My wife interview, blue sheet @ HCM consulate

[NQT1976 1]

My wife interview on 8/5/09, she answer every question well but got stupid blue sheet.( in attachment)

they requested nonsense evidence like I-864A which I don't need to file one( I file I-864 annual income $38000 only I and my wife in the household).

then they asked chronology(timeline). I dont know what kind of timeline they need, they want a letter or detail listing ?

anybody help, please

[Anh map 2,098]

Did you include anyone else in the income calculation for the I-864? If only your income then line 23 should be $38000.

Did you list anyone on line 24b? Did you check the box on line 24d?

Did your income change drastically from 2008 to 2009? Will your 2009 income be similar to 2008? If they see current income (2009) much lower and closer to the minimum they want a co-sponsor. The way the blue slip reads I am thinking that your I-864 indicated there is a co/joint sponsor.

[NQT1976 1]

Did you include anyone else in the income calculation for the I-864? If only your income then line 23 should be $38000.

Did you list anyone on line 24b? Did you check the box on line 24d?

Did your income change drastically from 2008 to 2009? Will your 2009 income be similar to 2008? If they see current income (2009) much lower and closer to the minimum they want a co-sponsor. The way the blue slip reads I am thinking that your I-864 indicated there is a co/joint sponsor.

my manual income $38000 and will increase 2.75% each year according to union policy, my 2008 tax return is $24000 since I just get new job at middle of 2008. In tax return I only list my income and my wife have no income and filing as joint.

I dont check any box 24b or 24d.

yes, look like they want cosponsor. but why ? I got income last year of $24000, this year $38000 and next year $40000. they are so crazy.

what should I do ? add cosponsor and timeline or just write timeline and explain them that I dont need cosponsor ?

[pushbrk 12,883]

My wife interview on 8/5/09, she answer every question well but got stupid blue sheet.( in attachment)

they requested nonsense evidence like I-864A which I don't need to file one( I file I-864 annual income $38000 only I and my wife in the household).

then they asked chronology(timeline). I dont know what kind of timeline they need, they want a letter or detail listing ?

anybody help, please

Use the description in the blue slip as your guide and give them everything they want. Sometimes they'll just ask for this with no specific reason in mind but you should be thinking about why they may have a concern about how you met and how your relationship progressed. Then be certain to give satisfactory information about any potential red flag. For instance, if you met her through friends or family, they'll be concerned the relationship is about a green card instead of about the couple. Take this very seriously. HCMC is a tough place from which to obtain a visa.

[ScottThuy 140]

Did you include anyone else in the income calculation for the I-864? If only your income then line 23 should be $38000.

Did you list anyone on line 24b? Did you check the box on line 24d?

Did your income change drastically from 2008 to 2009? Will your 2009 income be similar to 2008? If they see current income (2009) much lower and closer to the minimum they want a co-sponsor. The way the blue slip reads I am thinking that your I-864 indicated there is a co/joint sponsor.

I think I understand the income flag Roger..... He submitted proof of 08 income less than the required level... they dont care that he likely makes more now.. they are looking at over time and are requiring a co sponsor due to the shortfall in 08. IMO even though you likely will make 38000 this year.. they dont have IRS documentation of it happening before so are requiring the Co sponsor...

The timeline issue is easily resolved by doing a search in the Asia: East and Pacific (Except China) area of this te for 'timeline' there are a couple of great dicussions there that will address that issue.

[NQT1976 1]

Did you include anyone else in the income calculation for the I-864? If only your income then line 23 should be $38000.

Did you list anyone on line 24b? Did you check the box on line 24d?

Did your income change drastically from 2008 to 2009? Will your 2009 income be similar to 2008? If they see current income (2009) much lower and closer to the minimum they want a co-sponsor. The way the blue slip reads I am thinking that your I-864 indicated there is a co/joint sponsor.

