Received revocation notice for our I-130

[Rocio0010 5,579]

2 hours ago, Zeegee said:

to do the apeal to reopen and reconsider because if I file new I 130 those issues will be there so it’s batter to resolve those issues and response to those because new filing these thing still come up they are not going no where so I think apeal works best

How does an appeal “work best” in a case like OP’s, where USCIS did not err?

I’m not saying your case will be unsuccessful, but it seems odd he’s saying that refilling is not worth because the same issues will be there, but appealing does make sense. Are the issues going away with an appeal? And he’s charging $8000? A lot of times attorneys give you false hopes and they charge you an awful lot of money.
 

I’m sorry, I just don’t see how an appeal would make the issues go away, especially if USCIS did not make the wrong call. 

[Just Paul 4,594]

1 hour ago, ra0010 said:

How does an appeal “work best” in a case like OP’s, where USCIS did not err?

 

So USCIS approved the petition initially (they are verifying that the petition and beneficiary appear to be eligible for the immigration benefit).  The consulate eventually denied the visa.  The petition was returned to, and reviewed by USCIS (something a K1 isn't eligible for).  The petitioner wasn't able to address the issues in the NOIR and have the petition sent back to the consulate.  There doesn't appear to be anything that USCIS err in but that doesn't stop an appeal from taking place.  It doesn't sound like the petitioner wants to live in Pakistan and build up a better case and refile. Regardless, it will cost more money and time - which the petitioner should use to strengthen her case by spending more time with her husband.

[Zeegee 3]

2 hours ago, ra0010 said:

How does an appeal “work best” in a case like OP’s, where USCIS did not err?

I’m not saying your case will be unsuccessful, but it seems odd he’s saying that refilling is not worth because the same issues will be there, but appealing does make sense. Are the issues going away with an appeal? And he’s charging $8000? A lot of times attorneys give you false hopes and they charge you an awful lot of money.
 

I’m sorry, I just don’t see how an appeal would make the issues go away, especially if USCIS did not make the wrong call. 

It did work when you over come the issue my case it’s works since my husband already got his visa and he is here 4 month ago got his social and 10 years greencard 

[Zeegee 3]

Just now, Zeegee said:

It did work when you over come the issue my case it’s works since my husband already got his visa and he is here 4 month ago got his social and 10 years greencard 

And what ever the err is you need to fix it unless it’s a fraud marriage to gain the benefit

[Redro 4,609]

14 minutes ago, Zeegee said:

It did work when you over come the issue my case it’s works since my husband already got his visa and he is here 4 month ago got his social and 10 years greencard 

What issues did you have to overcome?

Were they as numerous as the OPs (questions about who is funding the trips and gifts, bankruptcy the month you married, and incorrect answers about when you met).

And if you had the issue, how did you overcome the issue of incorrect answers- e.g giving the incorrect year of meeting.. . 

[Rocio0010 5,579]

26 minutes ago, Zeegee said:

It did work when you over come the issue my case it’s works since my husband already got his visa and he is here 4 month ago got his social and 10 years greencard 

Yes!! I saw that after I posted the message. Congrats! I just think that there might be a language barrier here and that maybe your appeal was successful because USCIS made the wrong judgment. From what I’ve seen in VJ, that’s the only chance an appeal can get you the outcome you wanted. OP’s husband had several inconsistencies during the interview, so indeed made a good decision in serving them with a NOIR. If you don’t mind answering, what were your issues?

[John & Rose 7,239]

On 11/1/2021 at 5:33 AM, ra0010 said:

Yes!! I saw that after I posted the message. Congrats! I just think that there might be a language barrier here and that maybe your appeal was successful because USCIS made the wrong judgment. From what I’ve seen in VJ, that’s the only chance an appeal can get you the outcome you wanted. OP’s husband had several inconsistencies during the interview, so indeed made a good decision in serving them with a NOIR. If you don’t mind answering, what were your issues?

No two cases are alike and the OP has pretty serious challenges that this poster probably didn't have.  USCIS seems to be clear of any mistakes in the OP's case.  We don't know many details of the other poster's case.

[Rocio0010 5,579]

11 minutes ago, John & Rose said:

No two cases are alike and the OP has pretty serious challenges that this poster probably didn't have.  USCIS seems to be clear of any mistakes in the OP's case.  We don't know many details of the other poster's case.

