Michael Moore: 'Capitalism is anti-Jesus'

[Heracles 417]

Michael Moore: 'Capitalism is anti-Jesus'

In a Fortune interview, the flame-throwing director explains why his new film brings his religion into the picture for the first time.

By Scott Cendrowski, reporter

Last Updated: September 23, 2009: 8:51 AM ET

NEW YORK (Fortune) -- The title of Michael Moore's latest film, "Capitalism: A Love Story," may be ironic, but there's nothing subtle about the message, right from the opening scenes.

The two-hour documentary begins with footage of a family being evicted from their foreclosed home by a half dozen police officers. Then he presents more incriminating evidence: a bankrupt Chicago factory where workers are denied pay, a privately run juvenile prison that paid off judges to give convicts longer sentences, and last year's $700 billion bailout of the banking system.

Moore, 55, ends with this conclusion: "Capitalism is an evil and you can't regulate evil. You have to replace it with something that is good for everyone."

The writer-director-partisan, who rose to prominence after his 1989 takedown of GM in the documentary "Roger & Me" and his mainstream hit "Fahrenheit 9/11" in 2004, spoke with Fortune on the eve of his film's Wednesday opening in New York City and Los Angeles (it opens nationwide on Oct. 2).

Moore talked about how his Catholic upbringing influenced the film, why Corporate America still irks him, and how to fix his economically troubled home state of Michigan. Excerpts:

You've said you started filming "Capitalism: A Love story" a year and a half ago. Did the film change after Lehman went bankrupt and the stock market crashed?

I've thought about this for 20 years. Ever since "Roger and Me," I've felt the problem here is an economic system that is unjust and unfair. It's not democratic. And I keep making these films but I dance around the subject: it's General Motors here, the health-care industry there, and I started thinking, "Why don't I just name it?"

I started out wanting to explore the premise of capitalism being anti-American, and anti-Jesus, meaning it's not a Democratic economy. And it's not run with a moral or ethical code. But when the crash happened, it added a third plot line: not only is capitalism anti-American and anti-Jesus, it doesn't work.

[The wealthiest Americans] proved that the free market is something they really don't believe in, they don't believe in competition, they actually do believe in socialism, that we the people should use our tax dollars to keep them in their mansions and their yachts.

I think they exposed themselves to a lot of middle class people who did believe in their system and they showed everybody the Ponzi scheme that it is. It's set up like a pyramid, so that the richest 1% at the top have more financial wealth than the 95% beneath them.

But the trick here is to get the 95% believing that if they work hard and slave away, they would get to the top of the pyramid. Of course, as we know, only a few people can stand on top of a pyramid. The fact that this crash exposed our economic system as a corrupt scam was something I didn't intend on happening while I was making the movie.

How is this film different from your previous ones?

I talk about my religion, which I have never talked about. I think religion should be a private matter. But I thought it was important to this discussion. I'm not a proselytizer, but I do have very strong beliefs and these beliefs were formed not in the school of Karl Marx, but in the Catholic Church. Priests and nuns taught me these lessons of how we're to treat each other, how we're to treat the poor, and how we're to divide up the pie.

I'm one of the few people on the left who's been fortunate to have access to a mainstream audience. I'm always thinking about ways to communicate with them and stay true to myself, because I am them, and I come from Middle America. I have very conservative values that go contrary to the fictional character that's been created of me by Bill O'Reilly, Rush Limbaugh, and the Fox News Channel. I've been with the same woman for 30 years, I don't invest my money in anything but a savings account.

Has your view of corporate America changed since your first film, "Roger & Me," opened in 1989?

I've become all the more agitated, especially with what I've seen and with having a peak behind the curtain. Having the life I do, working in an industry that's owned by major corporations. [Moore's film is distributed by a unit of Liberty Media, whose CEO John Malone is a formidable capitalist.]

Just a couple weeks ago, the film was going to debut in the Toronto Film Festival in the Elgin Theatre. Visa sponsors the theater, so during the festival it's called the Visa Screening Room. So they had [the film studio] call me to ask, Is there any reference against Visa in the movie? And this is while they're still deciding whether to put the movie in the festival.

Are there any good things happening in American business?

I see very little support for the things we really need to be investing in. Where's the cure for cancer? Where's the bullet train to take us from New York to L.A. in 10 hours? Where are the alternative energy systems to save us when we run out of oil?

I wish these were the priorities. But when Wall Street sucks up our best mathematicians, physicists, engineers, when they should be working on these other things and instead they're working to create derivatives ... c'mon. We're in deep, deep trouble. We need the best minds working on these things.

You live in Michigan, where you were born and raised. How can Detroit be saved?

It revolves around good-paying jobs. We've allowed the middle class to be decimated over the last 30 years. We've allowed our industrial infrastructure to collapse. So instead of initially giving bailout money to a General Motors that was never going to change or to banks so they can cover losses from crazy betting schemes, this money should be going to helping to create jobs in places like Detroit. People need to work. There are so many things we need to build and create for the 21st century.

