Koran Burning at U.S. Base Sparks Afghan Protests

[mounir412 101]

Troops on the U.S.'s largest base in Afghanistan have inadvertently burned Korans and other religious materials, triggering angry protests and fears of even larger demonstrations as news of the burning spreads.

The books were mistakenly thrown out with the trash at Bagram Air Field north of Kabul and were on a burn pile Monday night before Afghan laborers intervened around 11:00 p.m., according to NATO and Afghan officials.

The workers doused the flames with their jackets and mineral water before marching out of Bagram in a fury, carrying with them the charred remains, according to Sabir Safar, secretary of the provincial council of Parwan, the province where Bagram is located.

By the morning, hundreds of demonstrators gathered outside of Bagram and on the outskirts of Kabul. Some shot into the air, some threw rocks at the Bagram gate, and others yelled, "Die, die foreigners." Many of them were the same people who work with foreign troops inside the base. At one point, apparently worried that the base would be stormed, guards at the base fired rubber bullets into the crowd, according to the military.

"They should leave Afghanistan rather than disrespecting our religion, our faith," Mohammad Hakim told the Associated Press outside of Bagram. "They have to leave and if next time they disrespect our religion, we will defend our holy Koran, religion and faith until the last drop of blood has left in our body."

There is perhaps no action that enrages Afghans more than foreigners' mistreating the Koran. It taps into widespread doubt of whether Americans respect Islam as well as deep frustration that, more than 10 years after the Taliban were overthrown, violence remains widespread. Korans are supposed to be buried or released into a flowing river if they need to be disposed.

NATO officials scrambled furiously to contain the fallout, tweeting and emailing reporters not long after the first protests began. Gen. John Allen, the commander of all foreign forces in Afghanistan, released a statement, then a video statement, then gave an interview to NATO television. In his and in all NATO officials' communication today, each emphasized that the burning was unintentional.

"Those materials were inadvertently given to troops for disposition and that disposition was to burn the materials. It was not a decision that was made because they were religious materials," Allen told NATO TV. "It was not a decision that was made with respect to the faith of Islam. It was a mistake, it was an error. The moment we found out about it we immediately stopped and we intervened."

Allen launched an investigation and promised to take steps that the same incident would not be repeated.

"This is not who we are. These are very, very isolated incidents," Allen said. "We've been dying alongside the Afghans for a long time because we believe in them, we believe in their country, we want to have every opportunity to give them a bright future."

In the morning, U.S. officials on Bagram escorted local Afghan elders to the site of the burning. Ahmad Zaki Zahed, the chief of the provincial council, said 60 to 70 books had been recovered from the fire, including Korans that were once used by detainees at the base.

"Some were all burned. Some were half-burned," Zahed told the Associated Press.

The protesters' fury was immediate, but Afghan officials eventually calmed them down by the afternoon. They demanded to see President Hamid Karzai and threatened to resume demonstrations.

Previous reports of Koran burning have led to deadly protests in Afghanistan. In April, 2011, after a fringe protester burned a Koran, a mob in a usually peaceful northern city stormed the United Nations compound and killed at least seven foreigners. In May, 2005, Afghan police killed at least four demonstrators angry over a report that an American interrogator in Guantanamo Bay prison flushed a Koran down a toilet.

While today's reaction was quick and furious, the protests might have been larger if it wasn't snowing and if it had happened at a different time. Many Afghans did not know about the burning because it occurred late last night and news is generally consumed during television newscasts in the evenings, at home. Many Afghans and Westerners fear that protests could get larger Wednesday and the rest of the week.

"Past demonstrations in Afghanistan have escalated into violent attacks on Western targets of opportunity," the U.S. embassy said in statement known as a Warden Message, sent to Americans living in Afghanistan. "U.S. citizens in Afghanistan should remain vigilant and avoid areas where Westerners congregate. Avoid large public gatherings or demonstrations. Do not discuss travel plans or other personal matters with strangers, or in public."

Far to the south, in an area where a surge of U.S. troops has removed many Taliban safehavens, insurgents reminded the local population that they still held considerable sway.

In the Washer district of Helmand, insurgents beheaded four people they accused of spying for the U.S., according to the Helmand governor's spokesman. The Taliban denied any involvement in the executions, claiming they were carried out by Western intelligence officials to bring the Taliban a bad name.

