HELP!!proof of domicile living abroad rejected

[ccece 2]

My husband (u.s citizen) living abroad with us, and we sent all the documents to the NVC , is the second time they rejected the proof of domicile, we sent a letter from his brother where we are going to live, a new open bank account in U.S. He applied for a job there, we sent that too, and a email from a school for our daughter, at the same time in my Case they rejected but in my son case they accepted, so im very confused and i dont want to keep wasting more time on this. He is thinking to travel before us, to reestablish domicile there, what is the fastest thing he can do there as a proof like he returned to the U.S.

We dont have money to buy a house yet. A driver license? Some bill on his name? A plane ticket?? What can work for NVC in this case. Thank you all!!!

[Khallaf 650]

35 minutes ago, ccece said:

My husband (u.s citizen) living abroad with us, and we sent all the documents to the NVC , is the second time they rejected the proof of domicile, we sent a letter from his brother where we are going to live, a new open bank account in U.S. He applied for a job there, we sent that too, and a email from a school for our daughter, at the same time in my Case they rejected but in my son case they accepted, so im very confused and i dont want to keep wasting more time on this. He is thinking to travel before us, to reestablish domicile there, what is the fastest thing he can do there as a proof like he returned to the U.S.

We dont have money to buy a house yet. A driver license? Some bill on his name? A plane ticket?? What can work for NVC in this case. Thank you all!!!

I have heard voter registration, insurance bills in his name also.

 

sorry your having such a hard time with them

[ccece 2]

yeah unfortunately he dont have none of those two

 

[Lil bear 4,286]

The best evidence would be for your husband to be physically living and working in the US.......That HE has made the choice and acted on it... that he has gone ahead and is preparing for the rest of his family to join him and make their long term home there. 

[ccece 2]

1 minute ago, Lil bear said:

The best evidence would be for your husband to be physically living and working in the US.......That HE has made the choice and acted on it... that he has gone ahead and is preparing for the rest of his family to join him and make their long term home there. 

OK , yes that is what he is planning to do, but once he is physically there, what type of proof can be, cause i just read again the website and they said: voting records, paying taxes, have  a permanent mail address( how he can prove that), having property.

Also they specify : " The sponsor does not have to precede the applicant to the United States but, if he or she does not do so, he or she must arrive in the United States concurrently with the applicant."

but obviously thats a lie.

[Lil bear 4,286]

4 minutes ago, ccece said:

OK , yes that is what he is planning to do, but once he is physically there, what type of proof can be, cause i just read again the website and they said: voting records, paying taxes, have  a permanent mail address( how he can prove that), having property.

Also they specify : " The sponsor does not have to precede the applicant to the United States but, if he or she does not do so, he or she must arrive in the United States concurrently with the applicant."

but obviously thats a lie.

I know it’s hard to understand why your evidence is not being accepted when we hear of others who are getting approved with the same evidence. But there are just so many things that come into to decision process. It is true that , if the visas were approved with your current evidence , that your husband could wait to enter the US with you, but if approval isn’t coming then you need to look at a different option. 

 

He lives in US

He has a job

He has a place to live .. rent, own , share , with extended family... 

etc. 

He has his state driver’s licence, car insurance, health insurance, voter registration, bank accounts, US cell phone etc 

 

[ccece 2]

1 minute ago, Lil bear said:

I know it’s hard to understand why your evidence is not being accepted when we hear of others who are getting approved with the same evidence. But there are just so many things that come into to decision process. It is true that , if the visas were approved with your current evidence , that your husband could wait to enter the US with you, but if approval isn’t coming then you need to look at a different option. 

 

He lives in US

He has a job

He has a place to live .. rent, own , share , with extended family... 

etc. 

He has his state driver’s licence, car insurance, health insurance, voter registration, bank accounts, US cell phone etc 

 

Thank you!!! yes, you are totally right, i will see it like that.

[SalishSea 18,073]

3 hours ago, ccece said:

OK , yes that is what he is planning to do, but once he is physically there, what type of proof can be, cause i just read again the website and they said: voting records, paying taxes, have  a permanent mail address( how he can prove that), having property.

Also they specify : " The sponsor does not have to precede the applicant to the United States but, if he or she does not do so, he or she must arrive in the United States concurrently with the applicant."

but obviously thats a lie.