I would do what my friend Dan Kildee is doing in Flint, Michigan. He's the county treasurer and he's taken over 9,000 homes that have been abandoned. He's tearing them down and his idea essentially shrank the city in physical size. They restored neighborhoods by building parks, fields and woods.

For crime in Detroit: what is the chance, if the person down the street is making $50,000 to $60,000 a year, [that he would] break into your home to steal your TV?

You tried to get Hank Paulson on the phone in the film, but weren't successful. If you got him on the phone today, what would you ask?

If I had a chance to talk to him, I'd want him to come clean and tell me the truth about how he rigged this whole thing. Tell us what happened because we don't know the details. How did so many Goldman people end up in the administration? How is it that Goldman's chief competitors are left to die -- not bailing out Lehman Bros., Bear Stearns falls apart, Merrill Lynch is absorbed into Bank of America -- and look who's left standing: the company that's got all their boys inside the administration.

If capitalism is evil, what's the solution?

Some people say to me, democracy is not an economic system, it's a political system. My answer to that is, you think capitalism has nothing to do with politics?

Let's quit talking like we're back in Economics 101. Capitalism is not only an economic system that legalizes greed, it also has at its foundation a political system of capitalism that is, "We have to buy the political system because we don't have enough votes. We're only 1% of the votes. We have to buy the people, and we have to buy the people by convincing them if they work hard, they too can be rich one day." [Americans] have gone along with it for the last 30 years.

First Published: September 23, 2009: 8:45 AM ET

Find this article at:

http://money.cnn.com/2009/09/22/news/econo...rtune/index.htm

Edited September 24, 2009 by Booyah!

[Ban Hammer 13,333]

like anyone pays attention to mikey moore?

[Heracles 417]

like anyone pays attention to mikey moore?

Hey I think he is onto something here.

I certainly don't want to be like one of these guys who refuse to listen to Bill O'reilly or Glenn Beck, just because they don't like him.

Edited September 24, 2009 by Booyah!

[AlHayatZween 2]

i would go see the film if it opens here in BTR.

[thepizzadude 26]

I've never really liked Michael Moore either but alot of what he is saying he talks about in this movie is IMHO the truth.

[I AM NOT THAT GUY 5,715]

Maybe Mikey and Rush could have a sumo wrestling match. I might pay to see that, although I would have to wear dark sunglasses, so as not to be blinded by their huge pale white asses!

[Joseph & Ana 0]

Actually Rush is bone skinny now. He'd lose the match.

[Ban Hammer 13,333]

Actually Rush is bone skinny now. He'd lose the match.

if rush sat still long enough, mikey would probably eat him too.

[Nagishkaw 510]

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

Moore makes some interesting points in that piece.

I still prefer his TV series to his movies.

[almaty 19]

'Capitalism is anti-Jesus'

as spokesman for commies for christ......we knew that sh!t 3 years ago

[SMR 368]

I agree that there are a lot of problems with big businesses. I have had some problems of my own and there isn't much that you can do about it. It's trues that the American system has huge problems.

However, big government is much worse than big business. There is no business in America that can force you to use them. You can always go elsewhere or do without their services. Government will always tax you.

I think it's useful to not try and classify organizations too departmentally. All organizations should be measured with the same yardstick. This includes the government, businesses, big and small, churches, schools, non-profit organizations, political action committees, etc. How could banks, which can't force you to use their services be more evil than an organization that in effect claims to own part of all property, forcefully claims a significant portion of all income, all sales, and violently punishes anyone who disputes these claims.

It's not really honest to claim that an average citizen has a say in what happens in the government because a single vote doesn't matter. A working person doesn't really have the time or resources to effect the change that they would like to see in the government. The services that are rendered by the government are not really proportional to the taxes collected.

So why is the government less evil than big business?

I realize that it isn't a valid argument to say that one group(business) is less evil just because another group(the government) is more evil. The point that the government is more evil is relevant because the answer to solving the problem of big business is not the government. For example, it's true that insurance companies can be unjust and dishonest. But I don't believe that the government is going to be more reasonable or fair.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

Well... you can kind of control the government, because after all, they are us.

[one...two...tree 2,762]

'Capitalism is anti-Jesus'

as spokesman for commies for christ......we knew that sh!t 3 years ago

Amen, brother. I think it's time to give Mike's lawyers a call.

[SMR 368]

Well... you can kind of control the government, because after all, they are us.

That's sounds great. But what can you actually get the government to do? Maybe if you had the time and money to sit in the mall and collect signatures then you could get a petition on the ballot. But even then the courts might just throw it out.

"They are us." --Do you work for the government? I suppose this is true in a more idealistic sense that we have a government of the people. But in reality, the government is a large organization with millions of employees (or a conglomerate of smaller organizations, probably more accurately). But even if you are part of this organization (work for them) it doesn't really give you decision making influence.