I-485 (AOS) denied under F2A due to USCIS error

[piff 46]

So based on that, are we sure it's all USCIS error in these cases? Or is it possible that it was current when filed but not when it came to be adjudicated?

Although I was under the impression that USCIS would just let those applications remain pending rather than deny them...

then they should have kept those cases pending until the date is current or so. But not just deny! Agree?

[arken 4,197]

then they should have kept those cases pending until the date is current or so. But not just deny! Agree?

Agree. There was a case which was denied after the interview. USCIS definitely made a mistake by scheduling an interview when the PD was not current. They should have simply kept the file on record after approval and scheduled the interview only after PD becomes current. I think the person is appealing the denial. Lets see where it goes.

[piff 46]

Agree. There was a case which was denied after the interview. USCIS definitely made a mistake by scheduling an interview when the PD was not current. They should have simply kept the file on record after approval and scheduled the interview only after PD becomes current. I think the person is appealing the denial. Lets see where it goes.

well who cares when they schedule for an interview, what matters is that they approve/deny based on real facts not not make a mistake. If they want they can schedule the next day and then hold on with the case until it's current... Right?

[EM_Vandaveer 2,408]

I believe that's correct, they are supposed to keep them pending, even EAD & AP are supposed to be renewable while waiting for the PD to become current.