Jump to content

59 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 58
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Filed: Country: Philippines
Timeline
Posted

Gary, do you know what percentage of you Fed income tax goes to welfare? Because if you do, you can then estimate how much you are paying for welfare based on your annually salary. Now, if you were to donate the same amount to your favorite charity, your taxable income would be less. You can complain all you want about taxes going towards things you don't agree with, but that's just part of living in this country...or any country for that matter.

Sorry, your math doesn't work but it is probably because you never did income taxes.

Let's say I know that exactly $10,000 of my taxes goes to welfare. So "instead" I DONATE another $10,000 of my income to local charities. Only I CAN'T do this "instead" as the government does not give me this choice and confiscates the money from pay before I can receive it and makes decisions about how to use it. This way they can give it to stupid sluts who open their legs and make babies with anyone. Most normal people would abject to this and not voluntarily donote to such nonsense. So, anyway, I follow your stellar tax advise and donate the money to the local disaster relief fund and they are very happy and give me a "thank you dinner"

Come the next February, I DEDUCT the $10,000 from my income. WOW a great idea you had. I am in the 35% tax bracket and will get $3500 of my $10,000 "back" (thank you very much oh wise and benevolent government, oh and never mind, keep the interest on the loan) and STILL paid $10,000 to welfare. So now I am out $20,000 and got back $3,500. Yikes. Get a clue.

See, the problem is, donations are deductions from INCOME, not from TAXES. So you only "save" the amount of tax you would have paid on that amount of income. Paying $10,000 for the purpose of recieiving a one time return of $3,500 would make me more stupid than the sluts making babies with this prize winning sperm shooter.

On the other hand, if you left me the $10,000 in MY income and then taxed my spending, instead of my income, giving me some disgression on how to spend some money. Especially if donations were not a taxed form of "spending"

Gary, you're not paying $10,000 in tax towards welfare. In fact, I doubt if many do. Even if your total federal income tax after deductions was $10,000, 11.79% goes to unemployment and welfare...or $1,179. If you gave that much to charities, your taxable income would be lower and you'd be paying less fed tax. It's not a dollar for dollar exchange, but you can lower your tax by giving to charities. In fact, it is advisable if your taxable income is in a higher tax bracket.

(unemployment and welfare is the purple slice - 11.79%)

800px-Fy2007spendingbycategory.png

Posted

The amount of taxation collected is irrelevant. It has been shown empirically that individuals will economize their wages better than any government will. Incentive matters.

Tahoma, if you want to help the children, then I applaud your generosity. But, no individual should be forced to bear the cost of another individual's action by forcible taxation.

21FUNNY.gif
Filed: Country: Philippines
Timeline
Posted (edited)
The amount of taxation collected is irrelevant. It has been shown empirically that individuals will economize their wages better than any government will. Incentive matters.

Tahoma, if you want to help the children, then I applaud your generosity. But, no individual should be forced to bear the cost of another individual's action by forcible taxation.

The idea that taxation is forced upon but wages are contractual is a fallacy, Matt. An individual is free to enter or leave this country, just like a job. By choosing to live here, you entering into a contract with the government.

Edited by Col. 'Bat' Guano
Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Ukraine
Timeline
Posted

Gary, do you know what percentage of you Fed income tax goes to welfare? Because if you do, you can then estimate how much you are paying for welfare based on your annually salary. Now, if you were to donate the same amount to your favorite charity, your taxable income would be less. You can complain all you want about taxes going towards things you don't agree with, but that's just part of living in this country...or any country for that matter.

Sorry, your math doesn't work but it is probably because you never did income taxes.

Let's say I know that exactly $10,000 of my taxes goes to welfare. So "instead" I DONATE another $10,000 of my income to local charities. Only I CAN'T do this "instead" as the government does not give me this choice and confiscates the money from pay before I can receive it and makes decisions about how to use it. This way they can give it to stupid sluts who open their legs and make babies with anyone. Most normal people would abject to this and not voluntarily donote to such nonsense. So, anyway, I follow your stellar tax advise and donate the money to the local disaster relief fund and they are very happy and give me a "thank you dinner"

Come the next February, I DEDUCT the $10,000 from my income. WOW a great idea you had. I am in the 35% tax bracket and will get $3500 of my $10,000 "back" (thank you very much oh wise and benevolent government, oh and never mind, keep the interest on the loan) and STILL paid $10,000 to welfare. So now I am out $20,000 and got back $3,500. Yikes. Get a clue.

See, the problem is, donations are deductions from INCOME, not from TAXES. So you only "save" the amount of tax you would have paid on that amount of income. Paying $10,000 for the purpose of recieiving a one time return of $3,500 would make me more stupid than the sluts making babies with this prize winning sperm shooter.

On the other hand, if you left me the $10,000 in MY income and then taxed my spending, instead of my income, giving me some disgression on how to spend some money. Especially if donations were not a taxed form of "spending"

Gary, you're not paying $10,000 in tax towards welfare. In fact, I doubt if many do. Even if your total federal income tax after deductions was $10,000, 11.79% goes to unemployment and welfare...or $1,179. If you gave that much to charities, your taxable income would be lower and you'd be paying less fed tax. It's not a dollar for dollar exchange, but you can lower your tax by giving to charities. In fact, it is advisable if your taxable income is in a higher tax bracket.

