Knesset Member Walks Back On Facebook Post Calling Palestinian Kids ‘Little Snakes’

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

Knesset Member Walks Back On Facebook Post Calling Palestinian Kids ‘Little Snakes’

An Israeli parliamentarian tries to walk back on a shared post calling Palestinian kids “little snakes” and defining the Gaza crisis as “war”.

A week after Israeli Knesset member Ayelet Shaked shared a Facebook post that referred to the current conflict in Gaza as a “war” and Palestinian children as “little snakes,” she is trying to walk it back—all the while alleging that her life is now at risk because of what she says are the lies I published about it.

In a brief and heated, but voluntary, telephone call with The Daily Beast, the outspoken Zionist attempted to clarify what she posted, which could have been read as an incitement for all-out battle.

“You published against me, a horrible article,” Shaked said as I introduced myself. “A distort[ed] message of what I was saying on Facebook. You know people told me to go to the police actually, because of what you published.”

The piece to which she was referring, published Monday, included language Shaked had shared publicly on her Facebook account.

“What I said is that the people whose heroes are murdering children, we should not do a peace agreement with them,” Shaked told me. “Because in Israel, we—all the public—are ashamed of what happened to Mohammed Abu Khudair.” She’s referring to the 17-year-old Palestinian who was murdered last week; a Jewishextremist, one of six arrested in connection with the crime, has reportedly confessed to the killing.

“But the Palestinian people, they looked at murderers of our children as heroes.”

I asked Shaked why she chose to share that post, which was originally written by Uri Elitzur, whom Shaked described as a former Netanyahu associate and journalist. She replied with the same sentiment, mentioning how Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas has, in the past, reportedly given freed prisoners a lump sum of $50,000 upon their release.

“We in Israel are ashamed of murderers and put them in jail for the rest of their lives. This is the difference between the two people,” Shaked told me.

Shaked spoke in these generalities initially—referring to two sets of people, two polar opposites on a pendulum. The lack of distinction between Hamas, a known radical Islamist enemy of Israel, and the rest of Palestine’s citizens seemed to correspond with the methodology of the Elitzur piece she posted. They’re all part of one united front. They’re all the enemy.

The Knesset member has been called out in the past for her extreme remarks, which don’t always line up with those of her peers in Parliament. One of the founding members of My Israel, a Zionist activist group that opposes BDS (Boycott, Divestments and Sanctions), the 38-year-old Shaked is also frequently the target of subtle sexism, at best referred to as “a young and pretty secular woman.” There was a reddit forum from last year devoted to figuring out how attractive she was compared to a female journalist. But when I attempted to broach this subject, giving her the opportunity to discuss her relationship with the media, Shaked was not interested in any further conversation, cutting me off before I could tell her what I wanted to talk about.

But when I finally got the opportunity to ask her if the use of the word “people” in this conversation meant radical extremists—the presumed culprits of the murder of three Israeli teens—as opposed to the entire population of Palestinian citizens, she responded with a simple: “Yes.” That was not before the following exchange:

“By the way, are you from Canada?” Shaked asked.

“No.”

“Where are you from?”

“I’m in New York.”

“Just to let you know, the guard from the Knesset told me I need a bodyguard because of what you published,” Shaked said shifting the conversation back to her preferred talking points.

“After what you wrote about me on your website, I’m really not interested in talking to you anymore. Sorry,” she said using an impending television interview as a reason for her hurriedness.

When I told her that I simply shared the words that she shared and asked whether she agreed with those words, she replied, “You said that I’m calling for a massacre?… listen I really don’t want to talk to you anymore. You need to accept that.”

Shaked raced off to her alleged television interview before I could engage her in further conversation but that didn’t stop her spokesman, Tal Benesh, from sending a furious follow-up email.

“You took an article of someone else Shaked posted, and put it in her mouth,” he wrote, after acknowledging that she had in fact shared the piece. “Interpreting words based on your own agenda. Doing so, probably, in order for ppl to see your article. In order to get your own 15 sec of glory. i hope you achieved it.”

