AMERICAN IDOL

[keltic 1]

Phil - good, but not unique

Jared - good performance, still not unique tho

AJ - smooth voice, but not unique

Sanjaya – good voice, but boring – lacks the confidence needed

Chris Sligh - liked him

Nick - not enough “sexy” in his voice to cut this song; just singing, not feeling it

Blake - best so far… really liked him

Brandon - bland

Chris Richardson - did well, but it just didn’t do it for me

Sundance - good song choice and much better than last week

i liked chris sligh and blake the best tonight, but i think they wont be able to beat the girls

[anya-D 8]

AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!

I LOVE THE GUYS TONIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I like most of them and I cant choose which to vote for!! I LOVE SUNDANCE TONIGHT!!!

I hope Sanjaya gone next week.. he's too young and has a stage shy.. he can comeback when he's ready or older.. he has a nice voice but he's just too young for the stage.... I dont know who else should go home..

[brnidokiegurl 0]

most were better but still not up with the girls, Sundance, Chris, Jared

[Robor007 0]

Vote early and often. I will.

http://www.votefortheworst.com/

Poo on you

if you don't like American Idol..... why waste your energy on it??

It's just entertainment. Don't take it too seriously.

If you bother to vote against, you do. I watch (on DVR because it's a must) and I don't vote.

[Robor007 0]

Sorry to be against popular opinion but IMO the guys were mostly awful tonight - again. I said last week that only 3-4 of the 12 had a chance of winning and I stand by it. I saw only 3 guys that even have a chance at winning and based on voice alone there's really only 1...

Chris Sligh - Best voice and performance of show again, period

Blake Lewis - He's not my style but he's got a lot of talent and given the weak field tonight I put him 2

Phil Stacy - Didn't like his song choice this week but he didn't totally suck and based on last week I hope he'll rebound

Chris Richardson - Sounded very 'pop' and did it well but not my style. Probably not versicle enough to last it out.

The rest... Sang their songs weakly behind their background vocals and none of them made me think they had a chance of winning. They should vote 6 guys off this week. They're nothing but FF buttons on a DVR at this point.

[Autumnchik 6]

I have to say, I am glad Sundance finally sang decently. Also liked Blake, but honestly, my favorite thing about Blake is his beat boxing, not his singing. Liked Chris Sligh a lot. Thought Chris Richardson was good but a bit too "pop" to suit me .... think he will do well in this though and maybe will change my mind down the road

[Marilyn. 340]

I think the reason they all liked Sundance was because he chose an upbeat song that hid how bad his voice really is..... people were just into the beat of the song....

I think there should only be about 3 guys in the Top 12 and the rest girls.....

[Hilarious Clinton 452]

Vote early and often. I will.

http://www.votefortheworst.com/

Poo on you

if you don't like American Idol..... why waste your energy on it??

It's just entertainment. Don't take it too seriously.

If you bother to vote against, you do. I watch (on DVR because it's a must) and I don't vote.

You got me there DVR master.

[Jenn! 918]

I thought the guys overall did a much better job than last week. But they still don't compare at all to some of the girls.

My faves were Phil, AJ, Blake, Chris Richardson, and Sundance actually.

I thought Chris Sligh's version of Trouble wasn't nearly as good as when Elliot sang it last year.

Dialidol is predicting that

Brandon and Nick

will leave.

[Jenn! 918]

I thought the guys overall did a much better job than last week. But they still don't compare at all to some of the girls.

My faves were Phil, AJ, Blake, Chris Richardson, and Sundance actually.

I thought Chris Sligh's version of Trouble wasn't nearly as good as when Elliot sang it last year.

Dialidol is predicting that

Brandon and Nick

will leave.

Here's a good summary/review of last night's performances from Entertainment Weekly: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20013629,00.html

I guess it was Taylor that sang Trouble last year, woops! Why did I think it was Elliot???

[Marilyn. 340]

I thought the guys overall did a much better job than last week. But they still don't compare at all to some of the girls.

My faves were Phil, AJ, Blake, Chris Richardson, and Sundance actually.

I thought Chris Sligh's version of Trouble wasn't nearly as good as when Elliot sang it last year.

Dialidol is predicting that

Brandon and Nick

will leave.

Here's a good summary/review of last night's performances from Entertainment Weekly: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20013629,00.html

I guess it was Taylor that sang Trouble last year, woops! Why did I think it was Elliot???

Elliot sang it too... in week 9 but I don't think it is the same song...

# Week 9: Elvis Presley

* "If I Can Dream" (Elvis Presley)

o Jackson loved it, Abdul appeared teary-eyed and said it was his "best performance vocally in this competition," and Cowell said he believed that Yamin was "coming in as the underdog" and had had "the best performance of the night so far."

* "Trouble" (Elvis Presley)

o Jackson said it was his "best performance ever." Abdul declared that, "Now, this was your best performance ever in this competition." Cowell said he was showing personality and "deserve[d]to go onto the next round."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliott_Yamin

Taylor sang Trouble (Ray LaMontagne).....

Yeah, they are two different songs with the same name.....

Elvis Presley

Title Trouble

f you're looking for trouble

You came to the right place

If you're looking for trouble

Just look right in my face

I was born standing up

And talking back

My daddy was a green-eyed mountain jack

Because I'm evil, my middle name is misery

Well I'm evil, so don't you mess around with me

http://www.lyricsvault.net/songs/5069.html

Trouble... by Ray LaMontagne

Trouble, trouble, trouble, trouble

Trouble been doggin' my soul since the day I was born

Worry...

Worry, worry, worry, worry

Worry just will not seem to leave my mind alone

We'll I've been...

saved by a woman

I've been...

saved by a woman

I've been...

saved by a woman

She won't let me go

She won't let me go now

She won't let me go

She won't let me go now

http://www.raylamontagne.com/lyrics.php

Edited February 28, 2007 by MarilynP

[Jenn! 918]

Ah thanks, Marilyn, that must be why I was confused! Still doesn't explain why I thought that Eliot's version was better than Chris'. I was comparing renditions of two different songs!

[CarolineM 0]

Can't wait for tonight

[CarolineM 0]

Antonella's GOT TO GO.

[JenT 0]

Antonella's GOT TO GO.

Kids are watching it now. Celine Dion? What was she thinking?