect it to my number. They didn't transfer it to my number because we didn't pay it off in full. They used the unnormal trick to connect it to my number. I think at that time my caller ID became the reset.. I dont know why exact reason why caller ID (bill statement) for my number changed back to her name again. 

 

3. they mentioned that one of the credit card statement address is in SF (all statement is in LA, SF is her grandmother place)

-> Actually my wife was changed mind easily, but I realized that one of credit card statement address is in SF after they mentioned and asked to me. we used the joint account, but I didn't have the social at that time. she made the credit card and I was authorized user. we have differenet financial habit. I Treid to save the moeny for purchasing car, but she kept purchasing food or coffee to coworker. Even though our income is not enough. ( I get 2500 per month, and she was part timer. However she always resigned from her work place) we had alot of argue at that time. That was why she might hide statement from me. that was why she changed the address to her grand mother place. I dont know what proof. I need to give to them.

 

4. discrepancies for date on roommate agreement.

I lived in 2 bed and 2 bath apartment ( my roommate was original contractor with landlord). in the beginning she attended the school in SF and i was student in LA. That is why we back and fourth from la to SF. I visited their grandmother and uncle place. she decided to withdraw her school and came to LA. However, roommate agreement date my roommate put wrong year on the agreement.. 

they asked me the lease agreement.  we just kept staying in that place because we want to save the money for the future. and we have some mind to go SF if I get the better job in SF. Moreover, we didn't pay utility because my roommate was single mom with two kids. They paid all utility. we paid the rent to my roommate.

I dont know how to explain. I have contacted with previous roommate, but she changed the number one month ago. I dont know why.

 

5. they asked me that I singed up the christian mutual med aid for avoiding penalty for not having insurance. However, it is not insurance, but it is certified from goverment to waive the penalty when we submitted the tax return. However, they mentioned it is not the insurance. they asked me health insurance.

-> I treid to get the job who provided the health insurance for me and wife, but it was little harder for me even though I kept applying. My previous company didn't provided the insurance. she kept using medical , but I knew that green card applicant get negative effect if I use the public charge (such as medicals ebt). I didn't sign up the medical because I knew that I can;'t use public charge. Moreover, I just endure when I had the pain. we just singed up the CMM for avoiding penalty, but they also have the level and provided the benefit if we are sick.

 

6. I also provided the gift receipt and receipt for hospital bills for her sickness. She only know me in LA. 

She bring document and went to Canada. ( she is dual citizen and parent live in canada) I dont have that much document I can show under both name. 

 

etc.

 

They asked me alot of question, but I dont know why.. I dont know how to explain and provide the evidence. It was all my fault. if I found the better job and we can get the place under our name and had more evidence for our self like utility. I never think it will be problem and I will go to separated with wife.

 

we purchase the car with loan for 6 year and 0% interest. it still under our name, but she didn't have the drive licecnse..

 

I gave the 3 affidavit when I filed the 751. I will give my mom's letter and my other best firend letter from korea.

 

My lawyer is not helpful for me..

Please help me and advice for me 

On 7/23/2022 at 12:37 PM, God is a good God said:

Any point they mentioned if you don’t have proof, just explain that point why you don’t have proof and hope it works

 

On 7/23/2022 at 7:22 AM, Villanelle said:

Evidence or proof comes in many forms. Sometimes they ask for things you have but didn't send, like all pages of bank statements. If that was the case you would simply send them. But what if they don't exist? That you didn't send bank statements because you didn't have a bank account? Are you simply out of luck? No! You send a statement stating you had no account and evidences of how you paid for things without one.

 

Im sure you're familiar with the concept of circumstantial evidence. So try to think of it that way. Your statement is the main evidence and you will back it up with as much circumstantial evidence as you can. 

 

If you want additional advice on your response before you submit it you can post it here. Just edit it to block personal details or you can copy paste just the relevant bits you want input on.  

Hello,

 

I just share what they wanted to explain.

 

1. they asked me that my paystub status was single and goes to married and go back to single. they think it is inconsistent.