Also Read

[I AM NOT THAT GUY 5,715]

Oops! How could Obama have let something like this happen?

[luckytxn 2,264]

Troops on the U.S.'s largest base in Afghanistan have inadvertently burned Korans and other religious materials, triggering angry protests and fears of even larger demonstrations as news of the burning spreads.

The books were mistakenly thrown out with the trash at Bagram Air Field north of Kabul and were on a burn pile Monday night before Afghan laborers intervened around 11:00 p.m., according to NATO and Afghan officials.

The workers doused the flames with their jackets and mineral water before marching out of Bagram in a fury, carrying with them the charred remains, according to Sabir Safar, secretary of the provincial council of Parwan, the province where Bagram is located.

By the morning, hundreds of demonstrators gathered outside of Bagram and on the outskirts of Kabul. Some shot into the air, some threw rocks at the Bagram gate, and others yelled, "Die, die foreigners." Many of them were the same people who work with foreign troops inside the base. At one point, apparently worried that the base would be stormed, guards at the base fired rubber bullets into the crowd, according to the military.

"They should leave Afghanistan rather than disrespecting our religion, our faith," Mohammad Hakim told the Associated Press outside of Bagram. "They have to leave and if next time they disrespect our religion, we will defend our holy Koran, religion and faith until the last drop of blood has left in our body."

There is perhaps no action that enrages Afghans more than foreigners' mistreating the Koran. It taps into widespread doubt of whether Americans respect Islam as well as deep frustration that, more than 10 years after the Taliban were overthrown, violence remains widespread. Korans are supposed to be buried or released into a flowing river if they need to be disposed.

NATO officials scrambled furiously to contain the fallout, tweeting and emailing reporters not long after the first protests began. Gen. John Allen, the commander of all foreign forces in Afghanistan, released a statement, then a video statement, then gave an interview to NATO television. In his and in all NATO officials' communication today, each emphasized that the burning was unintentional.

"Those materials were inadvertently given to troops for disposition and that disposition was to burn the materials. It was not a decision that was made because they were religious materials," Allen told NATO TV. "It was not a decision that was made with respect to the faith of Islam. It was a mistake, it was an error. The moment we found out about it we immediately stopped and we intervened."

Allen launched an investigation and promised to take steps that the same incident would not be repeated.

"This is not who we are. These are very, very isolated incidents," Allen said. "We've been dying alongside the Afghans for a long time because we believe in them, we believe in their country, we want to have every opportunity to give them a bright future."

In the morning, U.S. officials on Bagram escorted local Afghan elders to the site of the burning. Ahmad Zaki Zahed, the chief of the provincial council, said 60 to 70 books had been recovered from the fire, including Korans that were once used by detainees at the base.

"Some were all burned. Some were half-burned," Zahed told the Associated Press.

The protesters' fury was immediate, but Afghan officials eventually calmed them down by the afternoon. They demanded to see President Hamid Karzai and threatened to resume demonstrations.

Previous reports of Koran burning have led to deadly protests in Afghanistan. In April, 2011, after a fringe protester burned a Koran, a mob in a usually peaceful northern city stormed the United Nations compound and killed at least seven foreigners. In May, 2005, Afghan police killed at least four demonstrators angry over a report that an American interrogator in Guantanamo Bay prison flushed a Koran down a toilet.

While today's reaction was quick and furious, the protests might have been larger if it wasn't snowing and if it had happened at a different time. Many Afghans did not know about the burning because it occurred late last night and news is generally consumed during television newscasts in the evenings, at home. Many Afghans and Westerners fear that protests could get larger Wednesday and the rest of the week.

"Past demonstrations in Afghanistan have escalated into violent attacks on Western targets of opportunity," the U.S. embassy said in statement known as a Warden Message, sent to Americans living in Afghanistan. "U.S. citizens in Afghanistan should remain vigilant and avoid areas where Westerners congregate. Avoid large public gatherings or demonstrations. Do not discuss travel plans or other personal matters with strangers, or in public."

Far to the south, in an area where a surge of U.S. troops has removed many Taliban safehavens, insurgents reminded the local population that they still held considerable sway.

In the Washer district of Helmand, insurgents beheaded four people they accused of spying for the U.S., according to the Helmand governor's spokesman. The Taliban denied any involvement in the executions, claiming they were carried out by Western intelligence officials to bring the Taliban a bad name.

