Any Idol Fans?

[pixiegunn 0]

I didn't like anyone. Paris and Mandisa can always sing, but their performances just weren't that great in my non-musically educated opinion! I found it to be a pretty boring hour.

[Fuzzness 2]

I agree, everyone sucked tonight. But some sucked more than others.

[Dixie_Peach 1]

they need a porn version of american idol - where everyone is auditioning to be the newest up and coming porn star.

dang... i missed all of show... had to work the 2nd job tonight... marilyn, if you are around... please do your links for idol... let me catch up... ty ty ty

[Cristy 4]

Yes very underwhelming. I did not think anyone really sucked or really rocked. It was just average.

[babybunny 2]

who do yall think should be Axed???????????????

based on what yall are saying

bucky and Ace.

[CarolineM 0]

Kellie needs to go. Paris, too, but I'm the only one wtih that opinion...and Ace is so horrid I can't believe he's still in.

That said, Taylor sang my FAVORITE song of all time last night. When he's like, "Ray LaMontagne...." I almost died. I adore that song and I thought he did a great great job.

[LenJayUS 0]

I think the voting should be for who we thing should get axed... who gets the most votes leaves.. not the other way around... :-)

This was the first time I watched it... and I missed the first singer... They all were probably pretty average from what the judges were saying... I did like Lisa's little signing in the recap at the end.

I definately did not like Mandisa's performance and act at all. She'd be my vote for the weakest link :-). Paris's singing I liked, but not her performance. Taylor I didn't like much either.

For the gals, my vote would end up going between Katharine (I think she sang the best out of all the idol wannabe's), Kellie, or Lisa (in that order).

For the guys, my vote would end up going between Ace or Chris. I'd have to see more out of Elliot to make my mind up about the "funky whiteboy" as Paula called him.

[Mr. Big Dog 10,747]

Very disappointing hour. Nothing that stood out as great or awesome.

I thought Katharine, Mandisa, Paris, Chris, Taylor and Kelly did okay.

I don't get this whole Elliott thing.

Lisa, Ace and Bucky would make the bottom three and based on last night, Bucky needs to go first. He sucked yesterday.

My $0.02.

[Jenn! 918]

My ranking for last night:

Taylor

Paris

Elliot

Mandisa

Katharine

Chris

Lisa

Kelly

Bucky

Ace

[Cristy 4]

I don't get this whole Elliott thing.

I don't either.

[yogib37 3]

yes they all sucked..

I feel I am going on a limb, I think Chris should be gone. I dont think he is very good. Yes he can sing but if only Rock was the only kind of music then he is good.

I dont think he has a range of differnt types of music. Look in the past weeks, had stevie wonder, 50's etc..he had to jazz it up to a ROCK style.

So maybe that is only thing he can sing. Mono singer.

I think in the next couple weeks he is gone

this week I pray that Bucky or Ace is sent packing

[Marilyn. 340]

Katharine was good but I have seen her do better

I liked Elliot's performance.... he has the most orignal sounding voice on the competition

Not sure what is happening with Ace... the first week he sounded ok but now he sucks more and more each week.... I think he should go next but you know he won't because all the girls think he is cute

Bucky and Lisa weren't very good either....

I would be happy if Ace or Bucky got voted out tonight

all the rest were ok

DixiePeach, I will hunt down those links for you

[Jenn! 918]

Not sure what is happening with Ace... the first week he sounded ok but now he sucks more and more each week.... I think he should go next but you know he won't because all the girls think he is cute

You're so right! I think he should stick to George Michael.

I bet he could sing a mean "Careless Whisper"

[Bootylicious!! 2]

I have issues with the TV schedule tonight. I want to watch Idol to see Shakira and who gets voted off but I want to watch Lost too. What's a girl to do?

[Marilyn. 340]

I have issues with the TV schedule tonight. I want to watch Idol to see Shakira and who gets voted off but I want to watch Lost too. What's a girl to do?

well, what I am going to do is tape American Idol and watch Lost

I hate that they are on at the same time