 - > my wife filed married 2 on her w-9 and mine was married 3, but my first job manager withhold single and i asked them to change it to married that I gave to them. However, I knew that it is withholding status. If wife withhold married 2 and my paystub withhold married 3, we need to pay lots of pay when we submitted the tax return. I dont know what document do i need to prove.

 

2. they asked me that our phone bill is under her name. However, it goes to change my name on my number and go back to her name again (caller id and bill statement)

-> I dont know what I need to answer. I just transfer my number to her account , but I realized that I called to my friend and I realized that my caller id was my wife name when I call to someone. I chat with verizion that the reason why my phone show my wife name. That was why they chagned my caller ID. Account owner was my wife. However, I bring the non verizon device they didn't recognized my phone. THus, they tried to change the sim card and we had the apple watch 3G and paid the device payment as well as unlimited plan. she didn't use the apple watch, so I used her watch, but I need to connect it to my number. They didn't transfer it to my number because we didn't pay it off in full. They used the unnormal trick to connect it to my number. I think at that time my caller ID became the reset.. I dont know why exact reason why caller ID (bill statement) for my number changed back to her name again. 

 

3. they mentioned that one of the credit card statement address is in SF (all statement is in LA, SF is her grandmother place)

-> Actually my wife was changed mind easily, but I realized that one of credit card statement address is in SF after they mentioned and asked to me. we used the joint account, but I didn't have the social at that time. she made the credit card and I was authorized user. we have differenet financial habit. I Treid to save the moeny for purchasing car, but she kept purchasing food or coffee to coworker. Even though our income is not enough. ( I get 2500 per month, and she was part timer. However she always resigned from her work place) we had alot of argue at that time. That was why she might hide statement from me. that was why she changed the address to her grand mother place. I dont know what proof. I need to give to them.

 

4. discrepancies for date on roommate agreement.

I lived in 2 bed and 2 bath apartment ( my roommate was original contractor with landlord). in the beginning she attended the school in SF and i was student in LA. That is why we back and fourth from la to SF. I visited their grandmother and uncle place. she decided to withdraw her school and came to LA. However, roommate agreement date my roommate put wrong year on the agreement.. 

they asked me the lease agreement.  we just kept staying in that place because we want to save the money for the future. and we have some mind to go SF if I get the better job in SF. Moreover, we didn't pay utility because my roommate was single mom with two kids. They paid all utility. we paid the rent to my roommate.

I dont know how to explain. I have contacted with previous roommate, but she changed the number one month ago. I dont know why.

 

5. they asked me that I singed up the christian mutual med aid for avoiding penalty for not having insurance. However, it is not insurance, but it is certified from goverment to waive the penalty when we submitted the tax return. However, they mentioned it is not the insurance. they asked me health insurance.

-> I treid to get the job who provided the health insurance for me and wife, but it was little harder for me even though I kept applying. My previous company didn't provided the insurance. she kept using medical , but I knew that green card applicant get negative effect if I use the public charge (such as medicals ebt). I didn't sign up the medical because I knew that I can;'t use public charge. Moreover, I just endure when I had the pain. we just singed up the CMM for avoiding penalty, but they also have the level and provided the benefit if we are sick.

 

6. I also provided the gift receipt and receipt for hospital bills for her sickness. She only know me in LA. 

She bring document and went to Canada. ( she is dual citizen and parent live in canada) I dont have that much document I can show under both name. 

 

etc.

 

They asked me alot of question, but I dont know why.. I dont know how to explain and provide the evidence. It was all my fault. if I found the better job and we can get the place under our name and had more evidence for our self like utility. I never think it will be problem and I will go to separated with wife.

 

we purchase the car with loan for 6 year and 0% interest. it still under our name, but she didn't have the drive licecnse..

 

I gave the 3 affidavit when I filed the 751. I will give my mom's letter and my other best firend letter from korea.

 

My lawyer is not helpful for me..

Please help me and advice for me 

[POLLI2832 2]

On 7/17/2022 at 1:32 AM, Rocio0010 said:

First of all, sorry that your lawyer screwed up. Based on your previous post, your lawyer left out information about your ex. Most likely the RFE is about that, but there’s no point in counting the eggs before they hatch. What I would do on Monday is to fire that attorney and request a compensation for malpractice. What they did is a rookie mistake that’s now costing you stress and time. You don’t need an attorney to proceed. Once you get the RFE, post it here (leave out personal info) and we’ll help you.