Exactly. That’s why I asked OP about her issues. It’s great that they had them sorted out, though.

[Jeffry Hardy 6]

On 10/25/2021 at 10:54 PM, Luckystar78 said:

So, I received a revocation notice for my husbands I 130. Anyone who has gone thru this, is it better to appeal or start all over and submit a new application? We have been going thru this process for 4 years now and are so frustrated and disappointed. 

I will advise u to get very good  immigration lawyer, many people handle immigrate visas buy their self  many secret in immigrate process which u don’t know  but immigration lawyer knows everything, sad u are passing through this but don’t give up u will smile at the end of everything nothing Good comes easily I’m living testimony stay bless 

Edited November 4, 2021 by Jeffry Hardy

[Zeegee 3]

4 minutes ago, Jeffry Hardy said:

I will advise u to get immigration lawyer, many people handle immigrate visas buy their selfs they are alot of secret u don’t know but immigration lawyer knows everything sad u are passing through this but don’t give up that u will smile at the end stay bless 

I went throw the same situation then I have to get the Attrony and he thinks it’s batter to appeal which we did i290b which took 16 months to get approved then they open i130 again and start working on I use to call every day to Uscis and every month sand inquire then it’s took 24 months to get approved I 130 again but it’s worth of wait since my husband already here he went for interview again and with out any problem in 15 min he got his visa so my Attroney was right to file motion so what ever issue was it can solve on motion refilling will be no good since the issue which they revoked the case first place they be still there my husband already here for 4 months already have his 10 years greencard social security card driving license and every thing went very smooth if you need that Attroney name and no I can give you that 4 years ago he charge me 8000 but now I don’t know how much he charge 

[Zeegee 3]

On 11/1/2021 at 6:23 AM, Kor2USA said:

What issues did you have to overcome?

Were they as numerous as the OPs (questions about who is funding the trips and gifts, bankruptcy the month you married, and incorrect answers about when you met).

And if you had the issue, how did you overcome the issue of incorrect answers- e.g giving the incorrect year of meeting.. . 

We have multiple issues they thought why I get divorce from my home country which was clumsy issue since I was married there and it’s not wrong to get divorce from your home country then why I get the divorce from court and union council write it some thing else there was lot of issue but they all were wrong issue so when my Attroney answer everything satisfactory and tell them why this all is ok to do it and I wrote a big latter to them too explain that why I can’t go to visit my husband for 4 years and I get dr latter my employer latter that I take care of there mother and her mother only know me and eat and bath with me only she don’t know anyone else and then her dr wrote it for me that why I didn’t left her patient so it’s works out for us I don’t know why your issues are   

[Rocio0010 5,579]

33 minutes ago, Jeffry Hardy said:

but immigration lawyer knows everything, s

That’s a bit of an exaggeration. I’ve seen immigration attorneys mess up big time

[Boiler 44,814]

41 minutes ago, Zeegee said:

We have multiple issues they thought why I get divorce from my home country which was clumsy issue since I was married there and it’s not wrong to get divorce from your home country then why I get the divorce from court and union council write it some thing else there was lot of issue but they all were wrong issue so when my Attroney answer everything satisfactory and tell them why this all is ok to do it and I wrote a big latter to them too explain that why I can’t go to visit my husband for 4 years and I get dr latter my employer latter that I take care of there mother and her mother only know me and eat and bath with me only she don’t know anyone else and then her dr wrote it for me that why I didn’t left her patient so it’s works out for us I don’t know why your issues are   

How long did it take in total?

[Redro 4,609]

1 hour ago, Zeegee said:

We have multiple issues they thought why I get divorce from my home country which was clumsy issue since I was married there and it’s not wrong to get divorce from your home country then why I get the divorce from court and union council write it some thing else there was lot of issue but they all were wrong issue so when my Attroney answer everything satisfactory and tell them why this all is ok to do it and I wrote a big latter to them too explain that why I can’t go to visit my husband for 4 years and I get dr latter my employer latter that I take care of there mother and her mother only know me and eat and bath with me only she don’t know anyone else and then her dr wrote it for me that why I didn’t left her patient so it’s works out for us I don’t know why your issues are   

Did you use a lawyer when you received the NOIR. Or did you first reply without a lawyer?

Was your petition revoked and then you hired a lawyer to help you?

I'm trying to understand your timeline. 

 

But, it sounds like your case and the OP's case are very different.