Is TONS of evidence really necessary for I-751?

[Rocio0010 5,579]

10 minutes ago, Thomas Reinhardt said:

What's the lie ???? I'm just answering the question they have asked for an answer from anyone who reads the post and I wasn't spreading fear just stating the facts your I-751 petition must be strong enough to convince the USCIS officer that you are tried and true it's all about proving your word anyone can get married for the wrong reasons on this form they give you another chance to prove you didn't marry to get a visa nor avoid immigration laws be serious this petition will require good evidence. 

The first lie is that the spouse will be deported for not sending compelling evidence. The second lie is that children are the strongest evidence. Plenty of couples have no children and are approved. The third lie is that you should not send evidence that you have already sent: even the instructions say that the evidence that you sent has to cover the entire marriage, so yes, you have to send things they already have.

[Ang Oras 13]

Ok Immigration Attorney the only lies here are the ones that you're telling people that is what lawyers do right??? But remember they get paid to do that you don't! Nothing you've said is true do some more research before you give false information or information that's misleading. 

[Rocio0010 5,579]

33 minutes ago, Thomas Reinhardt said:

Ok Immigration Attorney the only lies here are the ones that you're telling people that is what lawyers do right??? But remember they get paid to do that you don't! Nothing you've said is true do some more research before you give false information or information that's misleading. 

Can you point out my lies, and back up what you claim?

[mindthegap 2,590]

41 minutes ago, Thomas Reinhardt said:

Ok Immigration Attorney the only lies here are the ones that you're telling people that is what lawyers do right??? But remember they get paid to do that you don't! Nothing you've said is true do some more research before you give false information or information that's misleading. 

@ra0010 wasn’t the only one to call you on your incorrect scaremongering.

(given my immigration experience with this journey I dare you to tell me to go do some research… 😂)

 

[Ang Oras 13]

1 minute ago, ra0010 said:

Can you point out my lies, and back up what you claim?

First: The I-751 Petition is all about providing evidence that your Marriage is tried and true USCIS wants to see where you stand 2 years later show from point of entrance to 90 days before your card expires now some couples wouldn't have provided the quantity of evidence I did with the CR130  a lot of what I used then shouldn't have been used until now during filing I-751 this would be like Life insurance, Copies of bills with joint names , Bank Statements, these are things a normal couple would have after establishing a single residence together but I used them then this is one of the many examples I can use to show you.

[Rocio0010 5,579]

5 minutes ago, Thomas Reinhardt said:

First: The I-751 Petition is all about providing evidence that your Marriage is tried and true USCIS wants to see where you stand 2 years later show from point of entrance to 90 days before your card expires now some couples wouldn't have provided the quantity of evidence I did with the CR130  a lot of what I used then shouldn't have been used until now during filing I-751 this would be like Life insurance, Copies of bills with joint names , Bank Statements, these are things a normal couple would have after establishing a single residence together but I used them then this is one of the many examples I can use to show you.

Sorry, not being mean, but a paragraph full of run-on sentences is very hard to understand. So you’re saying that one of my lies is that I -somehow- implied that you don’t have to send life insurance, copies of bills, etc etc. If so, please tell me when and how I have ever implied that. I couldn’t have and never said so, because actually the ROC package that I’m planning on submitting does have that. 
Now, on to your non- sense:

1) while technically it is true that the petitioner can be deported for not submitting good quality evidence, it’s not a fast process. Petitioner gets a NOID, a court date and then a judge is the one to decide whether they’ll remove your PR status. From submitting your ROC, to USCIS saying you didn’t submit enough evidence, to sending a NOID, to getting a court date can be years. 
2) about children being strong evidence: yeah, no… by that token, coupled with no kids wouldn’t be approved, or people that divorced and didn’t have kids. Children are not a commodity that one should get for immigration purposes imho. I have been here long enough to tell you that I have read about a few couples that did send BCs of kids born to the marriage, and still got RFEd for more evidence.

3) the instructions if I-751 point out clearly that you have to make sure that the evidence you send has to cover your whole marriage. When we did my AOS, we submitted bank statements from our joint bank account; now that we are collecting evidence for ROC we are going to send those statements and add the ones we will have up to the point of filing. We will also send the leases we already sent, together with new leases. Same with ver bills. USCIS wants to see a continuation of joint financial responsibilities from the moment you got married to whenever you apply for ROC. And even after you send your package, you should continue to collect such evidence because ROC can take up to two years, and they want to see if the marriage is still going on. 
And @mindthegapplease stop wasting your time here and go back and retake USCIS 101 please! 🙃 

19 minutes ago, mindthegap said:

@ra0010 wasn’t the only one to call you on your incorrect scaremongering.

(given my immigration experience with this journey I dare you to tell me to go do some research… 😂)

 

Yeah go research AOS and ROC 101 please 😂😂😂

[martinzl 91]

Here's something to ponder.  You need to supply evidence of a bonafide marriage from the date of the marriage to the time you submit the I-751.  However, the processing times are so delayed, for example 19-22 months for YSC, that much of what is submitted is outdated by the time the I-751 is processed. So what's the point? Over 95% are approved. I think the delays in processing are due in part because the USCIS does not see this as a priority.  You can continue to get extensions pending processing of ROC and can even apply for citizenship while waiting. In my opinion, the ROC has become a money grab.

[TBoneTX 45,267]

Folks, this legal-immigration process is dysfunctional at best and broken at worst.  The tension and frustration become unbearable, seemingly with no way to fight against it or relieve it.  Please remain unfailingly supportive of each other.  Remember that if you hold one pencil and snap it, it will break; conversely, if you hold a handful of pencils and try to snap them, they'll remain undamaged.

 

Not mentioned even once in this 7-page thread is to draft Wills, medical & statutory powers of attorney, HIPAA releases, and similar documents.  These make excellent evidence for ROC, and they're even more crucial to have in "life" -- even if you're young and don't own much.  Trust this.

 

[Moderator hat on]

Because enough good advice has been provided and bickering has begun to take over, this thread is now closed to further comment.  Do not transport the drama into other threads.

[Moderator hat  off]