And no, why would you give up your case?

Hello,

 

I just share what they wanted to explain.

 

1. they asked me that my paystub status was single and goes to married and go back to single. they think it is inconsistent.

 - > my wife filed married 2 on her w-9 and mine was married 3, but my first job manager withhold single and i asked them to change it to married that I gave to them. However, I knew that it is withholding status. If wife withhold married 2 and my paystub withhold married 3, we need to pay lots of pay when we submitted the tax return. I dont know what document do i need to prove.

 

2. they asked me that our phone bill is under her name. However, it goes to change my name on my number and go back to her name again (caller id and bill statement)

-> I dont know what I need to answer. I just transfer my number to her account , but I realized that I called to my friend and I realized that my caller id was my wife name when I call to someone. I chat with verizion that the reason why my phone show my wife name. That was why they chagned my caller ID. Account owner was my wife. However, I bring the non verizon device they didn't recognized my phone. THus, they tried to change the sim card and we had the apple watch 3G and paid the device payment as well as unlimited plan. she didn't use the apple watch, so I used her watch, but I need to connect it to my number. They didn't transfer it to my number because we didn't pay it off in full. They used the unnormal trick to connect it to my number. I think at that time my caller ID became the reset.. I dont know why exact reason why caller ID (bill statement) for my number changed back to her name again. 

 

3. they mentioned that one of the credit card statement address is in SF (all statement is in LA, SF is her grandmother place)

-> Actually my wife was changed mind easily, but I realized that one of credit card statement address is in SF after they mentioned and asked to me. we used the joint account, but I didn't have the social at that time. she made the credit card and I was authorized user. we have differenet financial habit. I Treid to save the moeny for purchasing car, but she kept purchasing food or coffee to coworker. Even though our income is not enough. ( I get 2500 per month, and she was part timer. However she always resigned from her work place) we had alot of argue at that time. That was why she might hide statement from me. that was why she changed the address to her grand mother place. I dont know what proof. I need to give to them.

 

4. discrepancies for date on roommate agreement.

I lived in 2 bed and 2 bath apartment ( my roommate was original contractor with landlord). in the beginning she attended the school in SF and i was student in LA. That is why we back and fourth from la to SF. I visited their grandmother and uncle place. she decided to withdraw her school and came to LA. However, roommate agreement date my roommate put wrong year on the agreement.. 

they asked me the lease agreement.  we just kept staying in that place because we want to save the money for the future. and we have some mind to go SF if I get the better job in SF. Moreover, we didn't pay utility because my roommate was single mom with two kids. They paid all utility. we paid the rent to my roommate.

I dont know how to explain. I have contacted with previous roommate, but she changed the number one month ago. I dont know why.

 

5. they asked me that I singed up the christian mutual med aid for avoiding penalty for not having insurance. However, it is not insurance, but it is certified from goverment to waive the penalty when we submitted the tax return. However, they mentioned it is not the insurance. they asked me health insurance.

-> I treid to get the job who provided the health insurance for me and wife, but it was little harder for me even though I kept applying. My previous company didn't provided the insurance. she kept using medical , but I knew that green card applicant get negative effect if I use the public charge (such as medicals ebt). I didn't sign up the medical because I knew that I can;'t use public charge. Moreover, I just endure when I had the pain. we just singed up the CMM for avoiding penalty, but they also have the level and provided the benefit if we are sick.

 

6. I also provided the gift receipt and receipt for hospital bills for her sickness. She only know me in LA. 

She bring document and went to Canada. ( she is dual citizen and parent live in canada) I dont have that much document I can show under both name. 

 

etc.

 

They asked me alot of question, but I dont know why.. I dont know how to explain and provide the evidence. It was all my fault. if I found the better job and we can get the place under our name and had more evidence for our self like utility. I never think it will be problem and I will go to separated with wife.

 

we purchase the car with loan for 6 year and 0% interest. it still under our name, but she didn't have the drive licecnse..

 

I gave the 3 affidavit when I filed the 751. I will give my mom's letter and my other best firend letter from korea.

