Denied Visa at Interview

[Harpa Timsah 13,258]

Does this proof of domicile stuff apply if you're sending in stuff to the NVC and are a US resident? Do they require something extra at the NVC stage, like a voter registration card or driver's license?

No, if you live in the US you don't need it. That's why it's not mentioned in the guides. It is covered in the DCF guides.

[Confusedtinybird 41]

Not just for DCF actually and why sites like this and selfless members that share are valuable for research.

A lot of these thinsg are not published and sometimes for good reasons by the emabssy so as to not create a scammers bible of sorts.

Yes, but would be nice if DCF could be the same for every country.

Agree without this site would be very lost!

[r060106 109]

No, if you live in the US you don't need it. That's why it's not mentioned in the guides. It is covered in the DCF guides.

Alright, thank you. Sorry for the confusion.

[belinda63 3,038]

They are looking for proof of where you will live when you enter the US. What good is it to issue an immigrant visa and have the person hop off the plane in the US with nowhere to go? Obtain a letter from the person you will be living with, a copy of the rental agreement for the housing, copy of the mortgage papers, whatever applies to prove you have a place for you and your spouse to live when you arrive.

[WrotoMco 0]

They are looking for proof of where you will live when you enter the US. What good is it to issue an immigrant visa and have the person hop off the plane in the US with nowhere to go? Obtain a letter from the person you will be living with, a copy of the rental agreement for the housing, copy of the mortgage papers, whatever applies to prove you have a place for you and your spouse to live when you arrive.

Great point. Thanks for clarifying this. I was having trouble wrapping my head around their motive, but this makes sense and is something I can definitely provide.

THANK YOU to everyone for your helpful responses. I feel a lot better to hear from others who have been or who are going through this.

this is ridiculous! you love this man, you got married, you made a family and your government wants you to leave your husband for ... nobody knows for how long cause these procedures take a bunch of time. it's against humans rights.

there are procedures in Poland too but separating family members is prohibited.

maybe the officer you were talking to or the one that interviewed your husband had a bad day.

can you please keep me updated cause our situation is very similar.

wish you luck!!! stay strong!!!

I will keep you posted. Good luck to you, as I am sure you will be going through the Warsaw Embassy too.

[WrotoMco 0]

I wanted to update you all on what has happened with our case.

I am submitted the following as proof of US domicile per Form I-864 Instructions:

1. Letter from my bank showing an active US bank account

2. Statements from E*Trade Securities LLC showing US stocks owned

3. Statement from Capital One showing my US mailing address

4. Statements from PayPal showing transfers made from PLN to USD (x3)

5. A copy of my US voter registration card

6. A copy of my Karta Pobytu decision showing my status as a temporary resident in Poland

7. A letter from mom confirming that my husband I will live at her home upon our arrival in the US

8. A letter from a company stating their intent to employ me upon my return to the US

...and we were still denied.

Any other ideas?

Anyone from Poland made it through this process?

[WrotoMco 0]

Hello,

My husband and I are applying for his visa through the consulate in Warsaw. We have a joint sponsor for the affidavit of support. I have spent the last three years living in Poland and this seems to be our biggest barrier now as they want me to return to US before they will grant his visa.

I am submitted the following as proof of US domicile per Form I-864 Instructions:

1. Letter from my bank showing an active US bank account

2. Statements from E*Trade Securities LLC showing US stocks owned

3. Statement from Capital One showing my US mailing address

4. Statements from PayPal showing transfers made from PLN to USD (x3)

5. A copy of my US voter registration card

6. A copy of my Karta Pobytu decision showing my status as a temporary resident in Poland

7. A letter from mom confirming that my husband I will live at her home upon our arrival in the US

8. A letter from a company stating their intent to employ me upon my return to the US

...and we were still denied.

Any other ideas?

Anyone from Poland made it through this process?

Thanks for your help

[WrotoMco 0]

Hello,

My husband and I are applying for his visa through the consulate in Warsaw. We have a joint sponsor for the affidavit of support. I have spent the last three years living in Poland and this seems to be our biggest barrier now as they want me to return to US before they will grant his visa.

