Jump to content
gqbabson

Green Card Lost?

 Share

10 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Filed: Country: India
Timeline

Hi VJ'ers,

Hope all is well. I wanted to know of stories of anyone who has had their initial Green Card lost in the mail, and was told that they have to file an I-90 for a replacement.

I am a US Citizen (by Birth) and find the system of Third World Countries far advanced then ours.

My wife came here in August on an Immigrant Visa with no trouble. POE was a breeze.

A month later a letter comes from DHS saying they need biometrics (they lost her fingerprints). We went and got that done.

A month later we get welcome letter. Yay!

6 weeks go by nothing happens. I made an infopass appointment. They said Good News and Bad News: Good News is Greencard was mailed out. Bad News is that it was probably lost in the mail. I have to File an I-90 now, wait 6 months, and pay about $400.

This is absurd. Even when I was in India, such a sensitive document is always sent through delivery confirmation and we are charged for it (which we gladly pay for). US Government does not even offer that (even after charging so much for Visa fees).

I am a Tax Paying Citizen who sends his Taxes every year via Delivery Confirmation, because if any of my documents are not reached to the IRS, then I am penalized. Why does DHS not follow the same rules? I smell government fraud. The DHS did not show me any confirmation that this sent out and lost. That is troublesome and I have lost all faith in the system. I guess they can do this to anyone to make an extra $400 per person.

What is even worse then the monetary and time value lost is that even if that Green Card was stolen or lost, it hurts our Nation's Security because of Identity Theft. Our Country is seriously in the stone age when it comes to processing Immigration at every level.

I asked the Immigration Officer, who can I talk to about the above. He said, "Write a letter to Washington". I said by the time I get a reply, I may already have my wife's Green Card, and he said, "Yup, there is no phone number".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Wales
Timeline

Have you considered moving to India?

“If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.”

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi VJ'ers,

Hope all is well. I wanted to know of stories of anyone who has had their initial Green Card lost in the mail, and was told that they have to file an I-90 for a replacement.

I am a US Citizen (by Birth) and find the system of Third World Countries far advanced then ours.

My wife came here in August on an Immigrant Visa with no trouble. POE was a breeze.

A month later a letter comes from DHS saying they need biometrics (they lost her fingerprints). We went and got that done.

A month later we get welcome letter. Yay!

6 weeks go by nothing happens. I made an infopass appointment. They said Good News and Bad News: Good News is Greencard was mailed out. Bad News is that it was probably lost in the mail. I have to File an I-90 now, wait 6 months, and pay about $400.

This is absurd. Even when I was in India, such a sensitive document is always sent through delivery confirmation and we are charged for it (which we gladly pay for). US Government does not even offer that (even after charging so much for Visa fees).

I am a Tax Paying Citizen who sends his Taxes every year via Delivery Confirmation, because if any of my documents are not reached to the IRS, then I am penalized. Why does DHS not follow the same rules? I smell government fraud. The DHS did not show me any confirmation that this sent out and lost. That is troublesome and I have lost all faith in the system. I guess they can do this to anyone to make an extra $400 per person.

What is even worse then the monetary and time value lost is that even if that Green Card was stolen or lost, it hurts our Nation's Security because of Identity Theft. Our Country is seriously in the stone age when it comes to processing Immigration at every level.

I asked the Immigration Officer, who can I talk to about the above. He said, "Write a letter to Washington". I said by the time I get a reply, I may already have my wife's Green Card, and he said, "Yup, there is no phone number".

We had a similar thing happen to us - never received the GC after 6 months from POE. USCIS infopass told us "it happens all the time, file the I-90 and say you lost, or mutilated the card" (the card which never came and we never moved)!

Involved husband's congressman and on the 2nd attempt managed to get the GC without paying any fees.

PM me so I can send you the letter we sent to our congressman.

ROC 2009
Naturalization 2010

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: Canada
Timeline

I wondering how many of these cards were really "lost" compared to how many might be "stolen".