 

My lawyer is not helpful for me..

Please help me and advice for me 

[Villanelle 4,122]

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

 

Ok so you have a lot you can respond with. Do you need help with formatting?

 

It's important to respond in your own way,  your own words. Your response to questions verbally or written need to be genuine and that means however you say it is how it should be said.

 

For formatting-

 

letter should start as response to RFE and then just as you did here list out each RFE point and the response. 

 

 

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

 

Hello,

 

I just share what they wanted to explain.

 

1. they asked me that my paystub status was single and goes to married and go back to single. they think it is inconsistent.

 - > my wife filed married 2 on her w-9 and mine was married 3, but my first job manager withhold single and i asked them to change it to married that I gave to them. However, I knew that it is withholding status. If wife withhold married 2 and my paystub withhold married 3, we need to pay lots of pay when we submitted the tax return. I dont know what document do i need to prove.

There are no documents. Not every thing will have a document as evidence. Some will just be your explanation. So for this issue- make sure your response is thorough. Include specific details. Ex- lets say you were married in Jan 2020. Started job feb 2020. Explain it was initially filled out withholding for 1. In March 2020 you asked for them to change it and made it 3 but then realized that would cause too much to be witheld so in june 2020 you changed it back to 1. If you have paystubs from back then reference the actual amounts of tax collected. Ex- I am attaching paystub for feb showing they took 300$ as withholding for 1. I changed it and in march they took 900$ ! So I changed it back to 1.

 

Also you might want to post in the working and finance/taxes subforum for help understanding tax withholdings and such because what you posted here is incorrect. The more they withhold the more likely it is you will get a refund upon filing. The less they withhold the more likely it is you will owe upon filing yearly taxes.  

 

 

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

2. they asked me that our phone bill is under her name. However, it goes to change my name on my number and go back to her name again (caller id and bill statement)

-> I dont know what I need to answer. I just transfer my number to her account , but I realized that I called to my friend and I realized that my caller id was my wife name when I call to someone. I chat with verizion that the reason why my phone show my wife name. That was why they chagned my caller ID. Account owner was my wife. However, I bring the non verizon device they didn't recognized my phone. THus, they tried to change the sim card and we had the apple watch 3G and paid the device payment as well as unlimited plan. she didn't use the apple watch, so I used her watch, but I need to connect it to my number. They didn't transfer it to my number because we didn't pay it off in full. They used the unnormal trick to connect it to my number. I think at that time my caller ID became the reset.. I dont know why exact reason why caller ID (bill statement) for my number changed back to her name again. 

The above explanation is sufficient. If you are not technologically inclined then your not. The fact that you went to verizion to change the name on your caller ID speaks for itself So if you attempted to change the caller ID and then it reverted and you didn't have the energy or time to go back to verizion to have them correct it again then that was it. Perhaps explain it wasn't a big deal for the caller ID to show her name. You all are / were married. You can also attempt to chat with verizion and get the transcripts from the chat. Perhaps you can get the chat rep to confirm in chat there was an issue and your previous visit? 

 

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

 

3. they mentioned that one of the credit card statement address is in SF (all statement is in LA, SF is her grandmother place)

-> Actually my wife was changed mind easily, but I realized that one of credit card statement address is in SF after they mentioned and asked to me. we used the joint account, but I didn't have the social at that time. she made the credit card and I was authorized user. we have differenet financial habit. I Treid to save the moeny for purchasing car, but she kept purchasing food or coffee to coworker. Even though our income is not enough. ( I get 2500 per month, and she was part timer. However she always resigned from her work place) we had alot of argue at that time. That was why she might hide statement from me. that was why she changed the address to her grand mother place. I dont know what proof. I need to give to them.

Your explanation is the proof. Was this particular credit card mentioned in the divorce? 

 

 

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

 

4. discrepancies for date on roommate agreement.

