Is Shariah the Same as Jewish Law?

[Danno 1,228]

http://bigpeace.com/dyerushalmi/2010/09/18/is-shariah-the-same-as-jewish-law/

==================================

[Darnell 8,479]

uhm. I say no.

[Laveau 67]

I'm with Darnell on this one.

[Sofiyya 1,687]

How would most people here know? A serious answer to this question requires more knowledge than most people here know about either Jewish law or Sharia than most here have, including the OP.

[ready4ONE 5,400]

I'm stumped.

[evli1966 88]

How would most people here know? A serious answer to this question requires more knowledge than most people here know about either Jewish law or Sharia than most here have, including the OP.

I do not know enough of either to say anything.

[Saddle Bronc 124]

No. Dietary laws are proof enough (stuffed-camel¹ is a known dish amongst Muslim Bedouin, and shellfish/crustaceans are not prohibited² in Muslim diet).

1. Leviticus 11:4 details prohibition of camel-meat in Jewish diet
2. I attempted (and failed) to put up a poll which included this subject four years ago--it all-too-quickly degenerated to a shill-fest and I asked Ewok to lock the thread (I'm not going to go through 100+ pages of the General Polls section to find it)

[Saddle Bronc 124]

How would most people here know? A serious answer to this question requires more knowledge than most people here know about either Jewish law or Sharia than most here have, including the OP.

IMO, Shal (who posted just before you) would be on the ball on that!

[IncorrectPolitics 26]

As long as you live in a secular country that separates church from state it doesn't matter. If another country in another part of the world wants to be governed by sharia or jewish law it is their business and their choice.

[Danno 1,228]

As long as you live in a secular country that separates church from state it doesn't matter. If another country in another part of the world wants to be governed by sharia or jewish law it is their business and their choice.

[evli1966 88]

As long as you live in a secular country that separates church from state it doesn't matter. If another country in another part of the world wants to be governed by sharia or jewish law it is their business and their choice.

Great response and I agree.

Thi sis the case whether or not we agree with those laws or not.

[The_Dude 1,142]

As long as you live in a secular country that separates church from state it doesn't matter. If another country in another part of the world wants to be governed by sharia or jewish law it is their business and their choice.

So once again, the best response to one of Danno's thread is "Who gives a sh!t". Nice.

[Danno 1,228]

So once again, the best response to one of Danno's thread is "Who gives a sh!t". Nice.

Another post from R&M which is no deeper than a puddle of piss.

You never disappoint.

[The_Dude 1,142]

Another post from R&M which is no deeper than a puddle of piss.

You never disappoint.

Danno, you've got 3 brain cells fighting over the same though. You might want to save some of those.

[Saddle Bronc 124]

Another post from R&M which is no deeper than a puddle of piss.

You never disappoint.

R&M is probably from Pigtown (Toronto), as I infer from his ingorance.

I met a Pigtowner (it may actually have been Rob) at Odenton Station last year, who responded to my comment that I could not understand what changed with Canada's 1982 Constitution (the comment was made to a non-Canuck) with the erroneous "the queen is no longer head of state"--and could NOT answer further when I asked him why the 1989 citizenship swear-in oath still mentioned her (and by name) and the coinage of Canada after that time STILL shows her profile.