Case is being forward to NVC for revocation

[Crazy Cat 42,056]

5 minutes ago, SHAHZAIB said:

sir you are wrong who told you my wife withdraw and she is not talking to me?

Sorry.  I must have been thinking about another thread.......my apologies.....

[SJ57 4]

it's ok no problem

[Marieke H 2,523]

26 minutes ago, SHAHZAIB said:

sir

are we falling under 100% ctageory

For a CR1 visa the sponsor needs to make 125%.

[mrmvkjts 459]

You keep talking abou the money while your bigger problem is that they didn‘t believe you have a bona fide relationship!!

If I were you I would just gather as much evidence as possible to be able to overcome it! 

 

It‘s gonna be a fairly long and uphill battle I would say

[SJ57 4]

Mrmvkjts I already told here me and wife tried best to provide proofs for bona fide of relationship. if you have any advice please tell me how i can  convince them ?

what kind proofs i need ?

 

[Jaquelly 1,647]

45 minutes ago, SHAHZAIB said:

Mrmvkjts I already told here me and wife tried best to provide proofs for bona fide of relationship. if you have any advice please tell me how i can  convince them ?

what kind proofs i need ?

 

What everyone is trying to express to you is that your FIRST concern should be the money. If you cannot show them you can support yourself, the proof of the relationship is useless.

[Reqahmed 92]

6 hours ago, debbiedoo said:

Income can always be overcome with a co sponsor or assets. 

 

For whatever reason, they do not believe you have a bonafide relationship, which is a MUCH harder obstacle to overcome.

 

You've only seen each other twice? Am I reading that correctly? You need more in person time together.

I am not agree with you. I think seen twice is more than enough. Most of South Asian people only meet during wedding that's it still get visa. He meet up twice within year. 

[debbiedoo 2,339]

1 minute ago, Reqahmed said:

I am not agree with you. I think seen twice is more than enough. Most of South Asian people only meet during wedding that's it still get visa. He meet up twice within year. 

you can disagree with me. makes no difference to me.

 

It's your visa application, not mine.

[Reqahmed 92]

1 minute ago, debbiedoo said:

you can disagree with me. makes no difference to me.

 

It's your visa application, not mine.

It's not my application. I'm here same as you.

[Crazy Cat 42,056]

8 minutes ago, Reqahmed said:

I am not agree with you. I think seen twice is more than enough. Most of South Asian people only meet during wedding that's it still get visa. He meet up twice within year. 

Did you read this: "Our office is also in process of sending this case back to National Visa Center recommending revocation of the petition for not establishing the bona fides of the relationship.'' "???

 

The best cure for this denial is more time spent together...

Edited August 30, 2018 by missileman

[debbiedoo 2,339]

1 minute ago, Reqahmed said:

It's not my application. I'm here same as you.

whatever.

 

its obvious, because the RFE/denial/whatever SAYS so, that they do not believe it is a bonafide relationship. 

 

How to overcome that?

 

ACTUALLY SEE EACH OTHER.

 

Pretty much any other RFE can be overcome - be it money, missing documents, or even, in all but the worst cases, criminal records.

[Reqahmed 92]

Seeing more doesn't mean it fullfil bonafide. There are also other things need to comply for bonafides relationship. This is not k1 that couple needs to meet more than twice. It could be other issues.

[Crazy Cat 42,056]

2 minutes ago, Reqahmed said:

Seeing more doesn't mean it fullfil bonafide

Actually, it is the STRONGEST indication of a bona fide relationship......time spent together normally overcomes all other red flags...

[debbiedoo 2,339]

1 minute ago, Reqahmed said:

Seeing more doesn't mean it fullfil bonafide. There are also other things need to comply for bonafides relationship. This is not k1 that couple needs to meet more than twice. It could be other issues.

Sure. but all we know is what OP said and what the RFE says. And (we're speaking in circles here and I'm about over it)... the most obvious way to overcome that issue is with MORE FACETIME. and not the phone app kind of facetime. obviously, they submitted whatever documents he stated and it wasnt enough. which pretty much mean the ONLY THING LEFT is to SEE each other IN PERSON

[debbiedoo 2,339]

Just now, missileman said:

Actually, it is the STRONGEST indication of a bona fide relationship......time spent together normally overcomes all other red flags...

right? if Paul and I got an RFE for lack of bonafide relationship I'm afraid I'd write them back and ask them if they were DAFT. 40+ visits, documented, over almost 3 years by the time we get to interview.  Plus additional joint stuff usually only required for AOS or CR1. lolololol