Jump to content
Jonara

French Immigration vs. U.S. Immigration

 Share

19 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline

This topic goes out to USC/French petitioners and beneficiaries.

Prior to receiving my NO2 approval notice, my fiance and I were a bit frustrated and were looking at marrying in France instead. He said the immigration process in France is a lot easier than the U.S. I'm somehow not convinced.

1. He mentioned there is a thing called pax (oh I don't recall the spelling) that allows you to be a couple and enjoy the benefits of a married couple even though it is truly not a marriage. Anyone has heard of that?

2. I also thought with an intent to marry, I have to apply for a long stay visa as opposed to coming to France like I normally do without a visa. Thoughts?

3. Supposed I move to France, what are the rules around getting a work permit and how long will it take?

If anyone knows of a site link that I can check, please let me know. I have a tough time navigating thru the sites that I found and for some reason, the information I'm getting is in bits and pieces.

We finally got our NO2 but of course it wouldn't hurt to know French immigration info. Any helpful feedback will be great.

Merci.

Lara

- LB

Stay tune for yet another immi-saga in the life of LB & JD. Coming soon ---> AOS Chronicles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This topic goes out to USC/French petitioners and beneficiaries.

Prior to receiving my NO2 approval notice, my fiance and I were a bit frustrated and were looking at marrying in France instead. He said the immigration process in France is a lot easier than the U.S. I'm somehow not convinced.

1. He mentioned there is a thing called pax (oh I don't recall the spelling) that allows you to be a couple and enjoy the benefits of a married couple even though it is truly not a marriage. Anyone has heard of that?

2. I also thought with an intent to marry, I have to apply for a long stay visa as opposed to coming to France like I normally do without a visa. Thoughts?

3. Supposed I move to France, what are the rules around getting a work permit and how long will it take?

If anyone knows of a site link that I can check, please let me know. I have a tough time navigating thru the sites that I found and for some reason, the information I'm getting is in bits and pieces.

We finally got our NO2 but of course it wouldn't hurt to know French immigration info. Any helpful feedback will be great.

Merci.

Lara

Getting a work visa in France is extremly hard, much less finding a job. I was offered a great job in Paris a few weeks ago, was told could take 1 year for work visa. Try another option. Hard to immigrate to France

Edited by Paris Heart

Truly happy!!!

New life, new adventures, and a new attitude.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
This topic goes out to USC/French petitioners and beneficiaries.

Prior to receiving my NO2 approval notice, my fiance and I were a bit frustrated and were looking at marrying in France instead. He said the immigration process in France is a lot easier than the U.S. I'm somehow not convinced.

1. He mentioned there is a thing called pax (oh I don't recall the spelling) that allows you to be a couple and enjoy the benefits of a married couple even though it is truly not a marriage. Anyone has heard of that?

2. I also thought with an intent to marry, I have to apply for a long stay visa as opposed to coming to France like I normally do without a visa. Thoughts?

3. Supposed I move to France, what are the rules around getting a work permit and how long will it take?

If anyone knows of a site link that I can check, please let me know. I have a tough time navigating thru the sites that I found and for some reason, the information I'm getting is in bits and pieces.

We finally got our NO2 but of course it wouldn't hurt to know French immigration info. Any helpful feedback will be great.

Merci.

Lara

Getting a work visa in France is extremly hard, much less finding a job. I was offered a great job in Paris a few weeks ago, was told could take 1 year for work visa. Try another option. Hard to immigrate to France

Caught you Beth lol! Betsy and I were just talking about you and wondering where you went!

Ok back to topic. Immigration to France can take as long or longer than to the US. At least if you go through the immigration process to the US you have an estimated time period and for the most part everyone falls within that period. For example, when I filed my CR1, the estimated time was 6 months, our interview is on tuesday and it will have been just a little over 6 months.

Met: 2004-07-18

Islamic marriage: 2006-07-31

Marriage : 2008-12-27

Entry San Fran 2009-09-27

Hubby is HOME!!!!

Received SSN 2009-10-06

Received welcome letter 2009-10-10

GREEN CARD!!! 2009-10-13

Driver's License 2009-10-26

HUBBY FOUND A JOB!!! after about 4 months of being here :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline

The PACS allows the foreigner to get a residency card IF they can proove they have already been living together for a year. Quite dumb I know...

