Federal Government To Ban Drop-Side Cribs And Many Others

[Obama 2012 1,714]

I don't see a problem with requiring a better quality of wood and also making sure the mattresses have support to where incidents like this won't happen.. but outright banning them is a bit silly imo.

We've used the same type of cribs for decades. Accidents happen as with anything.

Again though, I'm a numbers type of person when it comes to things like this. 0.00009% of the babies born each year in the US are killed by this. Yes, it's a baby. Yes deaath is bad and sad. At the same time - When you look at the sheer numbers it's really not warranted for a full ban.

As I said though, new mandates for better quality, sure. Full ban, no...

----------------

http://www.cnn.com/2010/US/07/14/crib.standards/index.html?hpt=T2

Government nears new standards for cribs, ban on drop-side cribs

(CNN) -- In an effort to make children safer while they sleep, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission voted unanimously Wednesday in favor of new proposed mandatory standards for cribs.

The new rules, likely to go into effect next year after a final vote by the federal commission, would render many cribs in the country as not up to code, regardless of whether the crib style and model was ever considered unsafe, and essentially would ban the manufacture and sale of drop-side cribs.

In addition to eliminating drop-side cribs, the new rules will mandate better mattress support, sturdier hardware and better quality wood for crib construction.

Between November 2007 and April of this year, there were 36 deaths associated with crib structural problems, according to Commission Chairwoman Inez Tenenbaum.

Hazards in cribs include faulty hardware, dangerous gaps created from mattress support failures, and poor wood quality with crib slats that can be broken easily. The new standards aim to eliminate gaps where babies could become entrapped and suffocate, and to prevent babies from falling out of the crib.

The new rules would impact multiple industries, from manufacturers to retailers who would not be able to sell any cribs already in stock but not meeting the new standards. Many hotels, motels and child-care facilities around the country would likely have to purchase new cribs for their businesses.

The wide-ranging effects could be a strain on some budgets.

"My biggest fear is that day-care centers, in particular, will be stuck with no other option but to place babies in play yards or on floor mats -- even temporarily -- since the purchase of so many new cribs will be quite expensive," said Commissioner Anne Northup in a statement.

But crib retailers and crib manufacturers will see a spike in demand for new cribs

"If you are a crib company, at this point you are probably dancing ... because of the various effects of this law," said Northup. "While companies certainly will lose current inventory that does not meet the new standard, they will also reap tremendous financial rewards since every family and day-care center in the near future will be forced to purchase a brand-new crib."

Families in search of an affordable crib at resellers like thrift stores will also be out of luck for the next few years, as people will no longer be able to donate cribs that do not hold up to the mandatory standards.

A public comment period on the new rules will begin shortly, in which time the agency will assess the comments received and make decisions on whether changes, such as timing, need to be made to the proposed rules. A final vote is expected in December, with the new rules taking effect in the summer of 2011.

The unanimous endorsement of the proposed standards came as the agency announced that Pottery Barn Kids is recalling over 80,000 drop-side cribs due to entrapment, suffocation and fall hazards.

The furniture maker said children have been hurt on seven occasions due to the crib's faulty drop side, which can detach when hardware breaks or is assembled incorrectly.

All incidents resulted in minor injuries when children fell out of the cribs or got their legs caught. In one instance, where an injury was averted, a child's head was trapped between the drop side and the crib mattress.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission is asking consumers to stop using the recalled cribs, inspect the hardware, and contact Pottery Barn Kids to receive a free kit that will convert the drop side to a fixed gate.

The cribs, ranging in price from $300 to $800, were sold at Pottery Barn Kids retail stores, online, or through the store's catalog from January 1999 through March 2010.

[Ban Hammer 13,343]

i'm for this - one death due to a faulty crib design is one death too many.

[luckytxn 2,264]

Probably the Feds way of helping the economy. Ban as much as possible and force us to buy the things they say we should.

[^_^ 5,021]

Again though, I'm a numbers type of person when it comes to things like this.

And that, right there, is what's wrong with you.

[The_Dude 1,142]

And that, right there, is what's wrong with you.

That is akin to a manufacturer doing a cost analysis of fixing a known problem with a recall versus paying out death benefits. Not acceptable when it comes to children.

[^_^ 5,021]

That is akin to a manufacturer doing a cost analysis of fixing a known problem with a recall versus paying out death benefits. Not acceptable when it comes to children.

Right, it's not. A human still in touch with his or her humanity would understand that.

[Obama 2012 1,714]

Right, it's not. A human still in touch with his or her humanity would understand that.

This isn't a one person society. The loss of one or two people; even Children, is not the end of the world.

It's not like 1% of kids are killed by this... not even a quarter of a percent...

so not a worry at all.

Also it's not like every day natural use is what causes the issues.

I said mandate the fixes, but don't ban them.... pretty simple.

[The_Dude 1,142]

This isn't a one person society. The loss of one or two people; even Children, is not the end of the world.

It's not like 1% of kids are killed by this... not even a quarter of a percent...

so not a worry at all.

Also it's not like every day natural use is what causes the issues.

I said mandate the fixes, but don't ban them.... pretty simple.

You're simply arguing semantics cyborg paul.

[Ban Hammer 13,343]

This isn't a one person society. The loss of one or two people; even Children, is not the end of the world.

It's not like 1% of kids are killed by this... not even a quarter of a percent...

so not a worry at all.

Also it's not like every day natural use is what causes the issues.

I said mandate the fixes, but don't ban them.... pretty simple.

be sure to tell that to someone who's lost a child.

[Obama 2012 1,714]

be sure to tell that to someone who's lost a child.

the risks have been there and known about for years, well publicized even.

A parent that doesn't do their research or chooses to buy the product knowing the concerns, I have little sympathy for.

[The_Dude 1,142]

the risks have been there and known about for years, well publicized even.

A parent that doesn't do their research or chooses to buy the product knowing the concerns, I have little sympathy for.

That doesn't make it any more acceptable cyborg paul.

[^_^ 5,021]

A parent that doesn't do their research or chooses to buy the product knowing the concerns, I have little sympathy for.

Yes, because you're a numbers guy and not a people person. We get it.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

A numbers guy would be able to see that this will boost crib sales. parents and daycare centers wouldnt object to purchasing a crib in the knowledge that decent standards exist for the protection of their children.

[Obama 2012 1,714]

That doesn't make it any more acceptable cyborg paul.

people know you shouldn't drink or smoke while pregnant and they still do it... More children develop health problems from that stupidity than die from the cribs..

[Jenn! 918]