Big Touble I-751

[Colombian23 0]

Ok, so i submitted the i-751 to Remove conditions, on November last year (2010), with some proofs, now 4 months later i received a latter saying that i need to send more proofs, but here is the BIG TROUBLE.... the truth is that my wife and i got separated several months ago (12 months) and have being taking and everything but never got back together, we didn't get divorced hoping being still married was going to help me get the GC. Meanwhile she got another man and got PREGNANT by him, now she has a baby of another person " different from his legally husband" and immigration wants more proofs of this marrige...

So i want to ask you guys what would you think is the best thing to do in this case...

Im about to send a letter to immigration saying what is going on, and let the decide whats going to happen with the case

[sciencenerd 56]

Ok, so i submitted the i-751 to Remove conditions, on November last year (2010), with some proofs, now 4 months later i received a latter saying that i need to send more proofs, but here is the BIG TROUBLE.... the truth is that my wife and i got separated several months ago (12 months) and have being taking and everything but never got back together, we didn't get divorced hoping being still married was going to help me get the GC. Meanwhile she got another man and got PREGNANT by him, now she has a baby of another person " different from his legally husband" and immigration wants more proofs of this marrige...

So i want to ask you guys what would you think is the best thing to do in this case...

Im about to send a letter to immigration saying what is going on, and let the decide whats going to happen with the case

So, 4 months ago you submitted an application presenting your marriage as totally fine and continuing while you had already been separated for 8 months? If you were dishonest in your initial application, you may have some pretty big problems. Good luck.

[beemer8 0]

Ok, so i submitted the i-751 to Remove conditions, on November last year (2010), with some proofs, now 4 months later i received a latter saying that i need to send more proofs, but here is the BIG TROUBLE.... the truth is that my wife and i got separated several months ago (12 months) and have being taking and everything but never got back together, we didn't get divorced hoping being still married was going to help me get the GC. Meanwhile she got another man and got PREGNANT by him, now she has a baby of another person " different from his legally husband" and immigration wants more proofs of this marrige...

So i want to ask you guys what would you think is the best thing to do in this case...

Im about to send a letter to immigration saying what is going on, and let the decide whats going to happen with the case

From reading different RFE cases here asking for more evidence, I think a good well described letter explaining why you can't produce those evidence with a logical reasoning could help you some. Honestly I am still waiting for my approval so...dig more here at the forum!

[elikhom 7]

Hola brother, a mi casi me pasa lo mismo, mande todos mis papeles y al mes mi esposa se separa de mi porque se enamora de alguien mas y pense en no hacer nada y que el tramite siga su curso como si no hubiera pasado nada pero al final me arrepenti y contacte un abogado y el hizo una llamada a USCIS para cambiar mi filing de casado a divorciado y ahora estoy haciendo al tramite asi.

In other words the best you can do is contact a lawyer and accept that from now on you have to either refile or update your already filed I-751, discuss a strategy with the lawyer, give USCIS all they need and hope for the best but prepare for the worst.

Best of luck.

Edited April 15, 2011 by elikhom

[Brother Hesekiel 2,236]

When you submitted your jointly filed I-751 although you were already separated for 8 months by then, you and your wife misrepresented your case. You cannot keep doing this. The only way to get this solved is by responding to the RFE by telling the truth, that you and your wife are now separated and consider divorce and that you therefore would like to change your I-751 to singular filing with a waiver or would like to refile it this way.

I have no clue how they will respond to that, but I know that if you got an RFE for lack of evidence and you have no way to produce this evidence, the only way out is to be honest.

[Gary and Alla 3,694]

Ok, so i submitted the i-751 to Remove conditions, on November last year (2010), with some proofs, now 4 months later i received a latter saying that i need to send more proofs, but here is the BIG TROUBLE.... the truth is that my wife and i got separated several months ago (12 months) and have being taking and everything but never got back together, we didn't get divorced hoping being still married was going to help me get the GC. Meanwhile she got another man and got PREGNANT by him, now she has a baby of another person " different from his legally husband" and immigration wants more proofs of this marrige...

So i want to ask you guys what would you think is the best thing to do in this case...

Im about to send a letter to immigration saying what is going on, and let the decide whats going to happen with the case

"Some proofs" Proofs of what? I hope you did not send "proof" you were living together when you were not.

Since fraud isn't working for you, try either telling the truth or simply do not answer the RFE and go back. Either way you will be denied. Being caught in immigration fraud will not be better.

[beemer8 0]

Ok, so i submitted the i-751 to Remove conditions, on November last year (2010), with some proofs, now 4 months later i received a latter saying that i need to send more proofs, but here is the BIG TROUBLE.... the truth is that my wife and i got separated several months ago (12 months) and have being taking and everything but never got back together, we didn't get divorced hoping being still married was going to help me get the GC. Meanwhile she got another man and got PREGNANT by him, now she has a baby of another person " different from his legally husband" and immigration wants more proofs of this marrige...

So i want to ask you guys what would you think is the best thing to do in this case...

Im about to send a letter to immigration saying what is going on, and let the decide whats going to happen with the case

By the way, did your RFE status get updated on the USCIS case updates ONline?

[w8inglongtime 29]

This is going to be a tough one to sell to uscis. I'm assuming you and your wife filed jointly as though you were still married and living together? There's no other way uscis will look at your case other than a fraudulent one. I hate to be blunt but your wife was either carrying another man's child or had the child at the time you jointly filed your petition. others have suggested you write a note explaining your situation but I doubt that will change the minds at uscis. That letter should have accompanied the package in November. How did you file your 2010 taxes?

You have no choice but to tell uscis exactly what you've said here and the answer from them wont be pleasant. You haven't been together for a year so all your evidence are over a year old and no longer reflective of an ongoing relationship. Maybe get your divorce finalized and refile on your own only if you entered the marriage in good faith to begin with. Good luck.