Jump to content
karimkabani

i-751 rejected twice

By karimkabani in Removing Conditions on Residency General Discussion

 Share

27 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

karimkabani Rookie

karimkabani   0

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Timeline
Posted

hi, my wifes green card will expire on june 7th, 2007. i send the i-751 and all the supporting docs on the 20th of feb, i got a rejection letter, stating i filed the form too early, need to file within 90 days of the green card expiration.

i resent the documet on mach 14th, 2007, got a rejection letter again, stating "the service is unable to process the petition as submitted. it appears that the form i-751 is not necessary at this time."

any thoughts gusy

any help or suggestions will be very much appreciated.

regards,

karim.

4/3/2004 engaged in usmania hotel Karachi Pakistan

4/23/2004 sent I-129F to <!--WORD2URL-01--><!--END WORD2URL-01-->NSC<!--WORD2URL-02--><!--END WORD2URL-02-->

4/28/2004 Received NOA#1

9/4/2004 Received NOA#2

10/11/2004 Sent packet 3.5 to Islamabad consulate

10/21/2004 Interview date set for 12/17/2004.

6/7/2005 Fiancé arrived in Chicago, no problems at POE

6/25/2005 Got married

7/25/2005 - filed for I-485,I-131, I-765

11/5/2005 - got AP

1/31/2006 - biometerics completed

2/1/2006 - got the EAD

2/10/2006 got the conditional greencard

3/14/2007 applied i-751 to remove the status on the conditional green card

4/2/2007 got rejected, the uscis is saying i need to apply for i-90, need help....

tweety Rising Star

tweety   1

Posted
Filed: Citizen (pnd) Country: Germany
 Timeline
Posted (edited)

I'm a little confused with what you write and your timeline... according to your timeline you didn't have your AOS approved in 2006, so your 2 year card shouldn't expire until at least 2008.... could it be you're a year too early?

edit to add: "2/10/2006 - I-485 transfered to csc, will take between 270-300 days...." from your signature timeline

Edited by tweety

animal-smiley-085.gif

Mar 06, 2007: mailed I751!

Mar 09, 2007: I751 arrived at TSC

Mar 13, 2007: checks cleared bank

Mar 24, 2007: biometrics receipt dated Mar 09

Mar 28, 2007: NOA1 dated Mar 09

Mar 28, 2007: biometrics letter dated Mar 22

Apr 06, 2007: biometrics appointment

(Oct 09, 2007: called USCIS: service request sent to TSC)

Jan 31, 2008: case transferred to VSC (last touch date changed from 04/07/07 to 02/01/08)

Feb 01, 2008: touch

Feb 04, 2008: touch

(Feb 05, 2008: infopass appointment)

Feb 07, 2008: transfer notice dated Feb 01, 08

Feb 13, 2008: touch (Current Status: This case is now pending at the office to which it was transferred.)

Feb 25, 2008: touch

Apr 11, 2008: approval email! (only took 1 year, 34 days!)

Apr 13, 2008: 2 more approval emails

Apr 16, 2008: email notice: "Approval notice sent"

Apr 18, 2008: MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!!!! card received!

tumbleweed-1.gif

04/22/2010 N400 mailed

05/05/2010 check cashed

05/07/2010 NOA1 dated 05/04/2010

YuAndDan Grand Master

YuAndDan   153

Posted
Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: China
 Timeline
Posted (edited)
hi, my wifes green card will expire on june 7th, 2007. i send the i-751 and all the supporting docs on the 20th of feb, i got a rejection letter, stating i filed the form too early, need to file within 90 days of the green card expiration.

i resent the documet on mach 14th, 2007, got a rejection letter again, stating "the service is unable to process the petition as submitted. it appears that the form i-751 is not necessary at this time."

any thoughts gusy

any help or suggestions will be very much appreciated.

regards,

karim.

How can your green card expire in June when your timeline shows applying for AOS July 05?

Also your profile still shows filed for K-1, since you are married now, and are filing to lift conditions, how about updating it to show lifting conditions?

:time:http://www.visajourney.com/timeline/profile.php?id=1936

Edited by YuAndDan

OUR TIME LINE Please do a timeline it helps us all, thanks.

Is now a US Citizen immigration completed Jan 12, 2012.