I've got a bunch of canadian friends here in Paris who have really high degrees and they have to fight like crazy with the french immigration.

And it's a neverending fight, it takes many years before getting a 5 years residency card...

There is two kind of specific visas for marriage, one with no residency, one with.

The denial rate is very high. You're not able to appeal, and they can deny you without any reason.

It's nothing like the US immigration...

In France, it's very recommended to hire a lawyer and it will cost you an arm and leg.

Do you speak french? :x

Last significant immigration event:

ROC: Approved : 04/17/2013

USCIS works in mysterious ways...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
The PACS allows the foreigner to get a residency card IF they can proove they have already been living together for a year. Quite dumb I know...

I've got a bunch of canadian friends here in Paris who have really high degrees and they have to fight like crazy with the french immigration.

And it's a neverending fight, it takes many years before getting a 5 years residency card...

There is two kind of specific visas for marriage, one with no residency, one with.

The denial rate is very high. You're not able to appeal, and they can deny you without any reason.

It's nothing like the US immigration...

In France, it's very recommended to hire a lawyer and it will cost you an arm and leg.

Do you speak french? :x

Do I? Non, not yet at least. That is part of my hesitation to move there now. I have to learn the language, and learn it really well.

But hey thanks for your info. I kinda sense it's not gonna be that easy but I figured to find out anyway. We were simply frustrated one day from living apart and waiting. A day later, my NO2 notice came. Voila. I hope your NO2 process goes smoothly. Merci bcp!

- LB

Stay tune for yet another immi-saga in the life of LB & JD. Coming soon ---> AOS Chronicles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline

Well, I have mixed feeling here from what I read. My wife and I lived in Paris before moving here and she got her "carte de sejour" (resident card) in about 8 weeks - her job got it for her.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
Well, I have mixed feeling here from what I read. My wife and I lived in Paris before moving here and she got her "carte de sejour" (resident card) in about 8 weeks - her job got it for her.

Sounds she could have been an expatriated worker for a big corporation?

That's very different.

Last significant immigration event:

ROC: Approved : 04/17/2013

USCIS works in mysterious ways...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
Well, I have mixed feeling here from what I read. My wife and I lived in Paris before moving here and she got her "carte de sejour" (resident card) in about 8 weeks - her job got it for her.

Was it an American company based in Paris?

- LB

Stay tune for yet another immi-saga in the life of LB & JD. Coming soon ---> AOS Chronicles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
Well, I have mixed feeling here from what I read. My wife and I lived in Paris before moving here and she got her "carte de sejour" (resident card) in about 8 weeks - her job got it for her.

Sounds she could have been an expatriated worker for a big corporation?

That's very different.

Agreed - She wasn't an expat but was on a "short term assignment". My point was that by making yourself needed by a big company in France then they would sponsor you. Are you able to make yourself needed when you don't speak french if you are not already an employee, I don't think so :) haha - ok Iam loopsided :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
This topic goes out to USC/French petitioners and beneficiaries.

Prior to receiving my NO2 approval notice, my fiance and I were a bit frustrated and were looking at marrying in France instead. He said the immigration process in France is a lot easier than the U.S. I'm somehow not convinced.

1. He mentioned there is a thing called pax (oh I don't recall the spelling) that allows you to be a couple and enjoy the benefits of a married couple even though it is truly not a marriage. Anyone has heard of that?

2. I also thought with an intent to marry, I have to apply for a long stay visa as opposed to coming to France like I normally do without a visa. Thoughts?

3. Supposed I move to France, what are the rules around getting a work permit and how long will it take?

If anyone knows of a site link that I can check, please let me know. I have a tough time navigating thru the sites that I found and for some reason, the information I'm getting is in bits and pieces.

We finally got our NO2 but of course it wouldn't hurt to know French immigration info. Any helpful feedback will be great.

Merci.

Lara

Getting a work visa in France is extremly hard, much less finding a job. I was offered a great job in Paris a few weeks ago, was told could take 1 year for work visa. Try another option. Hard to immigrate to France

Are you sure about what you say?

some good links hereafter

wiki about immigration

http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_e...e_fran.C3.A7ais

wiki about PACS

http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/PACS

long stay visa to get married in France

http://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/france_15...ance_10899.html

I'd be curious about bringing my husband here.

always thought it would be very easy.

