FORM I-130 QUESTIONS FOR IR-5

[Nich-Nick 3,354]

Yep, after looking...reading...and paying attention no doubt that you know what you are talking about and I do appreciate your time and help! I will be looking for you for sure again.

Regards

Well look for JoannaV again, who pointed it out to me because I overlooked it too.

[ngvuanh 0]

However, USCIS agent told me question 15 is petitioner's employer when I talked to them.

So, I am not sure who is right since the way they made the form makes people confusing.

If you look at the fist page of the I-130, most of the left half is Part B #1-14b --all about the petitioner, your son.

The right half of the page is call Part C #1-16 --all about the immigrant, you benuk.

Part C continues on page 2 with #17-22, also information about benuk.

[benuk 18]

However, USCIS agent told me question 15 is petitioner's employer when I talked to them.

So, I am not sure who is right since the way they made the form makes people confusing.

Oh God guys!! I start thinking that we need reinforce on this question 15?? Where is Jojo,Pinguin and all the other Senior Members??

[Nich-Nick 3,354]

However, USCIS agent told me question 15 is petitioner's employer when I talked to them.

So, I am not sure who is right since the way they made the form makes people confusing.

Well I feel very sure that 15 goes with Part C Beneficiary. Think about Part C. Would they pick up again on page 2 with #17 if they didn't have a 15 or 16 on the previous page? People do call the USCIS phoneline the mis-Information line because they don't always give out correct information.

[JoannaV 174]

100% sure. Have a look at this sample I-130 from the London Embassy: http://photos.state.gov/libraries/unitedkingdom/164203/dhs/sample_of_a_completed_i130.pdf You can be sure that the person who completed this sample knew what they were doing. Whereas unfortunately some of the people who answer the phone for USCIS do not know what they are talking about.

This should convince you that question 15 is about your, the beneficiary's, employer. It should also convince you that answering question 18 entirely truthfully (ie "i don't know yet") is fine.

Regarding your son's other names, do list the one shown on his Spanish passport.

[benuk 18]

100% sure. Have a look at this sample I-130 from the London Embassy: http://photos.state.gov/libraries/unitedkingdom/164203/dhs/sample_of_a_completed_i130.pdf You can be sure that the person who completed this sample knew what they were doing. Whereas unfortunately some of the people who answer the phone for USCIS do not know what they are talking about.

This should convince you that question 15 is about your, the beneficiary's, employer. It should also convince you that answering question 18 entirely truthfully (ie "i don't know yet") is fine.

Regarding your son's other names, do list the one shown on his Spanish passport.

Thanks JoannaV again for putting your time on this thread.I'm taking all your advices in consideration and we are already on the process of putting all the information on the form I-130. I feel a lot peace of mind having all you guys willing to share some ligth in here!

I thank you all.