1428954228.1592.1755425389.png

CHIN0001_zps9c01d045.gifCHIN0100_zps02549215.gifTAIW0001_zps9a9075f1.gifVIET0001_zps0a49d4a7.gif

Look here: A Candle for Love and China Family Visa Forums for Chinese/American relationship,

Visa issues, and lots of info about the Guangzhou and Hong Kong consulate.

karimkabani Rookie

karimkabani   0

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Timeline
  • Author
Posted

timeline has not been updated, my wife came to us in june 07-05. got the conditional green card sometime in jan 06, has an expiration of june 07-2007. i will update my timeline, in the mean time if you guys can help me out with my question i would greatly appreciate it.

hi, my wifes green card will expire on june 7th, 2007. i send the i-751 and all the supporting docs on the 20th of feb, i got a rejection letter, stating i filed the form too early, need to file within 90 days of the green card expiration.

i resent the documet on mach 14th, 2007, got a rejection letter again, stating "the service is unable to process the petition as submitted. it appears that the form i-751 is not necessary at this time."

thanks. karim

4/3/2004 engaged in usmania hotel Karachi Pakistan

4/23/2004 sent I-129F to <!--WORD2URL-01--><!--END WORD2URL-01-->NSC<!--WORD2URL-02--><!--END WORD2URL-02-->

4/28/2004 Received NOA#1

9/4/2004 Received NOA#2

10/11/2004 Sent packet 3.5 to Islamabad consulate

10/21/2004 Interview date set for 12/17/2004.

6/7/2005 Fiancé arrived in Chicago, no problems at POE

6/25/2005 Got married

7/25/2005 - filed for I-485,I-131, I-765

11/5/2005 - got AP

1/31/2006 - biometerics completed

2/1/2006 - got the EAD

2/10/2006 got the conditional greencard

3/14/2007 applied i-751 to remove the status on the conditional green card

4/2/2007 got rejected, the uscis is saying i need to apply for i-90, need help....

Gigiola Contributor

Gigiola   0

Posted
Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: Spain
 Timeline
Posted

Recheck the date on her greencard.

She may have arrived in June 05 but on K1. You married and then adjusted status and didn't receive her card until 2/10/2006. If this is all true, she should be filing to remove conditions some time in July 2008 by my calculations.

9/18/04 Married in Indiana

9/20/04 I-130 mailed to Nebraska

10/7/04 NOA1 received (dated 9/29/04 in CAL!)

1/5/05 I-130 APPROVED (99days)

1/11/05 case number entered into NVC system (105/6 days)

4/5/05 CASE COMPLETE (189/90)

4/12/05 case forwarded to Madrid(196/97)

4/19/05 case arrives at Madrid consulate (203/104)

6/3/05 Interview date APPROVED

6/11/05 POE Chicago

6/24/05 Welcome to America letter

6/31/05 2nd Welcome to America letter!

7/5/05 Greencard arrives

7/15/05 SNN arrives

karimkabani Rookie

karimkabani   0

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Timeline
  • Author
Posted (edited)

the expiration of the conditional green card is two years from the day she came to US, which was 07/07/2005. i am 100% sure that her green cards expires on 07/07/2007. i don't understand why i have to file for i-90. any thoughts...

karim.

Edited by karimkabani

4/3/2004 engaged in usmania hotel Karachi Pakistan

4/23/2004 sent I-129F to <!--WORD2URL-01--><!--END WORD2URL-01-->NSC<!--WORD2URL-02--><!--END WORD2URL-02-->

4/28/2004 Received NOA#1

9/4/2004 Received NOA#2

10/11/2004 Sent packet 3.5 to Islamabad consulate

10/21/2004 Interview date set for 12/17/2004.

6/7/2005 Fiancé arrived in Chicago, no problems at POE

6/25/2005 Got married

7/25/2005 - filed for I-485,I-131, I-765

11/5/2005 - got AP

1/31/2006 - biometerics completed

2/1/2006 - got the EAD

2/10/2006 got the conditional greencard

3/14/2007 applied i-751 to remove the status on the conditional green card

4/2/2007 got rejected, the uscis is saying i need to apply for i-90, need help....

Canuck78 Contributor

Canuck78   0

Posted
Filed: Lift. Cond. (pnd) Country: Canada
 Timeline
Posted

That doesn't make any sense! The conditional green card expire 2 years after its issue date. For example, I came to the US under a K1 as well, in June 2004. I only got my conditionnal green card in Sept. 2005, so my card expires in Sept. 2007. If your wife got her card in Oct. '06, then her green card doesn't expire until Oct. '08. You seriously need to double check her actual green card.

Melissa

**I am an Army wife, you may see me struggle, but you will NEVER see me fall**

Domsiggy-1.jpgHayleeSiggy.jpg

My timeline

K1 - TSC

10-07-2003 I-129f Sent

10-10-2003 NOA 1

02-23-2004 NOA 2

03-01-2004 NVC Rc'd

03-04-2004 NVC Left

03-09-2004 Consulate Rc'd

03-12-2004 Packet 3 Rc'd

03-29-2004 Packet 3 Sent

04-13-2004 Packet 4 Rc'd

04-23-2004 Interview...........Approved!

04-23-2004 VISA in hand

06-10-2004 US Entry

07-24-2004 Marriage

AOS - OKC

09-14-2004 I-485 Sent

10-01-2004 NOA

04-11-2005 Biometrics

09-13-2005 Interview..........Approved!