Yet Benesh didn’t clarify why Shaked had shared the inflammatory language in the first place.

“Based on what you did, i suggest you should be careful next time you singing an Ace of Base song, so that, god forrbid, no onecall you a Nazi. or also be careful when you see Woody Ellen’s [sic] movies so that no one will blame you you are a children rapist,” Benesh told me in his email.

“These are my words, my personal point of view," wrote Benesh in his email, "and i want to tell you: you are part of this war Gideon. Doing something like that is raising hatred and separatism In the world.”

Link

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

What happened in the other thread?

[Jacque67 7,328]

What happened in the other thread?

My post was deleted for some bizarre reason. I have got an idea of who reported me. This one will be closed soon!!

Criticism of Israel is not allowed.

Edited July 11, 2014 by Jacque67

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

It's no more controversial than any of the threads on this board.

Quite deliberately I didn't editorialise the OP.

[Jacque67 7,328]

It's no more controversial than any of the threads on this board.

Quite deliberately I didn't editorialise the OP.

Tell me about it. But it appears only Israelis have the right to talk about Israel. So much for debate.

[Harpa Timsah 13,258]

Well I don't know about you guys, but I love to wake up and see people who I thought were my friends wishing for my husband's parents to be nuked, and saying that they hate my husband because of where he was born.

It's fine if you don't like Israel, but to wish for death and hate? There is some serious moral relevancy at display here, if you can't see what is wrong with that.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

I didn't see what was posted but I certainly don't wish for that.

[Jacque67 7,328]

Well I don't know about you guys, but I love to wake up and see people who I thought were my friends wishing for my husband's parents to be nuked, and saying that they hate my husband because of where he was born.

It's fine if you don't like Israel, but to wish for death and hate? There is some serious moral relevancy at display here, if you can't see what is wrong with that.

Well, I certainly don't wish for Israel to be nuked. But I was put out that my comment in a previous thread was deleted when IMO it was an observation - can't repeat it , alas.

[Harpa Timsah 13,258]

I didn't see what was posted but I certainly don't wish for that.

Well that was what was posted, and you can see another in this thread here. It wasn't closed for the topic of the OP, from what I can tell.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

I get that Shaked might be an Fringe figure, but the comment she made was almost identical to one a poster made yesterday in a different thread. Now that guy is trying to say she doesn't speak for everyone.

I can accept that, but at the same time, if you don't agree with the sentiment why say almost the exact same thing? You either rate the sentiment or you don't.

[Jacque67 7,328]

I didn't see what was posted but I certainly don't wish for that.

I didn't wish for Israel to be nuked in my comment on that thread. I stated something that many of my (Jewish, anti-Zionist friends) have said.

Disgusted that it was removed.

Sulk.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

Well that was what was posted, and you can see another in this thread here. It wasn't closed for the topic of the OP, from what I can tell.

Which is strange as it wasn't changed from the title of the quoted article. It's perfectly fine if someone with an Israeli passport wants to hand it in because they don't like the political climate.

Surely all of the controversy is what people bring to the issue.

[Novembro 1,763]

Well that was what was posted, and you can see another in this thread here. It wasn't closed for the topic of the OP, from what I can tell.

Mine was a joke. If it's offensive, I'll remove it.

[Jacque67 7,328]

Well that was what was posted, and you can see another in this thread here. It wasn't closed for the topic of the OP, from what I can tell.

Lies. I did not say that Israel should be nuked. Not anything close to it. My mother spent some of her best years on a kibbutz.

How dare you imply that I wrote such a comment on the other thread. Shame on you!

[Harpa Timsah 13,258]

Lies. I did not say that Israel should be nuked. Not anything close to it. My mother spent some of her best years on a kibbutz.

How dare you imply that I wrote such a comment on the other thread. Shame on you!

I know exactly what you said, and it involved hating all modern Israelis, and I never implied that you said nuke.

I said two statements, one is here (the nuke comment) and the other was removed in the other thread.

Edited July 11, 2014 by Harpa Timsah