RFE: Primary VS Secondary evidence FEED BACK PLEASE

[CANbirdUSman 11]

Ideally you'd have ticket stubs of you going to Canada, or perhaps ticket stubs of her coming here as far as primary evidence. Credit card statements of you in Canada would also be helpful. It would be even better if you both had statements showing transactions at the same place and the same time (like if you split dinner and could come up with statements showing transactions at the same restaurant).

Hello from the Canadian beneficiary. Our RFE package has been sent off already. We'll see what transpires.

[CANbirdUSman 11]

Yes, I submitted every airfare receipt from every time we ever met (from the first time in 2007 through the most recent before filing). I think there was only 1 we didn't have still. It was a ton of them. The problem was all the receipts were emails. Nothing in the original instructions says emails aren't acceptable proof.

Yes we submitted the letters of intent. They just felt the need to ask for them again I guess?

You're welcome for the detailed list. Don't think everything on there was necessarily needed but at the point we were RFE'd I wasn't taking chances and went right into overkill mode. I took the keep it short and simple, bare minimum approach in the first place and when we got the RFE went a full 180. Wasn't going to risk a denial or further delay.

TOTAL felt the same way.

The California Service Center received our evidence Friday May 4th. Looking forward to hearing something 'within 60 days'...

[CANbirdUSman 11]

Ideally you'd have ticket stubs of you going to Canada, or perhaps ticket stubs of her coming here as far as primary evidence. Credit card statements of you in Canada would also be helpful. It would be even better if you both had statements showing transactions at the same place and the same time (like if you split dinner and could come up with statements showing transactions at the same restaurant).

We sent 1 1/2 lbs of evidence. Mostly credit card statements showing transactions my fiance, the USC made while he was visiting me in CANADA. And he rarely uses cash, so LOTS of transactions over the 2 year period 2009-2011. A few 'ticket stubs', but mostly 'ticket' receipts from him, the USC, traveling to Vancouver/CANADA. I included my visits to the USA of course, but he comes here more often.

Everything is now in the hands of someone else. Good thing both of us are patient.

Edited May 7, 2012 by CANbirdUSman

[CANbirdUSman 11]

Request For Evidence (RFE) reply: I-129F approved!

It only took 6 days for the decision to get made. Sweet!

[shydon 0]

Request For Evidence (RFE) reply: I-129F approved!

It only took 6 days for the decision to get made. Sweet!

congratulations!! i hope we will also receive our NOA2.. the CSC received our RFE reply today.. Me and my fiance are looking forward for the NOA2!