AMERICAN IDOL

[chri'stina 190]

My top 4 favorites are still in too.

I like all of them, so I'll be happy no matter what.

But, I think Blake might be my favorite!! Because of his originality and being able to arrange the music to what he wants(like jen above said).

The girls all have awesome voices, but I don't know. Blake really has become my favorite. I like his darker hair too. Melinda is the best singer, but I am not sure if she could sell much "pop" music. Jordin could, not sure about Lakisha. But I do like them all.

[Robor007 0]

if blake keeps doing really original arrangements of songs like he did this week... i might have to change my vote and say i'd like him to win! but allllllllllll up until this week i haven't loved him. but THAT was talent. he can sing AND arrange a song to be very unique.

but i still love jordin best, then melinda, then lakisha. i think either lakisha or blake will go next week.

Blake's voice is average at best and by far the worst of the 4 *singers* left. Plus he looks like a goofball when he sings.

I thought his beatbox stuff was terrible - very original but very terrible.

Jordin > Melinda >>>> Lakisha >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Blake

Reminder: This is still a singing competition. American Idol doesn't need another Taylor Hicks (personality > voice).

[brnidokiegurl 0]

Everyone ready? Who will it be?

[keltic 1]

so, the order i think they will go home now:

phil

chris

blake

lakisha*

jordin*

and melinda will win it

*not sure between lakisha and jordin

i still stand by this, but i think tonight will truly be about how each one performs...

my guess is that blake is next to go, then jordin, then lakisha, then melinda is the winner

however, if blake puts out a strong performance and lakisha is off... or if jordin is off... it could be one of them that goes this week...

its hard now, because i like all of the remaining 4... but, i still think melinda is gonna take it all after a battle of the "divas"

Edited May 8, 2007 by keltic

[sereia 0]

wow~ jordin is still my favorite! she blew all the rest away! (this is half way through....)

melinda #2

lakisha #3

and blake, sorry buddy....#4!

[Mary Lou 682]

So far im not impressed with anyone tonight.

Jordin did sing one of my fav BeeGee songs tho

[brnidokiegurl 0]

Think Blakes gone

[Robor007 0]

Jordin >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Melinda >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Lakisha >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Blake

Jordin was awesome tonight. On 'Woman in Love' Randy says everything is 'pitchy' and Simon criticized her outfit choice. Whatever!

Melinda was pretty good but the theme didn't fit her style. I think she did pretty well with it though.

Lakisha was average at best. Her lisp and screaming high notes pretty much eliminate her chance of winning but she should be around next week just because of...

Blake. Wow - that - was - bad. I was embarrassed for him. Welcome to the techno version of Taylor Hicks. He should be gone but it's AI so he'll probably be in the top 2.

[sereia 0]

robor i agree 100%!!!!!

[Jenn! 918]

I completely agree with Randy that Jordin was off pitch during that last song. I doubt that Randy has perfect pitch, but IMO it was not hard to hear that she was flat. It was a tough song to sing, and those notes were up there, so it's not surprising. She's not Barbra Streisand.

I'm still with Melinda.

[Mary Lou 682]

Blake was bad tonight, i was so bored with his songs, in fact had the last one been on the radio, i would have turned it off.

Like i said before i wasnt really impressed by anyone tonight, Melinda has a solid voice though even though i didnt like her songs.

I was shocked at how old Barry Gibb looked, he needs to either dye his hair to match his beard or vice versa lol Still when he sang he sounded good.

[MichelleandCraig 1]

I agree ML, he still sounds good anyway! I'm still with Melinda, too. Yeah, some days are better than others for her (for everyone, right??) and this wasn't her best style....but she is just so great anyway,and she sounds so natural..makes it look effortless. For sure it *should* be a Melinda/Jordin final, but who knows...it IS idol. I still do like everyone who made the top four though, so at least it won't be a final where I'm going...omg, omg, omg pleaseeeeeeeee don't let _____ win; I will be sooooooooo mad! M.

[sereia 0]

i'm sooooooooo disappointed i forgot to vote last night! i always wait a while before i try calling (busy signals) and i ended up forgetting! if jordin goes i'll be so sad maybe my 10 votes would have pushed her over the edge! LOLOL!!

i hope its jordin/melinda in the finals too. i like jordin better, but i do recognize she needs some serious voice training after the show is over and she'll be AMAZING.

[Sinergy 3]

i dunno, i like blake still. i like uniqueness. melinda i dunno, her facial expressions scare me. lakisha isnt doing well anymore, jordin, still awesome.

[brnidokiegurl 0]

Blake does do good most of the time but he has to realize the entire crowd he will sing to, he doesnt have to do that to every song but add some variety for the rest once in a while