Starting the IR-1 process

[db2016 100]

Hi All, 

 

I am in the process for filing the i-130 for my husband who lives abroad. One question I am stuck on is if a petition was filed for the beneficiary prior? I did apply or the K1 visa for him and after being put on AP for very long we decided to withdraw and get married in his country and then apply for the Spouse Visa. My question, would I put yes or no for this question since it does not explicitly say for any visa or the spouse visa? Additionally, can people who have applied share the types of evidence they provided with their i-130, it is a little different than what was asked of us for the K1. 

 

Part 5. Other Information
Have you EVER previously filed a petition for this
beneficiary or any other alien?
1.Yes/No
If you answered "Yes," provide the name, place, date of filing,
and the result.

[Khallaf 650]

2 minutes ago, db2016 said:

Hi All, 

 

I am in the process for filing the i-130 for my husband who lives abroad. One question I am stuck on is if a petition was filed for the beneficiary prior? I did apply or the K1 visa for him and after being put on AP for very long we decided to withdraw and get married in his country and then apply for the Spouse Visa. My question, would I put yes or no for this question since it does not explicitly say for any visa or the spouse visa? Additionally, can people who have applied share the types of evidence they provided with their i-130, it is a little different than what was asked of us for the K1. 

 

Part 5. Other Information
Have you EVER previously filed a petition for this
beneficiary or any other alien?
1.Yes/No
If you answered "Yes," provide the name, place, date of filing,
and the result.

your answer will be yes, you have filed one, write his name in the space and explain what the outcome was, did you pull the petition back?

3 minutes ago, db2016 said:

Hi All, 

 

I am in the process for filing the i-130 for my husband who lives abroad. One question I am stuck on is if a petition was filed for the beneficiary prior? I did apply or the K1 visa for him and after being put on AP for very long we decided to withdraw and get married in his country and then apply for the Spouse Visa. My question, would I put yes or no for this question since it does not explicitly say for any visa or the spouse visa? Additionally, can people who have applied share the types of evidence they provided with their i-130, it is a little different than what was asked of us for the K1. 

 

Part 5. Other Information
Have you EVER previously filed a petition for this
beneficiary or any other alien?
1.Yes/No
If you answered "Yes," provide the name, place, date of filing,
and the result.

my question is if you gotten the K1 starting over with a CR1 will take another 12-14 months to complete

[pushbrk 12,893]

47 minutes ago, db2016 said:

Hi All, 

 

I am in the process for filing the i-130 for my husband who lives abroad. One question I am stuck on is if a petition was filed for the beneficiary prior? I did apply or the K1 visa for him and after being put on AP for very long we decided to withdraw and get married in his country and then apply for the Spouse Visa. My question, would I put yes or no for this question since it does not explicitly say for any visa or the spouse visa? Additionally, can people who have applied share the types of evidence they provided with their i-130, it is a little different than what was asked of us for the K1. 

 

Part 5. Other Information
Have you EVER previously filed a petition for this
beneficiary or any other alien?
1.Yes/No
If you answered "Yes," provide the name, place, date of filing,
and the result.

If you'll look at the I-129F you filed, you will see it is a "petition" not a visa application.  Yes, YOU filed a petition for this beneficiary.

45 minutes ago, Khallaf said:

 did you pull the petition back?

my question is if you gotten the K1 starting over with a CR1 will take another 12-14 months to complete

The OP says they withdrew the petition.  They are no married.  Your question contains no question.

[pushbrk 12,893]

19 minutes ago, pushbrk said:

If you'll look at the I-129F you filed, you will see it is a "petition" not a visa application.  Yes, YOU filed a petition for this beneficiary.

The OP says they withdrew the petition.  They are no married.  Your question contains no question.

They are NOW Married.  Sorry for the typo.

[Khallaf 650]

6 minutes ago, pushbrk said:

They are NOW Married.  Sorry for the typo.

I meant to ask why they would start the process over, it will not take longer for them to be together. had they stuck out the K1, they would have been potential together sooner.

Edited January 24, 2018 by Khallaf

[db2016 100]

16 minutes ago, pushbrk said:

If you'll look at the I-129F you filed, you will see it is a "petition" not a visa application.  Yes, YOU filed a petition for this beneficiary.

