i751 evidence I-751 Evidence

[Ari4321 1]

Hi ,having a baby jointly and submitting the birth certificate of the baby as a evidence with i-751,anyone got rfe ?what if someone hasn't submitted lot of other documents with that!

[Hawksquill 151]

A child's birth certificate shouldn't be the only evidence submitted with I-751, and I suspect that if you did that, or submitted very little other evidence, that you'd be more likely to get an RFE.  If you have a child together, there should be lots of other proof that you've comingled your lives together - leases, mortgages, insurance documents, bank statements, bills, etc.  It's a pain to assemble all the evidence but I'd rather spend the time now and feel secure in the amount of evidence submitted than risk an RFE or denial later.  

[Thegirl 225]

Absolutely not enough evidence by itself. Evidence yes. I agree with the other response, you should include all evidence esp within the categories as outlined in the i-751 instructions. 

[Lucky2Lucky 2,526]

Only submitting a birth certificate isn’t enough evidence for the i751 and would probably lead to a denial or RFE. You should have plenty of other things to submit during your two years married.

[Crazy Cat 42,062]

2 hours ago, Ari4321 said:

what if someone hasn't submitted lot of other documents with that!

Seriously??? In itself, a birth certificate means only that a woman had a child.......period.   It means nothing else.  However, combined with other evidence normally generated during a marriage, it can help.......There are other things which can provide quality evidence of a bona fide marriage.  

 

If I asked you to prove you and your spouse are currently in a marriage, living together, HOW WOULD YOU PROVE IT?  Think about that and start looking for evidence.....

Edited February 22, 2020 by missileman

[Ari4321 1]

5 hours ago, missileman said:

Seriously??? In itself, a birth certificate means only that a woman had a child.......period.   It means nothing else.  However, combined with other evidence normally generated during a marriage, it can help.......There are other things which can provide quality evidence of a bona fide marriage.  

 

If I asked you to prove you and your spouse are currently in a marriage, living together, HOW WOULD YOU PROVE IT?  Think about that and start looking for evidence.....

Thanks. I also submitted some more.just asking opinions for that because I saw people got rfe not having any kids.i also submitted-

New pregnancy report of my wife.

Letter from my credit card company saying I AUTHORIZED my wife in my account. 

15 photos of my wife, my and baby together. 

Drivers lisence showing same address. 

Two joint bank account statement with transaction history. But only for 1 month. I didn't know before to give some more months. 

We live in a house which was brought by my wife's family before we got married. So I couldn't submit any mortgage or rent doc.

5 hours ago, Luckycuds said:

Only submitting a birth certificate isn’t enough evidence for the i751 and would probably lead to a denial or RFE. You should have plenty of other things to submit during your two years married.

Thanks. I also submitted some more.just asking opinions for that because I saw people got rfe not having any kids.i also submitted-

New pregnancy report of my wife.

Letter from my credit card company saying I AUTHORIZED my wife in my account. 

15 photos of my wife, my and baby together. 

Drivers lisence showing same address. 

Two joint bank account statement with transaction history. But only for 1 month. I didn't know before to give some more months. 

We live in a house which was brought by my wife's family before we got married. So I couldn't submit any mortgage or rent doc.

[Ari4321 1]

6 hours ago, Thegirl said:

Absolutely not enough evidence by itself. Evidence yes. I agree with the other response, you should include all evidence esp within the categories as outlined in the i-751 instructions. 

Thanks. I also submitted some more.just asking opinions for that because I saw people got rfe not having any kids.i also submitted-

New pregnancy report of my wife.

Letter from my credit card company saying I AUTHORIZED my wife in my account. 

15 photos of my wife, my and baby together. 

Drivers lisence showing same address. 

Two joint bank account statement with transaction history. But only for 1 month. I didn't know before to give some more months. 

We live in a house which was brought by my wife's family before we got married. So I couldn't submit any mortgage or rent doc.

[carmel34 3,650]

11 hours ago, Ari4321 said:

Thanks. I also submitted some more.just asking opinions for that because I saw people got rfe not having any kids.i also submitted-

New pregnancy report of my wife.

Letter from my credit card company saying I AUTHORIZED my wife in my account. 

15 photos of my wife, my and baby together. 

Drivers lisence showing same address. 

Two joint bank account statement with transaction history. But only for 1 month. I didn't know before to give some more months. 

We live in a house which was brought by my wife's family before we got married. So I couldn't submit any mortgage or rent doc.

This evidence seems weak to me, especially the one month of joint bank statements, and letter from the credit card company with no statements showing that you both use the same credit card account for purchases.  They want to see evidence of financial co-mingling since the marriage, not just the last month.  Don't you have any joint utility bills, joint cell phone bills, joint health insurance, beneficiary statements for life insurance and retirement accounts, or a will, living will, power of attorney?  IRS tax transcripts showing married filing jointly?  Your wife's family could write up a lease agreement even if the rent is 0.  You will likely get an RFE, so start getting more evidence now so that you are ready to respond if you get one.  Good luck!

Edited February 23, 2020 by carmel34