RWN's: The Constitution is a Loophole for Illegal Immigrants

[one...two...tree 2,762]

Kamala D. Harris, California Attorney General

It's an election year, and so we're accustomed to hearing typical hyperbole from politicians. But even the most jaded observers of our politics were troubled by the latest head-scratcher from Senator Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.). The Senate Minority Leader suggested, without irony or humor, that Congress "ought to take a look at" eliminating the Fourteenth Amendment's guarantee of citizenship to every natural-born American. He, and others in the punditsphere, believe that the Fourteenth Amendment is a problem because illegal immigrants come to this country unlawfully and then have children who are American citizens.

A generation ago, it would have been hard to imagine writing an op-ed defending the Fourteenth Amendment. But that's how polarized and demagogic our politics have become. The Constitution, we're told, isn't human history's finest effort to codify and honor the inalienable rights of persons; it's a loophole for illegal immigrants. And the Fourteenth Amendment? It's not the product of this nation's epic war to end slavery and enfranchise African Americans; it's just another political football that we can toss around to rile up votes and dollars on the margins.

We shouldn't be so cavalier. It dishonors our Constitution and our politics.

It's especially ironic that leading Republicans need this reminder, for it was another generation of Republicans that enacted the Fourteenth Amendment. We had a war about this very question--who is an American? Our answer was, and remains, elegantly simple: any person born in America is an American. Generations before the Civil War, our forefather fled the caste-like European system that uplifted people of "noble birth" and disenfranchised the rest of us. They crossed an ocean, fought a king, and died for a nation where your rights don't depend on your parents' lineage. Catholic or Protestant, sons and daughters of fishermen or noblemen, born to parents from many nations--they called themselves, and each other, Americans. The suggestion that we do any less today dishonors them and us.

Senator McConnell was right, though, that we need immigration reform in America. But thrusting a stake in the Fourteenth Amendment won't solve that problem. Extreme proposals like this are better designed for grabbing headlines, riling up the base, and driving contributions to one's party. But they're costing us a chance to actually solve problems. Honest dialogue about solutions isn't possible in an environment like this. Bipartisanship, compromise, and finding common ground aren't possible. We need to dial it back if we're going to have a chance to solve the big problems facing us, including illegal immigration. So, here's a modest proposal: Let's have a serious discussion that doesn't include eliminating entire sections of our Constitution. We'll each put forward our best ideas, without malignant agenda, we'll debate, and whoever convinces the majority of folks on the merit of their ideas, wins. We may actually solve the problem, which is what people deserve, and we'll spare our Constitution an unneeded trim.

[^_^ 5,021]

It's especially ironic that leading Republicans need this reminder, for it was another generation of Republicans that enacted the Fourteenth Amendment.

The two parties have always switched roles around.

[slim 1,514]

Anchor babies aside, what's stopping us from deporting their parents?

[one...two...tree 2,762]

Harris was born in Oakland, California. She is the daughter of a Tamil Indian mother, Dr. Shyamala Gopalan, a breast cancer specialist, who immigrated to the United States from Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India in 1960, and a Jamaican American father, Stanford University economics professor Donald Harris.

In Paul's words - she's not really an American.

[Heracles 417]

Here we go again, the Constitutional argument.

In Paul's words - she's not really an American.

At the time of her birth, were her parents permanent residents or not?

"Let's have a serious discussion that doesn't include eliminating entire sections of our Constitution. We'll each put forward our best ideas, without malignant agenda, we'll debate, and whoever convinces the majority of folks on the merit of their ideas, wins."

Nice try, but this is America, where the opinion of the majority of citizens means nothing.

Edited August 11, 2010 by Heracles

[slim 1,514]

At the time of her birth, were her parents permanent residents or not?

Yeah, what was the status of her parents? I'm pretty sure an Indian doctor and Jamaican economics professer didn't "sneak across" from TJ and somehow sprout that HPOA in hopes they could stay here.

[Heracles 417]

Yeah, what was the status of her parents? I'm pretty sure an Indian doctor and Jamaican economics professer didn't "sneak across" from TJ and somehow sprout that HPOA in hopes they could stay here.

This point has been raised many times before, that it's not professionals sneaking across the border. Anyone running on ideological stances rather than rational thought, always attempts to blur the lines.

[I AM NOT THAT GUY 5,715]

A Lack of Conviction

As D.A. Kamala Harris campaigns to be attorney general, her success rate in felony trials has dropped below that of any big-city prosecutor in California.

http://www.sfweekly.com/2010-05-05/news/a-lack-of-conviction/

Must be an election year!

Kamala D. Harris, California Attorney General

Just a little presumptuous, don't you think? I wonder who told Jerry Brown?

Image not showing.

I can see it.

[slim 1,514]

Image not showing.

I had to refresh to see it.

[one...two...tree 2,762]

I must be getting old. All I can see is the Subway.

[slim 1,514]

We are sorry to inform you that the image you are attempting to post is entirely too small. Please buy a ####### enlarger and try again later....

I'll post a link then - http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.fogcityjournal.com/images/photos/d6_drug_crime_meeting_060724/mw2w5892_std.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.fogcityjournal.com/news_in_brief/bcn_oakdale_mob_trial_061103.shtml&usg=__TveXheDyKWxvGKCphv8emAw7XwE=&h=333&w=500&sz=34&hl=en&start=17&itbs=1&tbnid=OoJu6tUE2JBY_M:&tbnh=87&tbnw=130&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dkamala%2Bharris%26hl%3Den%26gbv%3D2%26tbs%3Disch:1

[Kathryn41 3,205]

Inappropriate comments, image and posts quoting same and having nothing to do with the posted topic have been removed.