(unemployment and welfare is the purple slice - 11.79%)

800px-Fy2007spendingbycategory.png

You truly will be a good President, Colonel. OK, lets say $100 of my taxes go to welfare instead of the children I wanted it to go to. So now I get $35 back if I contribute $100 to a charity. Choose any numbers you like. I do not have the choice of where it goes and when it gets confiscated and I cannot get it back by contributing to a charity

VERMONT! I Reject Your Reality...and Substitute My Own!

Gary And Alla

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Ukraine
Timeline
Posted
The amount of taxation collected is irrelevant. It has been shown empirically that individuals will economize their wages better than any government will. Incentive matters.

Tahoma, if you want to help the children, then I applaud your generosity. But, no individual should be forced to bear the cost of another individual's action by forcible taxation.

The idea that taxation is forced upon but wages are contractual is a fallacy, Matt. An individual is free to enter or leave this country, just like a job. By choosing to live here, you entering into a contract with the government.

Indiviuals are not free to enter this country, you ought to know that. And why must we "take it or leave it" I opt to change it. Return it to what it should be. Individual responsibility and indiviual liberty. I have full faith in my fellow man to be successful in life.

VERMONT! I Reject Your Reality...and Substitute My Own!

Gary And Alla

Filed: Country: Philippines
Timeline
Posted
You truly will be a good President, Colonel. OK, lets say $100 of my taxes go to welfare instead of the children I wanted it to go to. So now I get $35 back if I contribute $100 to a charity. Choose any numbers you like. I do not have the choice of where it goes and when it gets confiscated and I cannot get it back by contributing to a charity

Yes. Just like you don't have a direct choice on what types of planes the Pentagon buys. All part of living in a Republic. We do have choices even they aren't the choices you prefer.

Filed: AOS (apr) Country: Philippines
Timeline
Posted
Gary, you're not paying $10,000 in tax towards welfare.

It's not that high but you're excluding all the other costs that come with supporting out-of-wedlock births to the poor. Medical costs, free housing, food stamps, education, greater crime leading to higher social costs and the legal system. It goes far beyond mere welfare payments.

David & Lalai

th_ourweddingscrapbook-1.jpg

aneska1-3-1-1.gif

Greencard Received Date: July 3, 2009

Lifting of Conditions : March 18, 2011

I-751 Application Sent: April 23, 2011

Biometrics: June 9, 2011

Filed: AOS (apr) Country: Philippines
Timeline
Posted
ALC, some stuff the Republican say does make sense with these costs used to fund the poor.

I forgot to add that poverty tends to run intergenerationally so all the costs go into future generations as well. Studies have shown that the biggest indicator of poverty isn't level of education but whether the parents are married.

David & Lalai

th_ourweddingscrapbook-1.jpg

aneska1-3-1-1.gif

Greencard Received Date: July 3, 2009

Lifting of Conditions : March 18, 2011

I-751 Application Sent: April 23, 2011

Biometrics: June 9, 2011

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Ukraine
Timeline
Posted
You truly will be a good President, Colonel. OK, lets say $100 of my taxes go to welfare instead of the children I wanted it to go to. So now I get $35 back if I contribute $100 to a charity. Choose any numbers you like. I do not have the choice of where it goes and when it gets confiscated and I cannot get it back by contributing to a charity

Yes. Just like you don't have a direct choice on what types of planes the Pentagon buys. All part of living in a Republic. We do have choices even they aren't the choices you prefer.

Right. I do not purport to be the expert on the choice of planes. The common defense IS a constitutionally mandated responsibility of the government, supporting out of wedlock babies is not. I fully support the government doing what WE mandate it do and do not complain about that. They were doing it long before an income tax was instituted.

welfare and other entitlement programs are a government mandate on us to provide the government with an underclass of people dependent on the government. That was not the intent of the constitution.

VERMONT! I Reject Your Reality...and Substitute My Own!

Gary And Alla

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Thailand
Timeline
Posted
Indiviuals are not free to enter this country, you ought to know that. And why must we "take it or leave it" I opt to change it. Return it to what it should be. Individual responsibility and indiviual liberty. I have full faith in my fellow man to be successful in life.

Gary, your extreme form of libertarian "Individual responsibility and individual liberty" is only one half of "what it should be".

The entire premise of our Constitution and form of government is that there is an inherent balance to be sought between individual and collective freedoms, and individual and collective responsibilities. It is NOT all about the individual. The framers understood that it is necessary to protect the commons and the "general welfare" of the state while at the same time not abrogating individual liberties. The right of governments to tax is often where that rubber hits the road. There are many aspects of public policy that you or I may disagree with. For example, avowed pacifists are opposed in principle to any military expenditures, a far larger part of their tax burden than welfare payments are. And yet, pacifists pay for the Pentagon's budget just as you pay for welfare.

You are free to disagree with public welfare. Oppose it! Vote against it. Run for office. But the collective public through democratic means has voted to have such a public policy and to pay for it from general tax revenues.

Regarding Steve's earlier claim that those who don't like it here should just leave the country, well of course that's silly. Steve -- think about it for a moment, you know better than that!

Posted
Indiviuals are not free to enter this country, you ought to know that. And why must we "take it or leave it" I opt to change it. Return it to what it should be. Individual responsibility and indiviual liberty. I have full faith in my fellow man to be successful in life.

It is NOT all about the individual.

There is no such thing as collective freedoms, or collective responsibilities.

These are abstractions that are intangible. Only individuals have responsibilities as only individuals are capable of action.

That is why there is such a divide in politics; intangible nonexistent metaphors cannot be quantified.

21FUNNY.gif
 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...