I-130, Question Number 17

[chrissiemissie 0]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

[Beth/ Paris Heart 2]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

YES, list your name there. That is a tricky one, but yes as mention, list your name.

[chrissiemissie 0]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

YES, list your name there. That is a tricky one, but yes as mention, list your name.

perfect! thank you so much for your input! everyone here is so helpful!!

[Chris Me lil D 17]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

The question says:

C. Information about your alien relative (continued)

____________________________________________________________

17. List husband/wife and all children of your relative.

(Name) (Date of Birth) (Country of Birth) (Relationship)

The answer:

crissie or missie (the beneficiary)

The petitioner (applicant) files the I-130, so he/she lists the beneficiary - the NOT US citizen / foreigner (however you can understand it better)!!!

Good luck

Edited May 9, 2009 by Chris and Ani

[Beth/ Paris Heart 2]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

The question says:

C. Information about your alien relative (continued)

____________________________________________________________

17. List husband/wife and all children of your relative.

(Name) (Date of Birth) (Country of Birth) (Relationship)

The answer:

crissie or missie (the beneficiary)

The petitioner (applicant) files the I-130, so he/she lists the beneficiary - the NOT US citizen / foreigner (however you can understand it better)!!!

Good luck

Look at the example form, under Example forms. If your the wife/petitioner and your filing for your husband the beneficiary, your name go in lines 17.

http://www.visajourney.com/examples/INS-Form-I-130.pdf

Notice on the form, the Petioner is the same name as on line 17.

Edited May 9, 2009 by Paris Heart

[chrissiemissie 0]

i think i agree with paris. seems redundant, but it's the only way it makes sense: i'm the wife of my alien relative. thank you everyone!

[pushbrk 13,133]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

The question says:

C. Information about your alien relative (continued)

____________________________________________________________

17. List husband/wife and all children of your relative.

(Name) (Date of Birth) (Country of Birth) (Relationship)

The answer:

crissie or missie (the beneficiary)

The petitioner (applicant) files the I-130, so he/she lists the beneficiary - the NOT US citizen / foreigner (however you can understand it better)!!!

Good luck

This is dead wrong again. The husband or wife listed in 17 for an I-130 is the petitioner. The "alien relative" is the beneficiary.

May I suggest you refrain from answering questions about filling out forms until you learn how yourself. You're 0 for 2 in one day with one OP.

[chrissiemissie 0]

i wasn't replying to the question, it was my question/thread and i'm just trying to confirm an answer...?

but now this is confusing. pushbrk you say paris heart and the example form is incorrect?

[chrissiemissie 0]

i wasn't replying to the question, it was my question/thread and i'm just trying to confirm an answer...?

but now this is confusing. pushbrk you say paris heart and the example form is incorrect?

SCRATCH THAT! i see what pushbrk is saying and who he's talking to.

[Beth/ Paris Heart 2]

i wasn't replying to the question, it was my question/thread and i'm just trying to confirm an answer...?

but now this is confusing. pushbrk you say paris heart and the example form is incorrect?

SCRATCH THAT! i see what pushbrk is saying and who he's talking to.

pssssttttt, Paris Heart and example 100% correct. Pushbrk answered same question for me when i posted this many, many months ago.

Edited May 10, 2009 by Paris Heart

[Chris Me lil D 17]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

The question says:

C. Information about your alien relative (continued)

____________________________________________________________

17. List husband/wife and all children of your relative.

(Name) (Date of Birth) (Country of Birth) (Relationship)

The answer:

crissie or missie (the beneficiary)

The petitioner (applicant) files the I-130, so he/she lists the beneficiary - the NOT US citizen / foreigner (however you can understand it better)!!!

Good luck

This is dead wrong again. The husband or wife listed in 17 for an I-130 is the petitioner. The "alien relative" is the beneficiary.

May I suggest you refrain from answering questions about filling out forms until you learn how yourself. You're 0 for 2 in one day with one OP.

: oops : Please, excuse me... very tired, I'm not talking anymore... sorry again for my second confusion crissiemissie, and thanks again to pushbrk for right answer...

pushbrk, that's why you're here, to give the right answer rite after someone like me screwed

going to bed now, it's 2.15 am, sleepy, tired of this process, have a good night fellow friends, forgive me my mistakes

[Beth/ Paris Heart 2]

this is a dumb question, i know, but here goes:

i'm filing out the I-130 for my husband the beneficiary. for question number 17 "List husband/wife and all children of your relative": do i need to list myself (his wife)as one of his relatives. or do i not, since i'm filing the form as his wife.

The question says:

C. Information about your alien relative (continued)

____________________________________________________________

17. List husband/wife and all children of your relative.

(Name) (Date of Birth) (Country of Birth) (Relationship)

The answer:

crissie or missie (the beneficiary)

The petitioner (applicant) files the I-130, so he/she lists the beneficiary - the NOT US citizen / foreigner (however you can understand it better)!!!

Good luck

This is dead wrong again. The husband or wife listed in 17 for an I-130 is the petitioner. The "alien relative" is the beneficiary.

May I suggest you refrain from answering questions about filling out forms until you learn how yourself. You're 0 for 2 in one day with one OP.

: oops : Please, excuse me... very tired, I'm not talking anymore... sorry again for my second confusion crissiemissie, and thanks again to pushbrk for right answer...

pushbrk, that's why you're here, to give the right answer rite after someone like me screwed

going to bed now, it's 2.15 am, sleepy, tired of this process, have a good night fellow friends, forgive me my mistakes

These forms an be so confusing, and makes this process even more over whelming.

Sweet dreams.