12-05-2005 Green Card Rc'd

Lifting Condition - TSC

09-13-2007 I-751 Sent

10-11-2007 Case transfered to CSC

10-18-2007 NOA

03-12-2007 Biometrics

03-31-2008 Card production ordered.........Approved!

04-07-2008 Card Rc'd

karimkabani Rookie

karimkabani   0

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Timeline
  • Author
Posted

hi all, i did, actually the copy of the green card is in front of me, the expiration is 06/07/2007. however, i just noticiced on the top of her green card it says,

"PERMANENT RESIDENT CARD".... Does this imply, she never got a conditional green card....

What does it say on your green card..... Again, she came in 06/07/2005 through k1 visa....

thanks for your response and help...

karim.

4/3/2004 engaged in usmania hotel Karachi Pakistan

4/23/2004 sent I-129F to <!--WORD2URL-01--><!--END WORD2URL-01-->NSC<!--WORD2URL-02--><!--END WORD2URL-02-->

4/28/2004 Received NOA#1

9/4/2004 Received NOA#2

10/11/2004 Sent packet 3.5 to Islamabad consulate

10/21/2004 Interview date set for 12/17/2004.

6/7/2005 Fiancé arrived in Chicago, no problems at POE

6/25/2005 Got married

7/25/2005 - filed for I-485,I-131, I-765

11/5/2005 - got AP

1/31/2006 - biometerics completed

2/1/2006 - got the EAD

2/10/2006 got the conditional greencard

3/14/2007 applied i-751 to remove the status on the conditional green card

4/2/2007 got rejected, the uscis is saying i need to apply for i-90, need help....

zyggy Experienced

zyggy   9

Posted
Filed: Country: Canada
 Timeline
Posted
hi all, i did, actually the copy of the green card is in front of me, the expiration is 06/07/2007. however, i just noticiced on the top of her green card it says,

"PERMANENT RESIDENT CARD".... Does this imply, she never got a conditional green card....

What does it say on your green card..... Again, she came in 06/07/2005 through k1 visa....

thanks for your response and help...

karim.

Ok this makes absolutely no sense... the resident since date on the GC would not be the same date that she entered the US unless she entered on an Immigrant Visa (CR-1). If she entered the US on a K visa, her resident since date would be much later when her AOS was approved.

Knowledge itself is power - Sir Francis Bacon

I have gone fishing... you can find me by going here http://**removed due to TOS**

tweety Rising Star

tweety   1

Posted
Filed: Citizen (pnd) Country: Germany
 Timeline
Posted

could it be possible you have been issued a greencard with an incorrect expiry date?! when was her permanent residency status approved?

Conditional greencards always expire excactly 2 years after approval of permanent residency status.

animal-smiley-085.gif

Mar 06, 2007: mailed I751!

Mar 09, 2007: I751 arrived at TSC

Mar 13, 2007: checks cleared bank

Mar 24, 2007: biometrics receipt dated Mar 09

Mar 28, 2007: NOA1 dated Mar 09

Mar 28, 2007: biometrics letter dated Mar 22

Apr 06, 2007: biometrics appointment

(Oct 09, 2007: called USCIS: service request sent to TSC)

Jan 31, 2008: case transferred to VSC (last touch date changed from 04/07/07 to 02/01/08)

Feb 01, 2008: touch

Feb 04, 2008: touch

(Feb 05, 2008: infopass appointment)

Feb 07, 2008: transfer notice dated Feb 01, 08

Feb 13, 2008: touch (Current Status: This case is now pending at the office to which it was transferred.)

Feb 25, 2008: touch

Apr 11, 2008: approval email! (only took 1 year, 34 days!)

Apr 13, 2008: 2 more approval emails

Apr 16, 2008: email notice: "Approval notice sent"

Apr 18, 2008: MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!!!! card received!

tumbleweed-1.gif

04/22/2010 N400 mailed

05/05/2010 check cashed

05/07/2010 NOA1 dated 05/04/2010

meredith pa Explorer

meredith pa   0

Posted
Filed: Lift. Cond. (apr) Country: Brazil
 Timeline
Posted

Hi

My two year greencard also has Permanent Res. Card. I filed my petition within 90 days of expiration date.

This is a conditional STATUS, despite of

fact that you don't see the word CONDITIONAL on the card.

You need to file to remove conditions within 90 days of the exact day of expiration that is in the front of the card ( not from the day she stepped her foot in the US)

If the card expires on 06/07/2007, in JUNE, that means you can fill within 90 days of this day...

90 days....get a calendar, and do the math.

If you try to send a petition before 90 days, they will send it back to you....

If you fail to file the petition, or if you file it AFTER THE EXPIRATION DATE, you will probably get denied..

