passport stamp

[jackieandkathy 0]

I read several threads discussing the importance of submitting passport stamps as a primary evidence to show someone was in a country and that makes me a bit worried.

Actually, my fiance was born in Hong Kong and he got HK permanent residency. When he was 12, his whole family moved to the US and later got his US passport there.

However, when he traveled to Hong Kong (4 times in the past 2 years), he used the Hong Kong Identity Card instead of his US passport to enter Hong Kong as it's more convenient to get through the Customs. So there's no stamp on his US passport showing he has been here in the past 2 years. In fact, we didnt even think of the importance of having the stamps, so we just submitted his flight tickets and boarding passes as evidence. (By the way, I have been to the US twice in the past 2 years and have submitted the copies of passport stamps, visas, flight ticket and boarding passes)

Do you guys think we may get an RFE owing to our failure to show the passport stamps ?

On the other hand, I knew that the Hong Kong Immigration Department can retrieve someone's travel records in the past 10 years by providing one's travel document / HK Identity Card. Do you guys think we should get the records back first just in case CSC asks for RFE ?? (I hope this is also a proof showing he has been to here and the records are provided by the HK Government)

[JenT 0]

Wouldn't hurt to have the travel record, just in case you get an RFE... especially if it takes a while to retrieve. I wouldn't send it in unless you do get an RFE, though...

Jen