The OP says they withdrew the petition.  They are no married.  Your question contains no question.

thank you, will be sure to state yes

 

1 hour ago, Khallaf said:

your answer will be yes, you have filed one, write his name in the space and explain what the outcome was, did you pull the petition back?

my question is if you gotten the K1 starting over with a CR1 will take another 12-14 months to complete

yes we withdrew, got married, reapplying now for the spouse visa. 

Just now, Khallaf said:

I meant to ask why they would start the process over, it will not take longer for them to be together. had they stuck out the K1, they would have been potential together sooner.

because we wanted to get married, regardless not really the point, we already moved forward, i am just seeking some guidance. 

[Abies 1,713]

1 hour ago, db2016 said:

Hi All, 

 

I am in the process for filing the i-130 for my husband who lives abroad. One question I am stuck on is if a petition was filed for the beneficiary prior? I did apply or the K1 visa for him and after being put on AP for very long we decided to withdraw and get married in his country and then apply for the Spouse Visa. My question, would I put yes or no for this question since it does not explicitly say for any visa or the spouse visa? Additionally, can people who have applied share the types of evidence they provided with their i-130, it is a little different than what was asked of us for the K1. 

 

Part 5. Other Information
Have you EVER previously filed a petition for this
beneficiary or any other alien?
1.Yes/No
If you answered "Yes," provide the name, place, date of filing,
and the result.

In our case,weAlSo had a previous denied K1. 

1.Yes 

My husband wrote down my name(maiden name)place of filing:Moreno Valley California

Date of filing was the date they received our petition

And the result: I-129f approved,K1 visa denied.

 

I hope this helps

[db2016 100]

8 minutes ago, Abies said:

In our case,weAlSo had a previous denied K1. 

1.Yes 

My husband wrote down my name(maiden name)place of filing:Moreno Valley California

Date of filing was the date they received our petition

And the result: I-129f approved,K1 visa denied.

 

I hope this helps

thank you dear, yes it does  in our case it was withdrawn, so perfect, will put that

[Khallaf 650]

18 minutes ago, Abies said:

In our case,weAlSo had a previous denied K1. 

1.Yes 

My husband wrote down my name(maiden name)place of filing:Moreno Valley California

Date of filing was the date they received our petition

And the result: I-129f approved,K1 visa denied.

 

I hope this helps

do you mind if I ask you, if in their reason for denial is it not something that could have been appealed? 

 

I guess I am clueless and never should have responded to the question before, as I didn't know that a denial could happen I just assume they would ask for more evidence.

[Abies 1,713]

1 minute ago, Khallaf said:

do you mind if I ask you, if in their reason for denial is it not something that could have been appealed? 

 

I guess I am clueless and never should have responded to the question before, as I didn't know that a denial could happen I just assume they would ask for more evidence.

K1 visa have a short validity period of 4months.. After your interview,the co allows it to expire before sending it back to the U.S. where you will be told to either refile a K1 or come over to the beneficiary's  country to marry him/her&start the CR1 route

[Abies 1,713]

17 minutes ago, db2016 said:

thank you dear, yes it does  in our case it was withdrawn, so perfect, will put that

Your welcome

[pushbrk 12,893]

6 hours ago, Abies said:

In our case,weAlSo had a previous denied K1. 

1.Yes 

My husband wrote down my name(maiden name)place of filing:Moreno Valley California

Date of filing was the date they received our petition

And the result: I-129f approved,K1 visa denied.

 

I hope this helps

Place of filing would be the service center, or even "Dallas, TX" where all I-129F petitions have been mailed the last few years would be the correct answer but it is not critical.

[pushbrk 12,893]

6 hours ago, Khallaf said:

I meant to ask why they would start the process over, it will not take longer for them to be together. had they stuck out the K1, they would have been potential together sooner.

I see that it is a question of personal curiosity.  Bear in mind that the quickest way to be together is not ALWAYS the highest priority for some couples.

[db2016 100]

On 1/24/2018 at 11:41 AM, Abies said:

Your welcome

can you share the types of evidence you sent as proof of your marriage?

[db2016 100]

hi all, i have a question. I am done with the form i-130 but some parts of the form for some reason wont allow me to type in. it is ok to have some parts handwritten and some typed? or does it have to be all handwritten or all typed?

Edited February 6, 2018 by db2016