I'm not a lawyer, but if you find the process too confusing, you should consult A lawyer....

Meredith.

hi all, i did, actually the copy of the green card is in front of me, the expiration is 06/07/2007. however, i just noticiced on the top of her green card it says,

"PERMANENT RESIDENT CARD".... Does this imply, she never got a conditional green card....

What does it say on your green card..... Again, she came in 06/07/2005 through k1 visa....

thanks for your response and help...

karim.

Permanent resident with10 year greencard 

Gigiola Contributor

Gigiola   0

Posted
Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: Spain
 Timeline
Posted

They all say Permanent Resident Card. .. there is no "conditional" on them.

I'm afraid it sounds as if a mistake was made with the date when they issued your wife's card. The expiry date should be two years from the date it was issued, not the date she arrived over here on a K1. It would be a good idea to make an Infopass appointment and get definite answers.

9/18/04 Married in Indiana

9/20/04 I-130 mailed to Nebraska

10/7/04 NOA1 received (dated 9/29/04 in CAL!)

1/5/05 I-130 APPROVED (99days)

1/11/05 case number entered into NVC system (105/6 days)

4/5/05 CASE COMPLETE (189/90)

4/12/05 case forwarded to Madrid(196/97)

4/19/05 case arrives at Madrid consulate (203/104)

6/3/05 Interview date APPROVED

6/11/05 POE Chicago

6/24/05 Welcome to America letter

6/31/05 2nd Welcome to America letter!

7/5/05 Greencard arrives

7/15/05 SNN arrives

karimkabani Rookie

karimkabani   0

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Timeline
  • Author
Posted (edited)

hi, on her green card it says resident since, 06/07/05, card expires, 6/07/07.

Thanks. Karim.

Edited by karimkabani

4/3/2004 engaged in usmania hotel Karachi Pakistan

4/23/2004 sent I-129F to <!--WORD2URL-01--><!--END WORD2URL-01-->NSC<!--WORD2URL-02--><!--END WORD2URL-02-->

4/28/2004 Received NOA#1

9/4/2004 Received NOA#2

10/11/2004 Sent packet 3.5 to Islamabad consulate

10/21/2004 Interview date set for 12/17/2004.

6/7/2005 Fiancé arrived in Chicago, no problems at POE

6/25/2005 Got married

7/25/2005 - filed for I-485,I-131, I-765

11/5/2005 - got AP

1/31/2006 - biometerics completed

2/1/2006 - got the EAD

2/10/2006 got the conditional greencard

3/14/2007 applied i-751 to remove the status on the conditional green card

4/2/2007 got rejected, the uscis is saying i need to apply for i-90, need help....

tweety Rising Star

tweety   1

Posted
Filed: Citizen (pnd) Country: Germany
 Timeline
Posted

you can tell what status the card has if you look at "category": CF1 means conditional greencard

Anyway, when was your AOS approved?, your card seems to be issued with incorrect dates. You should definetely make an infopass appointment and see what they have to say. I believe if USCIS issues an incorrect card and the error is USCIS error, then you won't have to pay anything to get a new, corrected card issued.

animal-smiley-085.gif

Mar 06, 2007: mailed I751!

Mar 09, 2007: I751 arrived at TSC

Mar 13, 2007: checks cleared bank

Mar 24, 2007: biometrics receipt dated Mar 09

Mar 28, 2007: NOA1 dated Mar 09

Mar 28, 2007: biometrics letter dated Mar 22

Apr 06, 2007: biometrics appointment

(Oct 09, 2007: called USCIS: service request sent to TSC)

Jan 31, 2008: case transferred to VSC (last touch date changed from 04/07/07 to 02/01/08)

Feb 01, 2008: touch

Feb 04, 2008: touch

(Feb 05, 2008: infopass appointment)

Feb 07, 2008: transfer notice dated Feb 01, 08

Feb 13, 2008: touch (Current Status: This case is now pending at the office to which it was transferred.)

Feb 25, 2008: touch

Apr 11, 2008: approval email! (only took 1 year, 34 days!)

Apr 13, 2008: 2 more approval emails

Apr 16, 2008: email notice: "Approval notice sent"

Apr 18, 2008: MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!!!! card received!

tumbleweed-1.gif

04/22/2010 N400 mailed

05/05/2010 check cashed

05/07/2010 NOA1 dated 05/04/2010

zyggy Experienced

zyggy   9

Posted
Filed: Country: Canada
 Timeline
Posted
hi, on her green card it says resident since, 06/07/05, card expires, 6/07/07.

Thanks. Karim.

90 days from July 6, 2007 is April 7, 2007.. I bet if you sent it in now, it wouldn't be rejected...

Knowledge itself is power - Sir Francis Bacon

I have gone fishing... you can find me by going here http://**removed due to TOS**

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...