Any Idol Fans?

[noemij 0]

FINALLY See Ya Bucky Boy

Next week its Ace for sure

I agree....and after that, Kelly needs to go....

[yogib37 3]

FINALLY See Ya Bucky Boy

Next week its Ace for sure

I agree....and after that, Kelly needs to go....

Kellie wont go..she is too pretty and a good singer. Yes she is dumb as a stump but she has that sexy look.. she will be in the top 3 or 2

[keltic 1]

FINALLY See Ya Bucky Boy

Next week its Ace for sure

I agree....and after that, Kelly needs to go....

Kellie wont go..she is too pretty and a good singer. Yes she is dumb as a stump but she has that sexy look.. she will be in the top 3 or 2

"a good singer" ?

i would beg to differ!!! really and truly... go back and close your eyes and listen again... she misses notes like mad... she winds up trying too hard... and then ends up making some of her words sound french... which when mixed in with the rest of the song in a southern drawl sounds ridiculous...

then open your eyes and watch it again... you can literally see the cogs turning in her head to try to remember her choreography, which then winds up looking stiff

i dont find the stiffness or the dumbness to be sexy at all

however, i will admit that i do not think she will go any time soon... simon is pimping her as much as hes pimping chris... and besides, VFTW is pushing kellie, so thats tons of votes right there

[doodlebugfor_u 0]

That song was from way back during the Iranian hostage crisis in '79. It had limited airplay on the radio. I was just a kid but I remember.

Pickler is a good singer????

[LenJayUS 0]

yes

[Welshcookie 17]

just caught up with the program.....I don't come into this thread until I have...

I was soooo sad to see Bucky go...

[yogib37 3]

FINALLY See Ya Bucky Boy

Next week its Ace for sure

I agree....and after that, Kelly needs to go....

Kellie wont go..she is too pretty and a good singer. Yes she is dumb as a stump but she has that sexy look.. she will be in the top 3 or 2

"a good singer" ?

i would beg to differ!!! really and truly... go back and close your eyes and listen again... she misses notes like mad... she winds up trying too hard... and then ends up making some of her words sound french... which when mixed in with the rest of the song in a southern drawl sounds ridiculous...

then open your eyes and watch it again... you can literally see the cogs turning in her head to try to remember her choreography, which then winds up looking stiff

i dont find the stiffness or the dumbness to be sexy at all

however, i will admit that i do not think she will go any time soon... simon is pimping her as much as hes pimping chris... and besides, VFTW is pushing kellie, so thats tons of votes right there

then who do you think is a good singer? I bet you like ACE. if you think Kelly is bad, ace is 1000% worst then kelly.

If Ace gets in the TOP 4 I am not watching anymore..

[keltic 1]

FINALLY See Ya Bucky Boy

Next week its Ace for sure

I agree....and after that, Kelly needs to go....

Kellie wont go..she is too pretty and a good singer. Yes she is dumb as a stump but she has that sexy look.. she will be in the top 3 or 2

"a good singer" ?

i would beg to differ!!! really and truly... go back and close your eyes and listen again... she misses notes like mad... she winds up trying too hard... and then ends up making some of her words sound french... which when mixed in with the rest of the song in a southern drawl sounds ridiculous...

then open your eyes and watch it again... you can literally see the cogs turning in her head to try to remember her choreography, which then winds up looking stiff

i dont find the stiffness or the dumbness to be sexy at all

however, i will admit that i do not think she will go any time soon... simon is pimping her as much as hes pimping chris... and besides, VFTW is pushing kellie, so thats tons of votes right there

then who do you think is a good singer? I bet you like ACE. if you think Kelly is bad, ace is 1000% worst then kelly.

If Ace gets in the TOP 4 I am not watching anymore..

nope... ace should be the next to go... hes a cutie boy... just like kellie is a cutie girl... but that doesnt make either of them an 'idol'

so, what did you bet?

i think ive been pretty clear in my previous posts on this thread who i like, but here ya go (of those left in the competition):

taylor is an entertainer... i would buy cds, go to concerts, etc (thats what its about... who can earn money for them) he isnt everyones style, but then everyone doesnt like country... everyone doesnt like rock... everyone doesnt like r&b... etc... taylor has a strong fan base and will do well, whether he wins this or not... all that said, i dont want him to be in the top 2, because i dont want him limited to what american idol says he should do/be... i love his passion and abandon... i dont want him to lose it

chris is a GREAT rocker... and i think he has the best shot at actually winning this whole thing... he has a definite look... he had a definite style... he has talent... hes likable... he has a good relationship with his family... all things that will make him a 'moneymaker' for AI... i do not think that i would pay to sit thru a 2 hr concert of his tho... it would all sound the same... and its just not my thing

katherine has a good voice, technically... and she sure thinks shes hot... when i watch her tho, i do not see any passion for what shes doing... she doesnt really move naturally (altho, admittedly, more naturally than kellie)

elliott nails every note... hes not the most handsome guy to walk the earth, but then hes not the ugliest either... i would definitely buy cds of his... and it seems as the weeks go by, hes getting more comfortable and some of his personality is coming out... and, he sings with passion... you can feel what hes singing

paris is exceptionally talented for a 17yr old... the power behind her voice is something that foretells a wonderful career for her if thats what she truly wants... i think some of her song choices are what puts me off a little now... i do NOT want to see a 17yr old girl dressed up like a hoochie singing "fever"... im sure it floats someones boat... and she sure can sing the notes, but its just not something i want to see... shes choosing songs that are just too mature for her...

kellie, well, see my previous post (that obviously you dont agree with)... shes ok... but not 'idol'... but i do see that AI is working her for all shes worth and gonna push her as far as they can (again, all about the $$$$)

ace tries to hard... it sounds forced... he misses notes and chooses songs that really just dont make sense to me... but, hes a pretty boy... and can get lots of preteen/teen girls to buy cds...

i do not say any of this to be nasty to any of the contestants or their fans... these are just my opinions... noone has to agree... wont hurt me one way or another... there is only gonna be one winner... but at least i try to give my reasons for what i think instead of saying "he sucks" or "she stinks" or "he rox!" or "shes hot!"

on to rod stewart week!!!!

[Jenn! 918]

So is everyone excited for tonight?

[Welshcookie 17]

chris is a GREAT rocker... and i think he has the best shot at actually winning this whole thing... he has a definite look... he had a definite style... he has talent... hes likable... he has a good relationship with his family... all things that will make him a 'moneymaker' for AI... i do not think that i would pay to sit thru a 2 hr concert of his tho... it would all sound the same... and its just not my thing

He is my personal favourite......it is getting so hard to make choices about who should go! I don't like the blonde southern girl who sang Bohemian Rhaposody...it really didn't do anything for me at all....

[Cristy 4]

Chris, Paris, Taylor....so far I am impressed.

[Fuzzness 2]

Chris was amazing

Paris was boring

Taylor was ok but not great, didn't know the song though.

[Cristy 4]

Nah you are wrong Taylor rocked lol. I love that song...and am partial to him.

[Fuzzness 2]

I do like Taylor, but i just didnt know the song so it's hard for me to judge if i've never heard the song before, and even more difficult if I don't like the song anyway.

sooooo i'll take your word for it

[Mr. Big Dog 10,747]

My girl pulled it off tonight.

Way to go Paris!