American Idol Season 10

[Zee Bee 61]

Can't believe it.

[Yurika & Jim 77]

Can't believe it.

What a shocker again!!! But I understand why...

Pia is too perfect and she is kinda an enemy of every girl. So, girls doesn't vote for her = almost no vote for her...

Well, I'm glad my prediction (Casey) was way off

[Jenn! 918]

I'm unreasonably upset about this outcome. I've voted for her about 10 times every week and I didn't vote last night because I was already in bed while I was watching. Honestly, I'm just so bummed that I won't get to hear her perform every week for the rest of the season. Terrible, terrible outcome.

Edited April 8, 2011 by Jenn!

[Zee Bee 61]

What a shocker again!!! But I understand why...

Pia is too perfect and she is kinda an enemy of every girl. So, girls doesn't vote for her = almost no vote for her...

Well, I'm glad my prediction (Casey) was way off

Good point.

I'm going to miss listening to her voice though.

My husband got so mad at the TV I had to change it while she was singing her swan song.

[JohnSmith2007 353]

Pia wasn't my favorite but she wasn't the worst of the bunch. This just proves that more women watch AI than men. I mean look at it. There are now only 2 women left. They all have awesome talent so now it is drool appeal that wins out.

[CDAgirlMI 51]

What a shocker again!!! But I understand why...

Pia is too perfect and she is kinda an enemy of every girl. So, girls doesn't vote for her = almost no vote for her...

I'm going to disagree with that. I think she got voted off because people thought she is so good that it would be a given that she'd be safe! So people voted for contestants they thought might be on the verge of going home instead. Sucks.

At least Paul is still in it

[Krikit 1,165]

OMG. My jaw dropped when they announced Pia. I honestly thought she'd be in the top two.

[aminah 6]

OMG. My jaw dropped when they announced Pia. I honestly thought she'd be in the top two.

I was pretty disappointed too. I thought she would at least be in the top 4. There are a few others I think should have gone home before her.

[aminah 6]

Can you imagine being Stefano at the moment when Pia's name is called eliminating her? Everyone in tears, knowing they all thought YOU (Stefano) should have been the one eliminated.

[Krikit 1,165]

Can you imagine being Stefano at the moment when Pia's name is called eliminating her? Everyone in tears, knowing they all thought YOU (Stefano) should have been the one eliminated.

Including him. Ryan Seacrest said in an interview that Stefano turned to him and said "Are you sure?" You can tell by the look on his face that he thought he was going home too.

[JohnSmith2007 353]

Well, who will it be this week? I thought Casey and James just nailed it. It couldn't have been any better. Stephano did a great job, I think he is also safe. I hate to say it but I think the two ladies and Paul will be the bottom three. From the way things have been going it looks like we will lose yet another lady from the show tonight.

[Yurika & Jim 77]

OK. That was a reasonable bottom 3. I wished Paul would stay though...

Last night, Casey wowed me again Scotty didn't make me smile...

I'm still rooting for James. He was very lucky he got Zakk Wylde on stage! \ m /

[CDAgirlMI 51]

That sucked

[Zee Bee 61]

I'm glad Paul is gone. Couldn't stand his "dancing".

[JohnSmith2007 353]

I never "got" Paul. Other than Rod Stewart songs I didn't like his singing style. Casey once again nailed it. I just love Jazz. James wowed me. I had my doubts when he said he was going to do a Sammy Hagar song but he hit that one out of the park. Did anyone notice that Casey whispered "I love you" to Haley when she survived the cut? Those two have really become an item. I think I will take the wife to see the group when they do the summer tour. They are a really talented bunch.