I am submitted the following as proof of US domicile per Form I-864 Instructions:

1. Letter from my bank showing an active US bank account

2. Statements from E*Trade Securities LLC showing US stocks owned

3. Statement from Capital One showing my US mailing address

4. Statements from PayPal showing transfers made from PLN to USD (x3)

5. A copy of my US voter registration card

6. A copy of my Karta Pobytu decision showing my status as a temporary resident in Poland

7. A letter from mom confirming that my husband I will live at her home upon our arrival in the US

8. A letter from a company stating their intent to employ me upon my return to the US

...and we were still denied.

Any other ideas?

Anyone from Poland made it through this process?

Thanks for your help

[lost_at_sea 995]

Wow, if that list didn't work on them, then you may have to go back to the USA ahead of your partner. I'm really surprised. You're 100% sure it's the domicile aspect you were denied for?

Other things you could consider:

* Actually signing up for and getting a lease on a place to live (rather than staying with family)

* Actually accepting and starting a job with a US employer

* Did you manage to keep a driving licence?

* Making plans for the move (such as shipping your household items, or obtaining a quote to do so)

* Any kids? Getting them school placements.

[Darnell 8,478]

that's weird , as 7 and 8 show clear intent to re-establish domicile in the USA.

[dwheels76 5,468]

I wanted to update you all on what has happened with our case.

I am submitted the following as proof of US domicile per Form I-864 Instructions:

1. Letter from my bank showing an active US bank account

2. Statements from E*Trade Securities LLC showing US stocks owned

3. Statement from Capital One showing my US mailing address

4. Statements from PayPal showing transfers made from PLN to USD (x3)

5. A copy of my US voter registration card

6. A copy of my Karta Pobytu decision showing my status as a temporary resident in Poland

7. A letter from mom confirming that my husband I will live at her home upon our arrival in the US

8. A letter from a company stating their intent to employ me upon my return to the US

...and we were still denied.

Any other ideas?

Anyone from Poland made it through this process?

Really look over this domicile list again. I guess you re-establishing you need more proof you are coming.

Intent to employ is it an actual job offer with start date and contract agreement?

Registration in school for you.

You want to show you are really coming back sign up get any and all memberships whatever you can sign up for to show you are resident setting up shop.

well here's the list from the NVC filers thread.

What if I (the petitioner) live with my spouse in their foreign country? Do I need to include anything in either package?

You'll need to provide proof of US domicile with the AOS package, as well as bring it with you to the interview. Please read the I-864 instructions (pages 3 and 4) for information about it. This is NOT needed if the petitioner is living in the US. Here is a sample cover letter to include in the package (it lists MANY possible documents, some may not be applicable of course, to prove that you have, or will re-establish, domicile in the US):

NAME

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER

FORM I-1864

No. 15 Country of Domicile

I, XXXX, am currently residing in FOREIGN COUNTRY with my spouse, SPOUSE'S NAME. Below you will find a list of attached documents to show that my principle residence is in the US and the steps that I have taken to return to the US with my family.

Steps I have taken to maintain US Domicile:

• Maintained my XXXX voter registration

• Maintained my XXXX credit card registered in the US with a US PO box

• Maintained my bank account at the XXXX Credit Union

• Maintained my bank account at XXXX Bank

• Maintained my XXXX drivers license

• Maintained my US retirement fund through XXXX

• Maintained my US investment account with XXXX

• Maintained my US PO box

• Maintained licensure by the XXXX

• Maintained membership in the XXXX

• Maintained my automobile in care of my parents

Supporting Documents for the above steps I have taken:

• Voter registration card showing permanent US address

• XXXX credit card statement showing US billing address

• XXXX Credit Union statement showing permanent US address

• XXXX Bank statement showing permanent US address

• XXXX drivers license showing permanent US address

• Retirement fund statement showing permanent US address

• Mutual fund statement showing permanent US address

• XXXX license currently up to date

• Renewal of XXXX membership

• County tax bill showing I still own a vehicle

Steps I have taken to return to the US to take up residence:

• Made arrangements for us to have a house to live in

• Contacted schools for requirements of things to bring to register my children in school

• Contacted my auto insurance company to find out about re-instating my insurance on my car

• Contacted shipping company for estimate of costs to ship belongings

Supporting documents for the above steps I have taken:

• Lease agreement for our house

• Email from schools regarding registration requirements

• Email from my former auto insurance company regarding my inquiry

• Email from XXXX with estimate and correspondence regarding shipping our belongings

I declare that I intend in good faith to re-establish my domicile in the United States no later than the date of spouse's admission into the US.

I certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the statements in this letter and all accompanying evidence are true and correct.

Signature: ____________________________________________________ Date: ______________________

NAME

Thanks to VJ member lemayz for this suggestion!

Edited November 12, 2013 by dwheels76

[PhilLuv 43]

They have probably made up their minds based on the previous refusal, who knows. Good luck as you go through this ordeal. There is light in the tunnel.

[Darnell 8,478]

please note that formletter contains BOTH paths, and must be edited before using it for submission, taking out the path that doesn't apply.

OP - suggest you get into the Consulate during an ACS (American Citizen Services) appointment and ask a Vice Consul, directly, what proof they are requiring, and ask if they were evaluating 'proof of domicile' or 'proof of re-establishing USA domicile'.

[WrotoMco 0]

Really look over this domicile list again. I guess you re-establishing you need more proof you are coming.

Intent to employ is it an actual job offer with start date and contract agreement?

Registration in school for you.

You want to show you are really coming back sign up get any and all memberships whatever you can sign up for to show you are resident setting up shop.

well here's the list from the NVC filers thread.

What if I (the petitioner) live with my spouse in their foreign country? Do I need to include anything in either package?

You'll need to provide proof of US domicile with the AOS package, as well as bring it with you to the interview. Please read the I-864 instructions (pages 3 and 4) for information about it. This is NOT needed if the petitioner is living in the US. Here is a sample cover letter to include in the package (it lists MANY possible documents, some may not be applicable of course, to prove that you have, or will re-establish, domicile in the US):

NAME

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER

FORM I-1864

No. 15 Country of Domicile

I, XXXX, am currently residing in FOREIGN COUNTRY with my spouse, SPOUSE'S NAME. Below you will find a list of attached documents to show that my principle residence is in the US and the steps that I have taken to return to the US with my family.

Steps I have taken to maintain US Domicile:

• Maintained my XXXX voter registration

• Maintained my XXXX credit card registered in the US with a US PO box

• Maintained my bank account at the XXXX Credit Union

• Maintained my bank account at XXXX Bank

• Maintained my XXXX drivers license

• Maintained my US retirement fund through XXXX

• Maintained my US investment account with XXXX

• Maintained my US PO box

• Maintained licensure by the XXXX

• Maintained membership in the XXXX

• Maintained my automobile in care of my parents

Supporting Documents for the above steps I have taken:

• Voter registration card showing permanent US address

• XXXX credit card statement showing US billing address

• XXXX Credit Union statement showing permanent US address

• XXXX Bank statement showing permanent US address

• XXXX drivers license showing permanent US address

• Retirement fund statement showing permanent US address

• Mutual fund statement showing permanent US address

• XXXX license currently up to date

• Renewal of XXXX membership

• County tax bill showing I still own a vehicle

Steps I have taken to return to the US to take up residence:

• Made arrangements for us to have a house to live in

• Contacted schools for requirements of things to bring to register my children in school

• Contacted my auto insurance company to find out about re-instating my insurance on my car

• Contacted shipping company for estimate of costs to ship belongings

Supporting documents for the above steps I have taken:

• Lease agreement for our house

• Email from schools regarding registration requirements

• Email from my former auto insurance company regarding my inquiry

• Email from XXXX with estimate and correspondence regarding shipping our belongings

I declare that I intend in good faith to re-establish my domicile in the United States no later than the date of spouse's admission into the US.

I certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the statements in this letter and all accompanying evidence are true and correct.

Signature: ____________________________________________________ Date: ______________________

NAME

Thanks to VJ member lemayz for this suggestion!

I wont be attending school again, so registering for one is out. Its difficult to get an actual employment contract when I am not there and we dont know when we will be able to go. I've seen this letter and its great, but I am not able to get everything they submitted...

Basically the embassy has said that I must return to US before they will issue the visa. Is this allowed?

[WrotoMco 0]

They are pretty much insisting that I go ahead of him. Can they do that??

I have a valid driver's license, but I lost it and I can only get a replacement in person. I am attempted to sign a lease, but they seem pretty set on me returning solo and I dont want to spend the money if the effort will just be wasted.

No kids..