I lived in 2 bed and 2 bath apartment ( my roommate was original contractor with landlord). in the beginning she attended the school in SF and i was student in LA. That is why we back and fourth from la to SF. I visited their grandmother and uncle place. she decided to withdraw her school and came to LA. However, roommate agreement date my roommate put wrong year on the agreement.. 

they asked me the lease agreement.  we just kept staying in that place because we want to save the money for the future. and we have some mind to go SF if I get the better job in SF. Moreover, we didn't pay utility because my roommate was single mom with two kids. They paid all utility. we paid the rent to my roommate.

I dont know how to explain. I have contacted with previous roommate, but she changed the number one month ago. I dont know why.

 

Try to find previous roommate on social media and reach out to her there. Easiest solution is to get a statement from her correcting date mistake. If not you will want to come up with as much secondary evidence showing you lived there.  Bills or statements with the address.  DL records.  Bank transactions showing you were physically in LA and not SA. Most people tend to shop at the same stores or gas stations.  Try to show a pattern of buying groceries or picking up prescriptions at a place near home address. 

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

 

5. they asked me that I singed up the christian mutual med aid for avoiding penalty for not having insurance. However, it is not insurance, but it is certified from goverment to waive the penalty when we submitted the tax return. However, they mentioned it is not the insurance. they asked me health insurance.

-> I treid to get the job who provided the health insurance for me and wife, but it was little harder for me even though I kept applying. My previous company didn't provided the insurance. she kept using medical , but I knew that green card applicant get negative effect if I use the public charge (such as medicals ebt). I didn't sign up the medical because I knew that I can;'t use public charge. Moreover, I just endure when I had the pain. we just singed up the CMM for avoiding penalty, but they also have the level and provided the benefit if we are sick.

 

So you didn't have insurance. Its okay. Again you just explain it.

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

 

6. I also provided the gift receipt and receipt for hospital bills for her sickness. She only know me in LA. 

She bring document and went to Canada. ( she is dual citizen and parent live in canada) I dont have that much document I can show under both name. 

 

etc.

 

 

8 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

They asked me alot of question, but I dont know why.. I dont know how to explain and provide the evidence. It was all my fault. if I found the better job and we can get the place under our name and had more evidence for our self like utility. I never think it will be problem and I will go to separated with wife.

 

we purchase the car with loan for 6 year and 0% interest. it still under our name, but she didn't have the drive licecnse..

 

I gave the 3 affidavit when I filed the 751. I will give my mom's letter and my other best firend letter from korea.

 

My lawyer is not helpful for me..

Please help me and advice for me 

If your lawyer is not helpful find a new one!! You are paying them for assistance, if they are not assisting you they shouldn't be paid.

 

A multi point RFE like you got needs a well constructed response and it's clear you need personal assistance in drafting it. FIND A BETTER ATTORNEY.  You can call your local bar association and get referrals if needed. 

[POLLI2832 2]

On 8/12/2022 at 7:17 AM, Villanelle said:

Ok so you have a lot you can respond with. Do you need help with formatting?

 

It's important to respond in your own way,  your own words. Your response to questions verbally or written need to be genuine and that means however you say it is how it should be said.

 

For formatting-

 

letter should start as response to RFE and then just as you did here list out each RFE point and the response. 

 

 

There are no documents. Not every thing will have a document as evidence. Some will just be your explanation. So for this issue- make sure your response is thorough. Include specific details. Ex- lets say you were married in Jan 2020. Started job feb 2020. Explain it was initially filled out withholding for 1. In March 2020 you asked for them to change it and made it 3 but then realized that would cause too much to be witheld so in june 2020 you changed it back to 1. If you have paystubs from back then reference the actual amounts of tax collected. Ex- I am attaching paystub for feb showing they took 300$ as withholding for 1. I changed it and in march they took 900$ ! So I changed it back to 1.

 

Also you might want to post in the working and finance/taxes subforum for help understanding tax withholdings and such because what you posted here is incorrect. The more they withhold the more likely it is you will get a refund upon filing. The less they withhold the more likely it is you will owe upon filing yearly taxes.  

 

 

The above explanation is sufficient. If you are not technologically inclined then your not. The fact that you went to verizion to change the name on your caller ID speaks for itself So if you attempted to change the caller ID and then it reverted and you didn't have the energy or time to go back to verizion to have them correct it again then that was it. Perhaps explain it wasn't a big deal for the caller ID to show her name. You all are / were married. You can also attempt to chat with verizion and get the transcripts from the chat. Perhaps you can get the chat rep to confirm in chat there was an issue and your previous visit? 