I think I understand the income flag Roger..... He submitted proof of 08 income less than the required level... they dont care that he likely makes more now.. they are looking at over time and are requiring a co sponsor due to the shortfall in 08. IMO even though you likely will make 38000 this year.. they dont have IRS documentation of it happening before so are requiring the Co sponsor...

The timeline issue is easily resolved by doing a search in the Asia: East and Pacific (Except China) area of this te for 'timeline' there are a couple of great dicussions there that will address that issue.

look like you missed my last post, I made $24,000 for 2008. the required level is only $17,500.

[ScottThuy 140]

My oversight... I guess I am thrown by the fact that you filled out a I-864 and not an I-134... Did you file an I-134 showing the required income?

The I-864 was not really needed unless it was an AOS.

When do I file a Form I-864 if my fiancé(e), spouse, or child is a “K” nonimmigrant?

If your relative is either a “K-1” fiancé(e), a “K-3” spouse, or a “K-2” or “K-4” child of fiancé(e) or spouse, you do not need to submit a Form I-864 at the time you file your Form I-129F petition. Instead, you should submit a Form I-864 at the time that your fiancé(e), spouse, or child adjusts status to permanent resident after coming to the United States.

You don't have a timeline filled out on VJ but do show that you are a K1 filer so I am assuming you are talking about the interview at HCMC for the K1 and are not doing any AOS at this point...

[hniHnitsuJ 8]

Did you include anyone else in the income calculation for the I-864? If only your income then line 23 should be $38000.

Did you list anyone on line 24b? Did you check the box on line 24d?

Did your income change drastically from 2008 to 2009? Will your 2009 income be similar to 2008? If they see current income (2009) much lower and closer to the minimum they want a co-sponsor. The way the blue slip reads I am thinking that your I-864 indicated there is a co/joint sponsor.

my manual income $38000 and will increase 2.75% each year according to union policy, my 2008 tax return is $24000 since I just get new job at middle of 2008. In tax return I only list my income and my wife have no income and filing as joint.

I dont check any box 24b or 24d.

yes, look like they want cosponsor. but why ? I got income last year of $24000, this year $38000 and next year $40000. they are so crazy.

what should I do ? add cosponsor and timeline or just write timeline and explain them that I dont need cosponsor ?

Are you K1 or CR1, K1 doesn't allow cosponsor in VN.

[Anh map 2,098]

Actually the required amount is $18,212 for 2009. Be sure that you are using the most current information.

Did you have a lot of deductions to your income that would have shown line 22 on your 2008 form 1040 less than 18,212? That is the income number used, not the gross amount. If line 22 is too low, then a co/joint sponsor will be needed.

You filed for a CR1 spouse visa, correct? Your VJ listing shows that you as a K1 fiance visa petitioner and that is leading to confusion. The affidavit of support for K visa petitions is I-134, CR1 petitions require the I-864. Which is correct? Are you petitioning for a fiancee or a wife?

The timeline is now standard at HCMC. Don't take this step lightly. Your submission needs to be detailed with regard to how you met, when you met, who introduced you, your visits to VN, when you were engaged, married, etc. Be sure to address all the topics/events mentioned on the blue slip.

FYI - There is one member whose wife is interviewing in the morning that is submitting a 13 page timeline document. Check back tonight to see if it did the job.

[NQT1976 1]

Actually the required amount is $18,212 for 2009. Be sure that you are using the most current information.

Did you have a lot of deductions to your income that would have shown line 22 on your 2008 form 1040 less than 18,212? That is the income number used, not the gross amount. If line 22 is too low, then a co/joint sponsor will be needed.

You filed for a CR1 spouse visa, correct? Your VJ listing shows that you as a K1 fiance visa petitioner and that is leading to confusion. The affidavit of support for K visa petitions is I-134, CR1 petitions require the I-864. Which is correct? Are you petitioning for a fiancee or a wife?

The timeline is now standard at HCMC. Don't take this step lightly. Your submission needs to be detailed with regard to how you met, when you met, who introduced you, your visits to VN, when you were engaged, married, etc. Be sure to address all the topics/events mentioned on the blue slip.

