American Idol Season 10

[Jenn! 918]

Haley, Jacob, Thia, Lauren, Stefano, and Pia knocked it out of the park. I enjoyed Naima's rendition even though it was a little cheesey. Scotty was Scotty and Paul was Paul. lol. I love Casey and James but they didn't really do it for me this time. I hate that people have to get cut tomorrow!

I'm gonna predict Stefano and Thia to go this week, maybe Naima.

[JohnSmith2007 353]

I'm gonna predict Stefano and Thia to go this week, maybe Naima.

I think it will be Naima and Stefano. Do me a favor, if you talk about who is gone use the spolier function please? I will be watching on the DVR after work.

[CDAgirlMI 51]

Paul in the bottom 3!?!?

Kinda thought that was surprising.

Not going to dispute the 2 that went home.

[JohnSmith2007 353]

I agree with Naima going home. I knew that Thei would go at some point but I wish she could have stayed a little longer. I just don't get Paul. He does nothing for me. I think he will be gone next week.

[Amy and Nick 37]

Damn! Still havent watched it as its not been shown in England yet, but im not gutted about Naima and Thia going. Never really liked Naima, and while Thia's fab she is just far too young.

Im gonna pick my top 2 and see if im right:

The ones I WANT:

1.Scotty

2.Casey

(but struggling not to put James and Paul up here!)

The ones I THINK:

1.Pia

2.James

Any other bets out there?!

[Krikit 1,164]

I think Thia and Naima going were a good choice. I am glad that everyone gets to stay together for the tour, though. I kind of thought Stefano would be gone, too, so that was a bit of a surprise. Paul is a unique individual who makes me smile. That's what I love about him. He's different and he's going for it. I think that's great.

My personal top two are still Casey and James. However, I have learned that what I think and what actually happens are two different things. Whoever wins is certainly deserving, because they are all great. While I think Scotty has a fabulous voice and will go far in the C&W world, he's beginning to grate on my nerves. I'm starting to think of him as "The Lounge Lizard". Mostly due to that one way he always holds his microphone and has that accompanying kind of learing face.

[Amy and Nick 37]

haha its funny you should say that because his face wasnt bothering me too much until this week.

I loved his duet with Lauren, but his face is starting to show a little bit of arrogance that im not sure I like. I originally thought it might be his "thing" (Think Johnny Cash with the odd guitar 'tick') but now im not so sure!

Im always a sucker for the Southern accent though! Love me some C & W!

[Krikit 1,164]

I loved his duet with Lauren, but his face is starting to show a little bit of arrogance that im not sure I like.

That's exactly what I thought!!

I wish it were Wednesday. lol

[JohnSmith2007 353]

haha its funny you should say that because his face wasnt bothering me too much until this week.

I loved his duet with Lauren, but his face is starting to show a little bit of arrogance that im not sure I like. I originally thought it might be his "thing" (Think Johnny Cash with the odd guitar 'tick') but now im not so sure!

Im always a sucker for the Southern accent though! Love me some C & W!

I don't think it is arrogance but rather confidence. Remember he is only a teenager. Dealing with all this must be hard. I think his posture is more of a style than anything else. He does look a little like Alfred E Newman though. I like him.

[Krikit 1,164]

I don't think it is arrogance but rather confidence. Remember he is only a teenager. Dealing with all this must be hard. I think his posture is more of a style than anything else. He does look a little like Alfred E Newman though. I like him.

Haha. That's exactly what my husband said. It's true!

[Jenn! 918]

Scotty McLeery, lol.

[Krikit 1,164]

Scotty McLeery, lol.

[JohnSmith2007 353]

Scotty is the man!!! Wow! Elvis would have been proud!!

[Yurika & Jim 77]

Scotty is the man!!! Wow! Elvis would have been proud!!

Yeah! He made me smile again I loved it!

I think everybody did good job overall. I'm still rooting for James

Sad but Casey might be in danger again... He is still good, but no more "wow" moment for me and looks scarely lol...

[Amanda & Raad 0]

I also think they all did well last night. I wasn't too fond of Jacob's performance...but MJ is one of my all time favorite artists and I get picky about people who re-do his songs. I just don't like Jacob's bottom range...sounds like he is going to throw up.

I loved Casey's performance...he has something unique and the fact that he is a musician gives him points in my book in this world of artificial, synthetic, computerized beats & voices...I think he has real talent.

I was on the fence about Paul. He has a unique voice but didn't think he was up to par vocally with the others like James & Pia, but he did great last night...I was surprised in a good way.

Scotty was pretty good...I'd say average, didn't blow me away though. Lauren was average too. My votes got for James, Pia & Casey. I could do without Hailey..don't like her constant growling!

But just my honest opinion...as my mom says...opinions are like buttholes, everyone has one.