04-21-2006 | Marriage in Santa Ana, CA
I-130 Process
06-29-2006 | Mailed to CSC
08-23-2006 | Was told application was rejected & sent back
08-30-2006 | Recieved rejected package
09-01-2006 | Resubmitted I-130
09-08-2006 | NOA1 (now that's more like it)
09-13-2006 | Recieved NOA1 in the mail
12-19-2006 | Recieved email RFE
12-20-2006 | Recieved RFE in mail
12-22-2006 | Sent out RFE info
01-09-2007 | NOA2 Email received!
I-130 at NVC
01-24-2007 | Case Number Assigned
02-06-2007 | Emailed DS-3032 COA
02-09-2007 | NVC confirms COA in email
02-20-2007 | DS3032 & AOS Fee Bill Mailed
02-26-2007 | Received DS3032 and AOS Fee Bill
02-28-2007 | Mailed AOS Fee Bill and check
03-13-2007 | I-864 received
03-21-2007 | I-864 sent
05-16-2007 | IV Bill resent from NVC (never got the first)
06-02-2007 | IV Bill received
06-05-2007 | IV Bill payment sent
06-26-2007 | Received DS230
06-29-2007 | Mailed DS230 to NVC
08-15-2007 | NVC process complete but was sent back to US CIS (#@$%#$% this sucks)
11-08-2007 | I-130 returned to NVC
11-08-2007 | Requested expedited interview due to daughters illness
11-21-2007 | NVC approved expedited interview. Mailed to Montreal Embassy Nov 20th
12-11-2007 | Told by contact at US Consulate in Toronto that our interview date will be on Jan 4th.
01-04-2008 | Interview In Montreal. VISA GRANTED
01-11-2008 | Arrival in the US
11-09-2009 | Biometrics taken for 10 year green card
01-20-2010 | Approved- 10 GC ordered for production

06-22-2013 | N-400 package sent

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: India
Timeline

its been 1 month and 2 weeks and i still didnt get my green card either.. can anyone tell me the contact number of uscis so we can talk to them and ask.. we tried on 800 number but always machine is there.. how do we talk to an opratore??

interview date- 11/06/2009

visa approved! 11/17/2009.. pheww!!

received passport-11/20/2009

entered in US- 12/14/2009

POE- New york

welcome received- 02/01/2010

green card received- 02/08/2010

removal of condition-12/15/2011

ROC package sent to CSC- 09/21/2011

http://craftychefcooking.blogspot.com/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry you are having the trouble. I tend to go with the STOLEN theory as well. The should send out these valuable cards disguised as junk mail, but then you have to be careful in not throwing it out yourself. Sounds like you will have to pay for a replacement, unfortunately.

Sign-on-a-church-af.jpgLogic-af.jpgwwiao.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi VJ'ers,

Hope all is well. I wanted to know of stories of anyone who has had their initial Green Card lost in the mail, and was told that they have to file an I-90 for a replacement.

I am a US Citizen (by Birth) and find the system of Third World Countries far advanced then ours.

My wife came here in August on an Immigrant Visa with no trouble. POE was a breeze.

A month later a letter comes from DHS saying they need biometrics (they lost her fingerprints). We went and got that done.

A month later we get welcome letter. Yay!

6 weeks go by nothing happens. I made an infopass appointment. They said Good News and Bad News: Good News is Greencard was mailed out. Bad News is that it was probably lost in the mail. I have to File an I-90 now, wait 6 months, and pay about $400.

This is absurd. Even when I was in India, such a sensitive document is always sent through delivery confirmation and we are charged for it (which we gladly pay for). US Government does not even offer that (even after charging so much for Visa fees).

I am a Tax Paying Citizen who sends his Taxes every year via Delivery Confirmation, because if any of my documents are not reached to the IRS, then I am penalized. Why does DHS not follow the same rules? I smell government fraud. The DHS did not show me any confirmation that this sent out and lost. That is troublesome and I have lost all faith in the system. I guess they can do this to anyone to make an extra $400 per person.