Also Read

Just leave already. Why are we still in this country? What is the U.S. doing We are not the worlds policeman. We are a great fighting force. We can and will destroy anyplace we want with our military but that is all the U.S. can do. Get out of the middle east totally.

Oops! How could Obama have let something like this happen?

Obama is an idiot.

[SuperDuper! 230]

If Bibles were thrown out in the trash by soldiers, would we see a news story about it? Nope. It's all PC about Muslims.

[Hilarious Clinton 452]

Someone get them a 'Hurt Feelings Report'.

boo hoo

[X Factor 1,112]

That is just an insane reaction to burnt korans

[luckytxn 2,264]

That is just an insane reaction to burnt korans

They are kinda partial to them. Can't blame them for being upset. Obama screwed up big time.

[PalestineMyHeart 1,897]

If Bibles were thrown out in the trash by soldiers, would we see a news story about it? Nope. It's all PC about Muslims.

OK let me try to picture this comparison...

So if non-Christian foreign troops (say they happened to be Muslim, for instance) invaded and occupied the U.S. for more than a decade, bombing the ####### out of our country, forcibly overthrowing our government in the name of "liberating" us from violent terrorists... and then after about 10 or 11 years of enforcing martial law, those foreign troops got a little bored with the sheer ennui of it all and decided to entertain themselves with harmless little fraternity stunts like trashing Bibles... you're asking would there be any public outrage about it, might the story even get on the news ?

Hmmm that's a tough one... I have to think about it...

[luckytxn 2,264]

OK let me try to picture this comparison...

So if non-Christian foreign troops (say they happened to be Muslim, for instance) invaded and occupied the U.S. for more than a decade, bombing the ####### out of our country, forcibly overthrowing our government in the name of "liberating" us from violent terrorists... and then after about 10 or 11 years of enforcing martial law, those foreign troops got a little bored with the sheer ennui of it all and decided to entertain themselves with harmless little fraternity stunts like trashing Bibles... you're asking would there be any public outrage about it, might the story even get on the news ?

Hmmm that's a tough one... I have to think about it...

It would piss me off.

[Usui Takumi 1,562]

....by all accounts this appears to have been an accident. Its not like the Quran burning pastor incident.

I imagine someone was like "Oh look at these old books...hmm can't read them and they are using up valuable space that my macbook pro could be sitting in. Into the bin they go. Blame Steve Jobs.

[PalestineMyHeart 1,897]

....by all accounts this appears to have been an accident. Its not like the Quran burning pastor incident.

I imagine someone was like "Oh look at these old books...hmm can't read them and they are using up valuable space that my macbook pro could be sitting in. Into the bin they go. Blame Steve Jobs.

Reading other accounts of the incident, many questions arise.

Edited February 22, 2012 by wife_of_mahmoud

[Sofiyya 1,687]

I try to avoid burning holy books, but that's just me.

[I AM NOT THAT GUY 5,715]

I try to avoid burning holy books, but that's just me.

Much like phone books, they don't burn well.

I do wonder, as a side note, according to the American Legion, of which I am a member, the appropriate way to dispose of an American flag, that is no longer suitable for display, in by burning in a solemn manner. What is the appropriate way to dispose of worn, or excess religious books? Shredding? Burying in a landfill?

This more of an excuse to be indignant, I am 100% certain.

Edited February 22, 2012 by ☼

[Usui Takumi 1,562]

Much like phone books, they don't burn well.

I do wonder, as a side note, according to the American Legion, of which I am a member, the appropriate way to dispose of an American flag, that is no longer suitable for display, in by burning in a solemn manner. What is the appropriate way to dispose of worn, or excess religious books? Shredding? Burying in a landfill?

This more of an excuse to be indignant, I am 100% certain.

I think you are supposed to bury them or place them in a river (weighted down). Those appear to be the ideal, though apparently burning is allowed as well under certain conditions.

[Glyn and Kathy 288]

Just out of curiosity...does anyone here know the proper way to dispose of the Koran...if its an old unused copy? I honestly am asking out of ignorance. The same thing with a bible?

I'm not saying that is what happened here....I just honestly am curious. Is there a ceremonial way of doing it?? I've got several bibles, more than one person needs, and I can never figure out what to do with them. I have the bible I use....but really I just need the one right now.

Obviously throwing a bunch onto a burning pile of rubbish is disrespectful and apologies are definitely due.