FYI - There is one member whose wife is interviewing in the morning that is submitting a 13 page timeline document. Check back tonight to see if it did the job.

I got deduction ( student loan interest) line 22 is $24,000, line 37 is $22,900.

I file for CR1 visa.

my wife hire someone (dich vu) in VIETNAM write a chronology( timeline ) cost her 250000vnd, I dont know if he know anything or not. He write like a letter, it is not look like chronology to me.

any one have good form of chronology for HCMC ?

[NQT1976 1]

Did you include anyone else in the income calculation for the I-864? If only your income then line 23 should be $38000.

Did you list anyone on line 24b? Did you check the box on line 24d?

Did your income change drastically from 2008 to 2009? Will your 2009 income be similar to 2008? If they see current income (2009) much lower and closer to the minimum they want a co-sponsor. The way the blue slip reads I am thinking that your I-864 indicated there is a co/joint sponsor.

my manual income $38000 and will increase 2.75% each year according to union policy, my 2008 tax return is $24000 since I just get new job at middle of 2008. In tax return I only list my income and my wife have no income and filing as joint.

I dont check any box 24b or 24d.

yes, look like they want cosponsor. but why ? I got income last year of $24000, this year $38000 and next year $40000. they are so crazy.

what should I do ? add cosponsor and timeline or just write timeline and explain them that I dont need cosponsor ?

Are you K1 or CR1, K1 doesn't allow cosponsor in VN.

I file K1 couple year ago, and my wife failed the interview, my income low at that time.

now I file CR-1/IR-1 this time.

[ScottThuy 140]

Actually the required amount is $18,212 for 2009. Be sure that you are using the most current information.

Did you have a lot of deductions to your income that would have shown line 22 on your 2008 form 1040 less than 18,212? That is the income number used, not the gross amount. If line 22 is too low, then a co/joint sponsor will be needed.

You filed for a CR1 spouse visa, correct? Your VJ listing shows that you as a K1 fiance visa petitioner and that is leading to confusion. The affidavit of support for K visa petitions is I-134, CR1 petitions require the I-864. Which is correct? Are you petitioning for a fiancee or a wife?

The timeline is now standard at HCMC. Don't take this step lightly. Your submission needs to be detailed with regard to how you met, when you met, who introduced you, your visits to VN, when you were engaged, married, etc. Be sure to address all the topics/events mentioned on the blue slip.

FYI - There is one member whose wife is interviewing in the morning that is submitting a 13 page timeline document. Check back tonight to see if it did the job.

I got deduction ( student loan interest) line 22 is $24,000, line 37 is $22,900.

I file for CR1 visa.

my wife hire someone (dich vu) in VIETNAM write a chronology( timeline ) cost her 250000vnd, I dont know if he know anything or not. He write like a letter, it is not look like chronology to me.

any one have good form of chronology for HCMC ?

Cheap for the price, but still a waste of $.. do a search in the asia east and pacific area of VJ for 'timeline' a few really good examples in past weeks discussions..

[Huong and Phung 0]

Did anyone see the dates are different on the bluesheet? On the English section it says 25/8/09 but on the vietnamese translation it says 2/9/09. What's going on there? Can anyone explain?

[BinhJerome 14]

You will need to do the timeline, not her. It will have to be signed and notorized by you. My fiancee had a timeline that she did and they did not accept. They will interview your wife, so with a timeline they can hear from you in your words about your relationship not in hers. I will email you snippets from my timeline.

Jerpome

[johncali9 6]

You will need to do the timeline, not her. It will have to be signed and notorized by you. My fiancee had a timeline that she did and they did not accept. They will interview your wife, so with a timeline they can hear from you in your words about your relationship not in hers. I will email you snippets from my timeline.

Jerpome

Hey brother Binh

What's up men long time no talk,how you case going let us know why you keep bommbard men

john