AMERICAN IDOL

[Robor007 0]

I think the contestants that have already been voted off were far better singers then Sanjaya but I don't think they would have made it to the Top 3, so in the long run it doesn't really matter....

I totally agree there. There's very few seasons where someone got voted off early on and could have won it all. Stephanie was good and probably good enough to finish 3rd or 4th but she's not Melinda, Jordin, or Lakisha good. I think Chris Sligh was better than all of the males but I don't think any of the guys should make the top 3.

In the end I don't think the VFTW losers or that bird-face Howard Stern are influencing who wins. The thing that bothers me is instead of hearing Chris or Stephanie tonight I have to hear Suckjaya - I mean FF through his 'performance'. Oh well, it just means less time wasted watching TV. That's good, right?

[brnidokiegurl 0]

[Otto 83]

I think the contestants that have already been voted off were far better singers then Sanjaya but I don't think they would have made it to the Top 3, so in the long run it doesn't really matter....

I totally agree there. There's very few seasons where someone got voted off early on and could have won it all. Stephanie was good and probably good enough to finish 3rd or 4th but she's not Melinda, Jordin, or Lakisha good. I think Chris Sligh was better than all of the males but I don't think any of the guys should make the top 3.

In the end I don't think the VFTW losers or that bird-face Howard Stern are influencing who wins. The thing that bothers me is instead of hearing Chris or Stephanie tonight I have to hear Suckjaya - I mean FF through his 'performance'. Oh well, it just means less time wasted watching TV. That's good, right?

Bird Face...?

[Aymerlu 3]

Melinda was AWESOME!!!!

[Otto 83]

Gotta Admit...Blake hit that one pretty good...

(of course Melinda nailed it... )

Edited April 4, 2007 by Karin und Otto

[Mary Lou 681]

Melinda was AWESOME!!!!

I agree, she even showed a bit more personality tonight.

[Aymerlu 3]

Oh dear God....Sanjaya

[Mary Lou 681]

He really thinks he's good All the little girls in the audience with their I love Sanjaya signs The thing that is a real shame though, are singers who are better then him are getting voted off.

[brnidokiegurl 0]

Most all of them did good (except) the kid.....he sounds the same each week and he seems to think hes mr cool now

[Aymerlu 3]

Most all of them did good (except) the kid.....he sounds the same each week and he seems to think hes mr cool now

Oh he's a hottie!!!! ***JK***

[brnidokiegurl 0]

I KNEW you HAD to be kidding

[Mary Lou 681]

I thought Haley was awful tonight. Then again i never have liked her singing. The judges never even commented on her performance. I liked Chris R tonight, of course Melinda, Jordin and Blake.

Bottom 3 should be Phil, Haley and Sanjaya, even tho it will probably be Gina.

[bostonparis 0]

I feel bad for Sanjaya. He knows what everyone is saying about him - what's he supposed to do but make the best of it? Imagine if you were 17 and were in his position.

Haley screwed herself by basically saying that she only cares about what Simon says. Randy and Paula were maaaad!!

[Otto 83]

[Otto 83]

He really thinks he's good All the little girls in the audience with their I love Sanjaya signs The thing that is a real shame though, are singers who are better then him are getting voted off.

"Sanjaya Is My Papaya".... I can't stop laughing...