 

Your explanation is the proof. Was this particular credit card mentioned in the divorce? 

 

 

 

Try to find previous roommate on social media and reach out to her there. Easiest solution is to get a statement from her correcting date mistake. If not you will want to come up with as much secondary evidence showing you lived there.  Bills or statements with the address.  DL records.  Bank transactions showing you were physically in LA and not SA. Most people tend to shop at the same stores or gas stations.  Try to show a pattern of buying groceries or picking up prescriptions at a place near home address. 

 

So you didn't have insurance. Its okay. Again you just explain it.

 

 

If your lawyer is not helpful find a new one!! You are paying them for assistance, if they are not assisting you they shouldn't be paid.

 

A multi point RFE like you got needs a well constructed response and it's clear you need personal assistance in drafting it. FIND A BETTER ATTORNEY.  You can call your local bar association and get referrals if needed. 

which explanation is better between essay type or bullet point type?

 

Thank you for your explanation.

 

I dont know which Attorney is better for me now. 

[POLLI2832 2]

On 7/23/2022 at 12:37 PM, God is a good God said:

Any point they mentioned if you don’t have proof, just explain that point why you don’t have proof and hope it works

Hello i submitted the RFE answer and updated to received my answer and then updated to transferred another office. Do you know it is normal process to transfer other office? It is because of interview process?

Thank you for your help @God is a good God

[RCCC 7]

10 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

Hello i submitted the RFE answer and updated to received my answer and then updated to transferred another office. Do you know it is normal process to transfer other office? It is because of interview process?

Thank you for your help @God is a good God

Mine took 6 months. Another office will final review your case. If they still have any questions, might either ask for RFE additional evidence / explanation, or ask you questions at interview. Be prepare and have copy of all documents submitted. 

[POLLI2832 2]

13 hours ago, RCCC said:

Mine took 6 months. Another office will final review your case. If they still have any questions, might either ask for RFE additional evidence / explanation, or ask you questions at interview. Be prepare and have copy of all documents submitted. 

Thank you for answer @RCCC

 

can you share your timeline and case.

mine is i-751 self petitioner and I submitted the document with i-751. It changed to status to get the RFE when document is in laguna.

after i submitted the answer for rfe, it changed the status as transferred another office. Is it still possibility to get another RFE? Even though i got the RFE before the transferring it to somewhere (didnt get the notice yet).

It is also possibility to get the waive the interview once they dont have question?

 

thank you

[RCCC 7]

5 hours ago, POLLI2832 said:

Thank you for answer @RCCC

 

can you share your timeline and case.

mine is i-751 self petitioner and I submitted the document with i-751. It changed to status to get the RFE when document is in laguna.

after i submitted the answer for rfe, it changed the status as transferred another office. Is it still possibility to get another RFE? Even though i got the RFE before the transferring it to somewhere (didnt get the notice yet).

It is also possibility to get the waive the interview once they dont have question?

 

thank you

Everything is possible. 

 

3/11/2019 - Application received

5/21/2019 - Biometrics Taken

3/26/2020 - Case is transferred to Another Office

12/30/2020 - Contact House Representatives follows up with my case

3/4/2021 - I missed Interview...

3/5/2021 - Went to USCIS office in person w/o an appointment , informed officer interview letter was delay in mail delivery ... they escorted me out.....

3/6/2021 - Received Denial of Petition to Remove Conditions THE NEXT DAY!  (USCIS acts so fast when they deny it, but getting approve takes foreverrrrr)

3/8/2021 - Went to USCIS office in person w/o an appointment again. Request to speak w/ supervisor for another interview. Got another interview AT THE SPOT... I didn't bring any supporting documents  w/ me.. only driver license & passport..... wasn't expected an interview... So the supervisor interviewed me, and when he asked for original documents... I was like... Can I come back in 2 hours... and you already have all the copies... lol Then he was like yes copy is fine... I got approved AT THE SPOT. Interview was short and easy. He knows that I was super anxious and sad b/c denial situation.