Would imagine that he can come any time and then request to stay and and be authorised to work

but have not looked at it really.

Log

Wedding 01-2006

USCIS

I-130 NOA1 : 11-20-08 I-130 NOA2 : 05-14-2009

I-129F NOA1 : 12-04-08 I-129F NOA2 : 05-14-2009 Took no action since

NVC

Case number assigned at NVC : 05-18-2009

Case Completed at NVC : 08-03

Interview scheduled: 08-13

Embassy

medical : done 08-17 + pick up 09-08

Interview Date: 09-08-09

Visa received : 09-11-09 valid till 03-10-10

October 10th entered US with Visa Waiver Program for 2 weeks holidays (not usual with visa received!)

had to go through secondary inspections to explain

November 25th entered again US with WVP, officer did not notice my green card visa

left US on dec 28 to avoid meeting the substantial presence test for IRS

Jan 9 2010 entered and activated green card though PHL port of entry

waiting for SSN requested with DS230 and 10 years GC

01-30 received tracking number for GC Welcome issued on 01-27

but not yet SSN

SSN expected by Feb 20 else I might go and ask for one regardless of DS230

GC expected by March 27

Feb 3 2010 update card ordered says to allow for 30 days

Feb 8 2010 update saying approval notice sent

Feb 12 2010 received GC card Permanent resident valid till 2020

Feb 18 2010 went to file ss5 for ssn card as not yet received and center would not find me in ssn files

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline

another good link to learn French

http://vosdroits.service-public.fr/particu...20&l=N16144

If already married you can ask for a visa for personal reasons "vie privée et familiale"

In that case you don't require "carte de sejour"

then about working I don't know

also I don't know how long it takes

Log

Wedding 01-2006

USCIS

I-130 NOA1 : 11-20-08 I-130 NOA2 : 05-14-2009

I-129F NOA1 : 12-04-08 I-129F NOA2 : 05-14-2009 Took no action since

NVC

Case number assigned at NVC : 05-18-2009

Case Completed at NVC : 08-03

Interview scheduled: 08-13

Embassy

medical : done 08-17 + pick up 09-08

Interview Date: 09-08-09

Visa received : 09-11-09 valid till 03-10-10

October 10th entered US with Visa Waiver Program for 2 weeks holidays (not usual with visa received!)

had to go through secondary inspections to explain

November 25th entered again US with WVP, officer did not notice my green card visa

left US on dec 28 to avoid meeting the substantial presence test for IRS

Jan 9 2010 entered and activated green card though PHL port of entry

waiting for SSN requested with DS230 and 10 years GC

01-30 received tracking number for GC Welcome issued on 01-27

but not yet SSN

SSN expected by Feb 20 else I might go and ask for one regardless of DS230

GC expected by March 27

Feb 3 2010 update card ordered says to allow for 30 days

Feb 8 2010 update saying approval notice sent

Feb 12 2010 received GC card Permanent resident valid till 2020

Feb 18 2010 went to file ss5 for ssn card as not yet received and center would not find me in ssn files

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline

another good link to learn French

http://vosdroits.service-public.fr/particu...20&l=N16144

and also

http://vosdroits.service-public.fr/particu...tml#titreN1004A

If already married you can ask for a visa for personal reasons "vie privée et familiale"

In that case you don't require "carte de sejour"

also I don't know how long it takes

you may ask at Embassy if abroad

also apparently you can already be in France and request the visa then

I see a condition about you showing interest for learning French

About working I don't know

it does not seem to me that France is difficult about allowing spouses to be together

only if suspicious of Fraud

maybe when marriage is recentor spouse if from a country that immigrates a lot to France

... or the spouse is not learning French

Edited by Frenchwife

Log

Wedding 01-2006

USCIS

I-130 NOA1 : 11-20-08 I-130 NOA2 : 05-14-2009

I-129F NOA1 : 12-04-08 I-129F NOA2 : 05-14-2009 Took no action since

NVC

Case number assigned at NVC : 05-18-2009

Case Completed at NVC : 08-03

Interview scheduled: 08-13

Embassy

medical : done 08-17 + pick up 09-08

Interview Date: 09-08-09

Visa received : 09-11-09 valid till 03-10-10

October 10th entered US with Visa Waiver Program for 2 weeks holidays (not usual with visa received!)