It is not a lie.  Many Americans living abroad KEEP active lives in the US, in the form of property, bank accounts, voter registration, etc.  For those folks, proving domicile is not an issue, and they can travel with their families instead of before.

[ccece 2]

1 hour ago, Jorgedig said:

It is not a lie.  Many Americans living abroad KEEP active lives in the US, in the form of property, , but bank accounts, voter registration, etc.  For those folks, proving domicile is not an issue, and they can travel with their families instead of before.

Others Americans are living abroad didnt keep active lives in US and intent to re establish domicile in U.S. thats our case. And for  this  type of case NVC suggest upload the documents we already submitted, but they reject it in my case and not in my our son case, so it seems that acceptance is very subjective.

[SalishSea 18,073]

40 minutes ago, ccece said:

Others Americans are living abroad didnt keep active lives in US and intent to re establish domicile in U.S. thats our case. And for  this  type of case NVC suggest upload the documents we already submitted, but they reject it in my case and not in my our son case, so it seems that acceptance is very subjective.

Is your son not a US citizen though?  If so, he wouldn't need a visa.

[Just Paul 4,595]

12 hours ago, ccece said:

" The sponsor does not have to precede the applicant to the United States but, if he or she does not do so, he or she must arrive in the United States concurrently with the applicant."

but obviously thats a lie.

This is true.  Maybe you are misunderstanding it.  He either has to be in the US before you or travel with you.   Sometimes it is even annotated on the VISA.

 

[carmel34 3,650]

19 hours ago, ccece said:

He is thinking to travel before us, to reestablish domicile there, what is the fastest thing he can do there as a proof like he returned to the U.S.

We dont have money to buy a house yet. A driver license? Some bill on his name? A plane ticket?? What can work for NVC in this case. Thank you all!!!

He moves to the US now, gets a job, starts working and earning an income sufficient to support the family, gets a driver's license, car insurance, cell phone bill, registers to vote, with evidence of all of that showing his brother's address where you will live.  Normal things US citizens do.  He could do all of that in a month or two if he has a job lined up and is really motivated.  Submit the additional evidence and then you and the kids follow.  Lots of couples do this.  Good luck.  How has he shown sufficient income to sponsor you, or does he have a co-sponsor?

[ccece 2]

On 1/17/2019 at 10:19 AM, carmel34 said:

He moves to the US now, gets a job, starts working and earning an income sufficient to support the family, gets a driver's license, car insurance, cell phone bill, registers to vote, with evidence of all of that showing his brother's address where you will live.  Normal things US citizens do.  He could do all of that in a month or two if he has a job lined up and is really motivated.  Submit the additional evidence and then you and the kids follow.  Lots of couples do this.  Good luck.  How has he shown sufficient income to sponsor you, or does he have a co-sponsor?

yes , he have a joint sponsor. his brother.

 He moves to the U.S  a week ago, he got his driver license, vote registration. we submitted that to the NVC, but do you know how we can change his residence address to NVC, because before as a residence address he have the one overseas. and i cant find where we can change that. thanks!!

[carmel34 3,650]

4 hours ago, ccece said:

yes , he have a joint sponsor. his brother.

 He moves to the U.S  a week ago, he got his driver license, vote registration. we submitted that to the NVC, but do you know how we can change his residence address to NVC, because before as a residence address he have the one overseas. and i cant find where we can change that. thanks!!

Have you submitted all required forms to NVC yet?  If not, just change his address on those forms, then they will have the new one.  If you have already sent NVC all forms and documents, then call NVC and give them the new address.

[UltraHD 24]

On 1/16/2019 at 10:41 PM, ccece said:

My husband (u.s citizen) living abroad with us, and we sent all the documents to the NVC , is the second time they rejected the proof of domicile, we sent a letter from his brother where we are going to live, a new open bank account in U.S. He applied for a job there, we sent that too, and a email from a school for our daughter, at the same time in my Case they rejected but in my son case they accepted, so im very confused and i dont want to keep wasting more time on this. He is thinking to travel before us, to reestablish domicile there, what is the fastest thing he can do there as a proof like he returned to the U.S.

We dont have money to buy a house yet. A driver license? Some bill on his name? A plane ticket?? What can work for NVC in this case. Thank you all!!!

They are totally unpredictable.