I am a permanent resident, married to an US Citizen and my mom just had her visa denied.

[Carol & Tim 4]

Hello all,

I'm very disappointed with US Consulate in Brazil. I've been living in the US for three and half years with my american husband. My mother has always been scared to fly and I was the one always going to visit her. Last month, she decided she wants to come and applied for her tourist visa which was DENIED today!

I think it is so disrespectful that they would deny her visa since I live here. So it means my family is not allowed to visit me?

She took proof of her job and the she told the consul she has family there and that she just wanted to come for a visit. I sent a letter to the consul explaining that she was coming for a short visit but she still got denied.

I know since it's a tourist visa there is nothing I can do. I applied for Citizenship and I am in the process right now.

Do you think once I become a citizen her chances of getting a visa would be higher? She doesn't want to live here, just visit.

I am so frustrated right now! Sorry for venting. Just want to know my options of bringing my loved mom to visit me.

Thanks!

Edited April 7, 2015 by Carol & Tim

[canadian_wife 1,822]

Please vent here, that's what we are here for.

It has nothing to do with respect. Trust me, after being denied entry twice I felt the same way as you. However, I was rightfully denied because I had clear ties to the U.S. that overshadowed my ties to Canada. I suspect your mother does too. Having a daughter in the US (are you her only child? Does she have other family ties?) is a strong tie to the U.S.. You and your situation (as in becoming a citizen) does not increase her chances of being granted a non-immigrant visa.

Your options appear to be to have her apply again. Have her show she has money and ties to Brazil.

good luck

[NancyNguyen 1,657]

The fact of having an immigrant relative in the US is not ideal for tourist visa. Your option is to sponsor her green card when you become citizen or apply for another tourist visa when she has more proof of ties with Brazil.

[mallafri76 1,012]

I'm so sorry to hear that, must be very difficult. ?

Do you have brothers or sisters in Brazil, so your mum can show family ties to Brazil? What about mortgage or rental agreement of home?

[pdking5000 56]

The fact of having an immigrant relative in the US is not ideal for tourist visa. Your option is to sponsor her green card when you become citizen or apply for another tourist visa when she has more proof of ties with Brazil.

a friend of mine has a girlfriend who got a visitor's visa even though her sister is illegally living in the States. Family or no family isn't a reason for denial. I know of another person whose mom has been living illegally in the states for years and she got a visitor's visa as well (although the first time she was denied). I know of another fellow who has no job and his motive for applying for a visa was to see relatives. Whether or not you are denied depends on the mood and attitude of the consular officer. There is no magic formula.

[Boiler 45,559]

The problem is that large numbers of Brazilians have forgot to go home, she needs to show that she will not be one of them.

[NancyNguyen 1,657]

a friend of mine has a girlfriend who got a visitor's visa even though her sister is illegally living in the States. Family or no family isn't a reason for denial. I know of another person whose mom has been living illegally in the states for years and she got a visitor's visa as well (although the first time she was denied). I know of another fellow who has no job and his motive for applying for a visa was to see relatives. Whether or not you are denied depends on the mood and attitude of the consular officer. There is no magic formula.

Every case varies, you can't apply your friend's girlfriend to others. The fact is that her daughter is an immigrant in the US, who has pending N400. In IO perspective, it always has intention to immigrate.

[pdking5000 56]

Every case varies, you can't apply your friend's girlfriend to others. The fact is that her daughter is an immigrant in the US, who has pending N400. In IO perspective, it always has intention to immigrate.

the N400 shows intent to immigrate lawfully for the person in question, not for her mother. Regardless, for all tourist applications, every candidate is assumed to have intent to immigrate, even those with no siblings or family in the States.

[Carol & Tim 4]

Thanks everyone for your responses! I am the only child and she works. I don't know what could lead them to deny her. Maybe because I am the only child. That sucks.

And I am sure brazilians are not the only people that"forgot to go home". I know people from other countries that live here illegally. I've done everything the right way and I have never been illegally in this country. We should not judge by race. Thanks.

[Boiler 45,559]

a friend of mine has a girlfriend who got a visitor's visa even though her sister is illegally living in the States. Family or no family isn't a reason for denial. I know of another person whose mom has been living illegally in the states for years and she got a visitor's visa as well (although the first time she was denied). I know of another fellow who has no job and his motive for applying for a visa was to see relatives. Whether or not you are denied depends on the mood and attitude of the consular officer. There is no magic formula.

It is possible she got the visa without lying, however much more likely that she did

[Boiler 45,559]

Thanks everyone for your responses! I am the only child and she works. I don't know what could lead them to deny her. Maybe because I am the only child. That sucks.

And I am sure brazilians are not the only people that"forgot to go home". I know people from other countries that live here illegally. I've done everything the right way and I have never been illegally in this country. We should not judge by race. Thanks.

Who mentioned race?

There is a large Brazilian diaspora which does not help. She was coming alone, what about you Father?

[pdking5000 56]

It is possible she got the visa without lying, however much more likely that she did

actually no. the friend of mine that was denied once and later received her visa said she was going to visit her mother (who is living illegally). In fact, the officer was asking all sorts of questions about her illegal family....

I know people that have gotten visas with entire illegal families in the States and those that couldn't get one despite having no ties to anybody in the US. It is a broken system.

[asisflyer 47]

http://travel.state.gov/content/dam/visas/Statistics/Non-Immigrant-Statistics/RefusalRates/FY14.pdf

Brazil has 3.2% Adjusted Refusal Rate for B visas. This is among the lowest 5% of countries for denials.

Let her go back and try again but with more documentation of ties to Brazil.

#1. Pension, Retirement Savings, Small Business, Job, etc.

#2. Land ownership . etc.

Perhaps also try with a true Touristic Itinerary - Disneyland, reservations at better hotels, etc. etc. and conform more to a true touristic journey moreso than a social visit. Tourists often fit the pattern of touristic activities.

I might also suggest that she consider a GROUP TOUR to the U.S. for the first trip OR travel with a family group among whom one or more have better profile of ties.

Beyond this, does she have special skills ? educational background? professional conferences to attend ? etc.

Edited April 7, 2015 by asisflyer

[pdking5000 56]

I would take the statistics used by the Department of State with a grain of salt. Those numbers aren't real at all. For example, South Africa's denial rate is 2.6%. Lol. Come on, every single South African would be in the States by now if that were true. Really? For those that have been involved with the immigration process, you will know that the government routinely fudges numbers or denies reality. If I call a Tier 2 officer and ask about my K1 case they will say that I am within processing times and that they haven't processed any visas beyond August 2 (which is on their page). Obviously that is not TRUE. There are September and October filers that have been approved. This is but one example of how the stats presented by the government don't reflect reality. Getting a visa from Brazil is harder than the 5% number indicated on the State Department webpage.

Edited April 7, 2015 by pdking5000

[asisflyer 47]

Also as other pointed out - your pending N-400 timed with the tourist visa might have made the CO think that you had an AOS for the Immediate Relative parent of USC in mind...

whereas as a LPR only, the parent would be waiting for a while and not become immediately available for AOS and be a lesser risk.

Either way, different CO, different personality, less nervousness the 2nd time through. Bring more documentation of ties. Give it a whirl.

A person who just buys new land for instance or who runs their own business and has its financials for it is not likely to run off.....

Surely living in her community these years she has demonstrable economic and social ties that perhaps she did not have well documented before.