had to go through secondary inspections to explain

November 25th entered again US with WVP, officer did not notice my green card visa

left US on dec 28 to avoid meeting the substantial presence test for IRS

Jan 9 2010 entered and activated green card though PHL port of entry

waiting for SSN requested with DS230 and 10 years GC

01-30 received tracking number for GC Welcome issued on 01-27

but not yet SSN

SSN expected by Feb 20 else I might go and ask for one regardless of DS230

GC expected by March 27

Feb 3 2010 update card ordered says to allow for 30 days

Feb 8 2010 update saying approval notice sent

Feb 12 2010 received GC card Permanent resident valid till 2020

Feb 18 2010 went to file ss5 for ssn card as not yet received and center would not find me in ssn files

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
another good link to learn French

http://vosdroits.service-public.fr/particu...20&l=N16144

and also

http://vosdroits.service-public.fr/particu...tml#titreN1004A

If already married you can ask for a visa for personal reasons "vie privée et familiale"

In that case you don't require "carte de sejour"

also I don't know how long it takes

you may ask at Embassy if abroad

also apparently you can already be in France and request the visa then

I see a condition about you showing interest for learning French

About working I don't know

it does not seem to me that France is difficult about allowing spouses to be together

only if suspicious of Fraud

maybe when marriage is recentor spouse if from a country that immigrates a lot to France

... or the spouse is not learning French

would like to amend myself, thought I had removed this part from my post

i]it does not seem to me that France is difficult about allowing spouses to be together

only if suspicious of Fraud

maybe when marriage is recentor spouse if from a country that immigrates a lot to France

... or the spouse is not learning French[/i]

It may not be easy

only it is not obvious from "procedures" where it is difficult

probably pratically can be difficult, in particular if not talking French or not handled by a person

proficient in French and in paperwork

sorry I am not writing very well

tired

should go to sleep now

Edited by Frenchwife

Log

Wedding 01-2006

USCIS

I-130 NOA1 : 11-20-08 I-130 NOA2 : 05-14-2009

I-129F NOA1 : 12-04-08 I-129F NOA2 : 05-14-2009 Took no action since

NVC

Case number assigned at NVC : 05-18-2009

Case Completed at NVC : 08-03

Interview scheduled: 08-13

Embassy

medical : done 08-17 + pick up 09-08

Interview Date: 09-08-09

Visa received : 09-11-09 valid till 03-10-10

October 10th entered US with Visa Waiver Program for 2 weeks holidays (not usual with visa received!)

had to go through secondary inspections to explain

November 25th entered again US with WVP, officer did not notice my green card visa

left US on dec 28 to avoid meeting the substantial presence test for IRS

Jan 9 2010 entered and activated green card though PHL port of entry

waiting for SSN requested with DS230 and 10 years GC

01-30 received tracking number for GC Welcome issued on 01-27

but not yet SSN

SSN expected by Feb 20 else I might go and ask for one regardless of DS230

GC expected by March 27

Feb 3 2010 update card ordered says to allow for 30 days

Feb 8 2010 update saying approval notice sent

Feb 12 2010 received GC card Permanent resident valid till 2020

Feb 18 2010 went to file ss5 for ssn card as not yet received and center would not find me in ssn files

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: France
Timeline
Are you sure about what you say?

some good links hereafter

wiki about immigration

http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_e...e_fran.C3.A7ais

wiki about PACS

http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/PACS

long stay visa to get married in France

http://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/france_15...ance_10899.html

I'd be curious about bringing my husband here.

always thought it would be very easy.

Would imagine that he can come any time and then request to stay and and be authorised to work

but have not looked at it really.

Though it's a cool tool, Wiki is always the last thing I reference for anything. The site relies on volunteers to charge articles in there. I'm not against that site by the way but in terms of immigration laws and regulations, I'd prefer to go for the most reliable source...which I presumed will be a French immigration website. :blink:

p.s. Thanks for your info too!

Edited by Jonara

- LB

Stay tune for yet another immi-saga in the life of LB & JD. Coming soon ---> AOS Chronicles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...