What is even worse then the monetary and time value lost is that even if that Green Card was stolen or lost, it hurts our Nation's Security because of Identity Theft. Our Country is seriously in the stone age when it comes to processing Immigration at every level.

I asked the Immigration Officer, who can I talk to about the above. He said, "Write a letter to Washington". I said by the time I get a reply, I may already have my wife's Green Card, and he said, "Yup, there is no phone number".

Did you read the instructions for the I-90?

If You Never Received Your Permanent Resident Card:

If USCIS mailed you a Permanent Resident Card more than 30 days ago and you have not received it; and It has been returned to USCIS by the Post Office as undeliverable; and You have not moved from the address you provided to USCIS during the application or immigrant visa process that led to the creation of the card not received, or Your Permanent Resident Card was issued with incorrect information because of a USCIS administrative error.

In both of these instances, you must prepare a Form I-90. On the first page of the application, under Part 2, Application type, Number 2, Reason for Application, check box "b" which reads: "My authorized card was never received," or box "d" which reads "My card was issued with incorrect information because of a USCIS administrative error." Include any documents that support your claim with your application.

For those applicants who check box "b," you must send a copy of your Form I-797, Notice of Action, that you received for your previously filed Form I-485, Form I-751, or Form I-90.

For those applicants who check box "d," you must submit the original Form I-551 card containing the incorrect information that supports the requested correction.

I've seen others get their card replaced, free of charge, because they never received it.

My Advice is usually based on "Worst Case Scenario" and what is written in the rules/laws/instructions. That is the way I roll... -Protect your Status - file before your I-94 expires.

WARNING: Phrases in this post may sound meaner than they were intended to be. Read the Adjudicator's Field Manual from USCIS

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: India
Timeline
Did you read the instructions for the I-90?

I've seen others get their card replaced, free of charge, because they never received it.

really?

interview date- 11/06/2009

visa approved! 11/17/2009.. pheww!!

received passport-11/20/2009

entered in US- 12/14/2009

POE- New york

welcome received- 02/01/2010

green card received- 02/08/2010

removal of condition-12/15/2011

ROC package sent to CSC- 09/21/2011

http://craftychefcooking.blogspot.com/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Have you considered moving to India?

+1

Timeline:

07/05/2006. Married in Anniston, AL, USA

I-130

02/06/2008. Mailed I-130 to Chicago Lockbox

02/08/2008. I-130 delivered to Chicago Lockbox. Signed by V BUSTAMANTE

02/20/2008. I-130 NOA1 date. Vermont Service Center

08/26/2008. Touched. (I-130 transferred to California Service Center)

08/27/2008. Touched.

08/28/2008. Touched. (This case is now pending at the office to which it was transferred)

08/29/2008. Touched.

09/26/2008. Touched.

09/27/2008. Touched.

10/16/2008. Touched.

10/17/2008. Touched.

11/12/2008. Touched.(Senator inquired on case status. Case with FBI. Was told not to inquire again for 90 days)

11/13/2008. Touched.

11/26/2008. Touched.

02/18/2009. Touched.(Senator inquired on case status again. Case still with FBI. Was told not to inquire for another 180 days)

02/24/2009. Touched.

03/10/2009. Received letter from USCIS requesting evidence to prove citizenship.

04/04/2009. Approved!! Received letter. Case status online didn't change.

NVC:

04/17/2009. Case number received.

04/22/2009. DS-3032 and AOS bill generated.

04/28/2009. Emailed DS-3032

05/04/2009. Paid AOS bill online.

05/07/2009. DS-3032 accepted.

06/23/2009. AOS mailed received by NVC on 06/26/2009

06/25/2009. Mailed DS-230 package form Azerbaijan received by NVC on 06/30/2009

07/09/2009. False RFE (ds-230 wasn't in the system yet)

07/14/2009. Case Completed!!!

07/30/2009. Got the interview date.

08/27/2009. Medical Passed.

09/29/2009. Interview Passed.

09/30/2009. Visa issued.

10/25/2009. POE Atlanta, Georgia

11/07/2009. 10 year Green Card received!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...