physical presence proof

[mnoman 2]

Dear All,

 

Could you please suggest these below evidence are enough for our child counseling report abroad or not my wife is US born she lives in US till she was 18 before our baby born but she didnt attend any school or job also she does not have any medical history as well. she only have her old passport it made when she was around 1 which has some entry exit records and her 2nd passport which also has entry exit records also her state ID.

also we requested CBP record for her too. will these evidence work for us or not ?

[payxibka 10,045]

She did not attend any school?  Not elementary or high school?

[mnoman 2]

no she didn't

[Going through 5,671]

She never attended school since she was born....neither elementary or high school at all, correct?  Doesn't matter if she graduated or not if that's what you're thinking....was she home-schooled in the US by her parents?

 

She never went for a doctor's appointment in the US ever since she was born, either?  Check ups, shots, etc.?

Edited January 24, 2018 by Going through

[mnoman 2]

16 minutes ago, Going through said:

She never attended school since she was born....neither elementary or high school at all, correct?  Doesn't matter if she graduated or not if that's what you're thinking....was she home-schooled in the US by her parents?

 

She never went for a doctor's appointment in the US ever since she was born, either?  Check ups, shots, etc.?

well she was also not home schooled basically her parents never made any record for medical or healthcare history all she has is passport old and new one that it.

[Boiler 45,434]

What does she have?

[mnoman 2]

she has her old passport when she was 1year old has entry exit record also she has her new passport which also has entry exit record we also requested CBP to get border border entry exit record to prove her presence.

[Boiler 45,434]

Come on be real, you do not live in the US for 18 years without leaving a paper trail.

Edited January 24, 2018 by Boiler

[NigeriaorBust 4,087]

Census records would pick her up.   Her parent income tax records should have listed her. 

[mnoman 2]

 

Just now, NigeriaorBust said:

Census records would pick her up.   Her parent income tax records should have listed her. 

we have call embassy that Her parents income tax records has her name as a dependence will be enough or not they said her parents Income tax records does not prove physical presence in United state.

[Going through 5,671]

You can't provide what you don't have, so all you can do is hope for the best with the passport info since that's all that you've got.

[Boiler 45,434]

1 hour ago, Going through said:

You can't provide what you don't have, so all you can do is hope for the best with the passport info since that's all that you've got.

He can but that will not hack it.

[Going through 5,671]

7 minutes ago, Boiler said:

He can but that will not hack it.

I know...that's why I added the "hope for the best" part. 

 

I find it hard to fathom that the parents made sure to add the daughter as a tax deduction but not enroll her in school...well, truth be told, I have an *assumption* as to why there was no schooling/no doctor visits ever but don't want to presume anything out loud.

[Boiler 45,434]

1 minute ago, Going through said:

I know...that's why I added the "hope for the best" part. 

 

I find it hard to fathom that the parents made sure to add the daughter as a tax deduction but not enroll her in school...well, truth be told, I have an *assumption* as to why there was no schooling/no doctor visits ever but don't want to presume anything out loud.

Thread things occurred to me but we will never know.

[jan22 3,049]

On 1/24/2018 at 8:08 AM, NigeriaorBust said:

Census records would pick her up.   Her parent income tax records should have listed her. 

Census records are not made public for 75 years; most recent one released is the 1940 one.  Tax records do not show physical presence of the filers, let alone dependents.