proof of relationship

[wghabour 0]

Hi all,

I have a question guys

there is a friend of mine who got married in Egypt on June 28 2009 from an american woman and his wife left Egypt on July 14 2009 and his wife did not visit him since she left but they kept contacting each other and he got his interview on Nov 22 2011 at the american embassy in Cairo Egypt and at the interview the consular officer told him that she is not convinced that their marriage will be permenant maybe as his wife did not visit him since she left for about 29 months and his wife was married before and got divorced and the consular officer asked him to send proof of relationship like phone bills,pictures, letters and e mails and he sent them pictures , letters and e mails.

my questions are these things ( letters, e mails and pictures ) enough to prove their relationship?? and does the consular officer have right to deny the visa despite the fact that it was approved from NVC??

if the visa is denied what things must be done after that??

plz guys answer my questions as my friend is in a very bad mood and I do not have any idea about this matter .

by the way all the documents needed were submitted and his wife changed her name and got his family name and sumbitted the affidavit of support.

so many thanks

Edited November 29, 2011 by wghabour

[habibi83 12]

yes, consulate can deny visa even though nvc approved. its up to the consulate n based on the interview. also, I can not imagine not visiting my husband for 29 months, we got married in sept 2010 n since then I went see him two more times jan n july. I would probably go more often but my work doesnt allow me more vacation time:( .

[marymina119 3]

Hi all,

I have a question guys

there is a friend of mine who got married in Egypt on June 28 2009 from an american woman and his wife left Egypt on July 14 2009 and his wife did not visit him since she left but they kept contacting each other and he got his interview on Nov 22 2011 at the american embassy in Cairo Egypt and at the interview the consular officer told him that she is not convinced that their marriage will be permenant maybe as his wife did not visit him since she left for about 29 months and his wife was married before and got divorced and the consular officer asked him to send proof of relationship like phone bills,pictures, letters and e mails and he sent them pictures , letters and e mails.

my questions are these things ( letters, e mails and pictures ) enough to prove their relationship?? and does the consular officer have right to deny the visa despite the fact that it was approved from NVC??

if the visa is denied what things must be done after that??

plz guys answer my questions as my friend is in a very bad mood and I do not have any idea about this matter .

by the way all the documents needed were submitted and his wife changed her name and got his family name and sumbitted the affidavit of support.

so many thanks

well from what i saw here your firend has a red flag if you are married they expect you to have some kind of real realtionship but for them to be away for 2 and half years without seeing each other its a big red flag unless she can prove that she has a very good reason not to come and visit him , and yes the CO has the right to deny your case even if it is approved by immgration and NVC they will return the case back to USA for further evaluation if they feel there is fraud.

letters emails joint bank accounts any thing to convience the CO that there is an ongoing relationship will help.

[together4evr 360]

I would like to know why they have not seen each other in over 2 yrs?

The flight to egypt is miserable and expensive.. but he could have gotten a tourist visa somewhere??? Mexico?? They could have vacationed somewhere???

I do not believe either

I have visited my husband 3 times this year and stayed for over 3 months total. It has caused a large dent in my pocketbook but it is worth it. I need to be with him. This separation is awful

Edited November 29, 2011 by togetherforever13

[Ryan H 3,812]

and does the consular officer have right to deny the visa despite the fact that it was approved from NVC??

yes, consulate can deny visa even though nvc approved.

The NVC doesn't "approve" anything. The NVC receives relevant documents from relevant parties and reviews them for anything the relevant parties may have missed. When the NVC has what it needs it sends the file to the Embassy or Consulate. Visa decisions are made by CO's at Embassies and Consulates.

if the visa is denied what things must be done after that??

If a visa is denied at a Embassy or Consulate, the file will be sent back to USCIS (via the NVC; overseas IV unit sends it back to NVC, NVC sends it to USCIS service center that approved the petition). When the file arrives back at the USCIS service center, USCIS will decide to re-affirm the approved petition or send the petitioner a Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR). If a petitioner receives an NOIR, the NOIR will specifically state why it has been sent and the petitioner will have to rebut the specific charges made on the NOIR. Additionally, the petitioner must respond to the NOIR by the stated deadline. Once the NOIR response is received by USCIS, the petition will be reviewed and a decision made. If the petition is reaffirmed, it will be returned to the appropriate Embassy or Consulate (via the NVC) for another interview.

[monalisa2010 1]

Hi all,

I have a question guys

there is a friend of mine who got married in Egypt on June 28 2009 from an american woman and his wife left Egypt on July 14 2009 and his wife did not visit him since she left but they kept contacting each other and he got his interview on Nov 22 2011 at the american embassy in Cairo Egypt and at the interview the consular officer told him that she is not convinced that their marriage will be permenant maybe as his wife did not visit him since she left for about 29 months and his wife was married before and got divorced and the consular officer asked him to send proof of relationship like phone bills,pictures, letters and e mails and he sent them pictures , letters and e mails.

my questions are these things ( letters, e mails and pictures ) enough to prove their relationship?? and does the consular officer have right to deny the visa despite the fact that it was approved from NVC??

if the visa is denied what things must be done after that??

plz guys answer my questions as my friend is in a very bad mood and I do not have any idea about this matter .

by the way all the documents needed were submitted and his wife changed her name and got his family name and sumbitted the affidavit of support.

so many thanks

well first of all i think that your friend husband met consular in window # 15 wish im right? second as most of members advice she have to give astrong reasons for not comming all that time ..she can say revoulations in the area and her work plus he couldnt come because he cant get any other kind of visas because he already presented for immgration visa ( her ex marriage has no related and never effected by the way )

so listen carefuly case i passed with same stuipd experience and i was depressed ..you know this is my first time to be here since last october ..i will tell what happen with me ..i went to the interview the conuslar was out of mood and wasnt friendly at all with me or my littel kids although my husband is their biloigical father and he is egyptian origion like me and same religion..after many questions she said i cant approve your case i need more evidances for relationship ...although i have many she doesnt care ...second day my husband sent western union bills.pictures .phone bills ,....etc and we waited for 2 months than she sent my passport back and said she doesnt convinced with relationship and she sent the case back to uscis for final descion thanks god it doesnt take long time for them to receive ..we involoved senator office cause its not logical what she did ...anyway we started for new evidances like the following:

1 credit cards under my name but he is the owner

2 taxes id ..anyone have husband or wife outside of us can present form w7 to get taxes id for him/her to be add to

his taxes and yes anyone can do it for his spouse even he is out of the states

3 he mad life insurance for us ,we are benificary in case of his death

4 i mad him additional visa card through my bank account

5 we bought some stuff under both of our names

so you have to act fast ..cause she may send case back to uscis and it will take hell months like first step before ..try to advice her to make any of those proofs and she have to visit him even month ayear ..act fast to prevent of send case back and i wish to help you or anyone in same situation ...good luck to evryone